During the mid-1970s, when Prime Minister
Indira Gandhi dismissed criticism about the levels of corruption
with an airy ''Corruption is a global phenomenon'', people were
shocked.Not any more. Things have come a long way from 1964 when
Punjab chief minister Pratap Singh Kairon was forced to resign following
charges of nepotism. Or even the 1989 elections which Rajiv Gandhi
lost because of the Bofors scandal.
Corruption in India is inevitable, given the
demand-supply gaps, a highly regulated economic system,and lack
of transparency.
Anti-corruption legislation dates back to 1946
when the Delhi Special Police Act was passed. A year later came
the Prevention of Corruption Act. The Central Vigilance Commission
was set up in 1964 as an advisory body. It got constitutional status
in 1998. However, there have been four futile attempts to enact
a legislation to set up a Lokpal (ombudsman) at the Centre. There
been much success in attempts to improve transparency in government,
barring Rajasthan, the only state to have passed a Right to Information
Act. n
-Seetha
Inspector Raj: The Great
Survivor
The licence-quota
raj may be over but the inspector raj still reigns supreme. Industry
may have been delicensed in 1991 but is still highly regulated.
Each industrial unit is visited by between 40 and 60 inspectors
in the course of a month. The following is an illustrative, and
not an exhaustive, list of inspectors. There may be several more
inspectors depending on the kind of manufacturing activity. As a
result, small and medium enterprises are forced to shell out bribes
to these officers. Or else face harassment.
-Seetha
MINISTRY
|
NO. OF INSPECTORS
|
WORK DON
|
Industryi |
5
|
Check registration, inventories,
tax payment quality control, safety equipment |
Home |
2
|
Check fire protection facilities
and compliance with Explosives Act |
Planning & Statistics |
1
|
Collect data on production, manpower,
manhours utilized and lost |
Finance |
12
|
Five for income tax (three of them
checking the same records for three different departments);
seven from excise department |
Separate Revenue |
5
|
Enforcement, verification and recovery
of sales tax; enrolment of professional tax; weights and measures |
Revenue Department (State government)
tax |
1
|
Registration of professional |
Labour |
8
|
Checking compliance with different
labour laws, checking the same records |
Municipal Corporations
Power & Energy
Health & Family Welfare |
2
1
2
|
Municipal bye laws electricity connections
hygiene health |
Urban Affairs & Employment |
1
|
Sanitation |
Environment & Forests |
2
|
Pollution control |
Communications |
1
|
Telecom facilities |
Local Self-government |
2
|
Octoi and mass raids |
Food & Drug Administration |
1
|
Safety standards |
Experiments
In E-Governance
To
the people they serve, e-governance projects have helped eliminate
the great Indian wait. All over India it is common for villagers
to travel to faraway government offices at district headquarters
to submit applications, meet officials, and obtain copies of public
records. Once at the government office, the official, record, or
information is hard to find, often forcing repeated visits, harassment
and additional expense, not just because of another trip but the
inevitable corruption involved in handing over records. The government
clerk or officer-in-charge, like the all-powerful Block Development
Officer works from yellowing stacks of carelessly stacked files
and most importantly, has a monopoly over the information and records.
All this has led to a horrendous lack of transparency and inefficiency
in the world's largest democracy. But it doesn't have to be that
way. Here are three initiatives that show how:
GYANDOOT. Dhar district, Madhya Pradesh.
Winner of an international award, Gyandoot is a Rs 26-lakh intranet,
conceptualised and implemented in just 51 days. Dhar is part of
the soyabean and cotton belt and handles transactions worth over
Rs 400 crore a year. Gyandoot serves as a government-to-citizen
e-commerce platform for five lakh people. It connects the district
headquarters to 21 multimedia kiosks or rural cyber cafes, called
soochnalayas. Each soochnalaya serves between 20 to 30 villages,
which is between 20,000-30,000 people.
The services available include: daily commodity
marketing information including prices and volumes; copies of land
records, bank loan forms and maps; online registration of applications
for income, domicile and other certificates-e-mails in Hindi are
sent through the soochnalaya when the certificate is ready; and
redressal of grievances. An e-mail reply is assured within seven
days. The project is to be replicated in all 44 districts by mