|
THE BT-COOL AVENUES CAMPUS HUSTINGS
2001
Back To (Good)
Old Economy
Tech slowdown be damned. Recruiters aren't
letting up on the hunt for talent, even if it means luring 20-somethings
with eye-popping salaries. Presenting the best of the deals at B-school
Bazaar 2001.
Fine, Infosys missed the game at the IIMs
this placement season. But V.V.S. Nathan isn't complaining. On Day Zero
(the first day of recruitments at B-school campuses), the 25-year-old, IIM-A
grad landed a job with the London office of Lehman Brothers. The package
offered to Nathan: a cool $225,000 (Rs 1 crore-plus) a year. Nathan, who
interned with the firm in New York, is but one of the 24 that Lehman
snapped up from four Indian campuses (IIM-A, -B, -C, and XLRI) at
comparable salaries.
PLACEMENT
2001 |
Institutes:
IIM-A, IIM-B, IIM-C, IIM-L, XLRI, SPJIMS, JBIMS, IIM-K, IMT, IIM-I, FMS,
MDI, NITIE, XIMB, IIFT
Total number of companies
Visiting Campus: |
209 |
Average number of campus
Visits Per Company: |
2.63 |
Total offers per company: |
7.02 |
|
For B-schools fearing the worst in the wake
of the dotcom meltdown, 2001 turned out to be a dream year. A total of 209
companies made a beeline to the top 14 B-schools, making an average of
seven offers each during their 549 visits to the campuses. The big news?
Old-line companies were back in vogue. While Placements 2000 saw a lot of
grads opt out of jobshops (tents at B-schools where the interviews are
done) and head straight into VC offices, there were few dotcom wannabes
this time round. So much so that not one of the graduate students BT-Cool
Avenues spoke to wanted to venture out on his own at least in the next
five years. Instead, they seemed more interested in lucrative careers in
investment banking, consulting, finance, and marketing. ''(The graduates)
are still interested in technology companies, but only those with a
revenue stream,'' says a recruiter with a technology firm.
Day
One at IIM-A |
9:30 am: IIM-A's red brick campus is buzzing
with activity. Fresh graduates in suits and ties are dashing between
interviews, looking nervous or thrilled variously. Juniors (a.k.a. ones)
with walkie-talkies try to co-ordinate the mad rush.
9:55 am: The jobshops (huge white and blue
interview tents) are full of recruiters. We spot V.V.S. Nathan, one of the
star grads, who has bagged a $225,000 job with Lehman Brothers in New
York. My gaze shifts to Rohithari Rajan, who's just finished his HLL
interview. Before I can buttonhole the tense young man, a serious-looking
exec catches up with Rajan. They shake hands. The HLL Director has just
offered Rajan his first job.
12:30 pm: I find Ronnie Ganguly serving a
glass of water to his classmate Deepti Raval. Ronnie, who's already been
signed up by i2 Technologies on Day Zero, is now acting as a 'flunkie' to
Deepti, who is yet to get a placement. Ronnie's job? Help destress Deepti.
1:00 pm: Arthur Andersen has finished its
recruitment, and is taking out its new employees out for lunch.
6:45 pm: 15 students of the 210 passouts are
yet to be placed. There is tension in the air.
Midnight: Hurray! All the grads have been
placed. Tomorrow will truly be a new day.
--Roshni Jayakar
|
As always, though, the top recruiters made
most of the kills. For instance, the top five recruiters picked up more
than a fifth of the outgoing batches, and by the time the next top five
were through, a third of Class 2001 at the 14 institutes had been cleaned
out. With so many companies chasing a relatively handful of B-school
cream, average salaries shot up. The highest Indian salary offered touched
a staggering Rs 14.5 lakh at IIM Kozhikode. Thanks to bulge-bracket banks
like Lehman and Goldman Sachs, dollar salaries soared too, touching a new
high of $225,000 at IIM-A and -c, although the average at the two
institutes was well under $100,000.
Foreign postings were a big draw with the
grads. At IIM-C, 84 overseas offers were made, while a and b pulled in
70-plus each. Even IMT-Ghaziabad managed five such offers. The star
overseas recruiters: i2 Technologies, Lehman Brothers, BristleCone, JP
Morgan, iMaritime, and Hewitt. ''Money isn't everything,'' says Neil Barve
of IIM-C and a Lehman recruit. ''I had always wanted to work on Wall
Street with Lehman Brothers. In that sense it's a dream come true.''
That Class 2001 was chasing more than just
money was evident from the way it went about sifting through the recruiter
pile. The most important criterion in accepting or rejecting an offer was
the job profile; more and more wannabe managers wanted to know what they
would be doing once on the job. Says Rahul Varma, hr Manager, Accenture
(formerly Andersen Consulting): ''A few of our recruits passed up on
overseas offers to join us, because our work profile was more
interesting.''
Consultancy: The Gravy Train
Functionwise
Highest salaries
Function:
SYSTEMS
Salary: USD 160,000+
Company: McKenna
Function: INVESTMENT
BANKING
Salary: USD 225,000
Company: Lehman Brothers
Function: CONSULTING
Salary: Rs 1,400,000
Company: A.T. Kearney
Function: MARKETING
Salary: Rs 800,000
Company: HLL
Function: Finance/Banking
Salary: Rs 1,450,000
Company: GE Capital
Most visible recruiters
» ICICI
»
i2 Technologies
»
Lehman Brothers
»
McKinsey
»
BCG
»
HSBC
»
Accenture
»
GE Capital
»
HLL
»
Citibank
Most preferred India jobs
» McKinsey
»
BCG
»
A.T. Kearney
»
Accenture
»
i2 Technologies
»
Cognizant
»
ICICI
»
Monitor Consulting
»
Arthur Andersen
»
HLL
Most preferred offshore jobs
»
Goldman Sachs
»
BCG
»
MSDW
»
Lehman Bros
»
i2 Technologies
»
JP Morgan
»
Deutsche Bank
»
iNautix
»
Deloitte Con.
»
McKenna Group
Most important factors in choosing a job
offer
» Job profile
»
Growth opportunities
»
Reputation
»
Salary
»
Location
»
Training
Most important factors in selecting a
campus
» Alumni performance
»
Class/student profile
»
Faculty profile
»
Curriculum
»
Recruiters profile
Most preferred campuses for recruitment
» IIM-A
»
IIM-C
»
IIM-B
»
IIM-L
»
XLRI
»
FMS
»
Bajaj
»
S.P. Jain
»
IIM-I
»
MDI
»
IIM-K
|
B-Schools
Infoporn:
How They Stacked Up
|
B-Schools
Infoporn:
Who Opted For What
|
Overseas
Offers
|
Hi-profile consulting jobs continued to be a
hot favourite on the campuses, although this year there was plenty of
competition from Wall Street I-banks. Nearly 27 per cent of the class at
IIM-A, -B and -L opted for a career in consultancy. Michael Porter's
company, Monitor, made its debut on Placements 2001. It short-listed about
10 candidates from across the IIMs and XLRI, although it finally settled
for the XLRI grad, paying him a hefty Rs 13 lakh per annum, besides a
house in Mumbai. Other leading recruiters were Accenture, McKinsey, A.T.
Kearney, KPMG, PWC, and Arthur Andersen. Says Janmejaya Sinha, Recruiting
Director, BCG: "We have found students here to be of the highest
calibre, and their talent helps our practice greatly."
Among IT consulting companies (yes, they are
still sought after), i2 Technologies was a clear favourite, followed by
Deloitte Consulting, which made six offers at IIM-B. i2, on the other
hand, made more offers at IIM-C and -L (15 and 10, respectively), probably
because of the high engineering mix at these institutes.
Finance: Making A Return
After a few seasons in the wilderness (blame
it on the dotcoms), Finance was back on track. During Placements 2000, the
sector had to share the spotlight with marketing, venture capital firms,
it and consultancy. But this year it only had consultancy firms to joust
with. At IIM-B, nearly 40 per cent of the class chose finance and banking,
and at IIM-A and -C, almost a third. Sure, the markets aren't booming, but
with the industry major players planning an aggressive push into retail
banking and insurance, there was huge demand for talent. For instance,
ICICI made offers to 67 passouts (excluding IIM-A), HSBC more than 50, and
Citibank made 41-plus.
Like in consulting, there were a few
debutantes in banking and finance. Barclays Capital and Capital One (a
leading credit card player in the US) showed up for the first time, with
the latter making six offers at IIM-B. The filtering down effect was
visible in this sector too, much to the delight of B-schools such as
Jamnalal Bajaj, S.P. Jain, and XLRI. Just another reminder that money, do
what you may, never goes out of fashion.
Dotcom and IT: Lying Low
The biggest surprise at Placements 2001 was
Infosys dropping out of recruitment at the last minute. Initially, it
created quite a scare, but by the end of Day 1 it was clear that Infosys
wasn't being missed. Some of Infy's peers such as HCL Technologies, Ramco
Systems, and Polaris Software, were undaunted. HCL Tech not only recruited
from the IIMs, but also Bajaj, FMS, and S.P. Jain. Ramco and Polaris
focused more on the second rung. There were some first-timers too,
including BristleCone, Seranova, ebiz Consulting, iMaritime, and Cognizant
Technology. The only internet companies to be seen on the prowl at all
were the biggies like Mphasis, Mindtree, and Planetasia. Guess what,
though? The recruits were for support services, not marketing or strategy.
Marketing: A Lot of Hardsell
Until a few years ago, they were at the top
of the recruiters heap. But at Placements 2001, marketing companies had to
bend backwards to lure the best minds. That meant, one, having to increase
their pay offers and, two, settle for the sub-60 rankers at the IIMs. At
IIM-C, a bare 12 per cent of the class opted for
marketing/sales/advertising; at IIM-B it was no better at 14 per cent,
while -A and -L still found a fifth of the class each taking the bait. IMT,
a breeding ground for marketers, saw a third of its Class 2001 sign up for
a future in the sector. The new haven for marketers could turn out be IIFT,
where almost half the class fell for the hardseller's pitch.
First-time Recruiters |
Name: Marakon Associates
Function: Consulting
Institute: IIM-A
|
Name: Stern Stewart & Co.
Function: Consulting
Institute: IIM-C
|
Name: Orbit-e Consulting
Function: Consulting
Institute: IIM-C
|
Name: Dresdner Kleinwort Wasserstein
Function: I-bank
Institute: IIM-C
|
Name: Handelsbanken
Function: I-bank
Institute: IIM-C
|
Name: Capital One
Function: Finance
Institute: IIM-C
|
Name: Barclays Capital
Function: Finance
Institute: IIM-C
|
Name: Indocean Chase
Function: Venture Capitalist
Institute: IIM-A
|
Name: Cognizant Technology
Function: IT
Institute: IIMs B,C, & L, and XLRI |
Top Dollar Salaries |
Top
Rupee Salaries |
Company |
Salary ($) - 01 |
Company |
Salary (INR) |
Lehman Brothers |
225,000 |
GE Capital |
1,450,000 |
Deutsche Bank Global |
186,000 |
A.T. Kearney |
1,400,000 |
McKenna |
160,000 |
Monitor |
1,300,000 |
JP Morgan |
150,000 |
BCG |
1,200,000 |
MMG |
130,000 |
McKinsey |
1,200,000 |
MSDW |
130,000 |
Accenture |
950,000 |
Barclays Capital |
125,000 |
Arthur Andersen |
850,000 |
Capital One |
110,000 |
Cognizant Technologies |
800,000 |
NIIT |
90,000 |
HLL |
800,000 |
Deloitte Consulting |
80,000 |
ICICI |
800,000 |
Fatwire Corporation |
77,000 |
Information provided by third parties.
Not confirmed with companies. |
i2 Technologies |
70,000 |
|
|
Information provided by third parties.
Not confirmed with companies. |
|
|
After more than 27 offers and visits to nine
campuses, FMCG giant Hindustan Lever managed to rope in 27 grads (exlcuding
IIM-A). But the slowdown in the sector took its toll on the recruiters.
Nestle, for instance, hired just four. While that may be the marketer's
loss, the Class of 2001 leaves the campuses much richer. Predictions are
that 2002 will see more of the big guns (SSB; Donaldson, Lufkin &
Jenrette; Bear Sterns; and Chase) make their passage to India. Looks like
the grossly overpaid MBA isn't about to get any cheaper.
IIMs vs Ivy League
Let's get something straight right away: IIMs
are tougher to get into. Just five in 1,000 applicants to the Indian
Institutes of Management make it, while 13 out of every 100 applicants get
through at Harvard. It's no surprise, then, that top Indian and foreign
companies are falling over each other to hire the best brains. Consider:
Like last year's, Day Zero of placement at IIM-A saw premier Wall Street
bulge-bracket banks like Goldman Sachs, Lehman Brothers, Morgan Stanley
Dean Witter, Deutsche Bank Global, and JP Morgan queue up. Of course,
there were top consultancy companies too, such as McKinsey, BCG, MMG, and
at Kearney, among others. What's striking is that these are the very
companies who make Day Zero at US b-schools too. Besides, pay packets at
the IIMs are inching up year after year; this year's top dollar offer of
$225,000 from Lehman Brothers is world-class by any standards, and neither
are the job offers restricted to their operations in India. More
imporantly, the reason why the biggies keep coming back is their good
experience with IIM alumni. But Ivy League-like communication skills and
slick self-marketing is something that IIMs still seem unable to teach
their students.
|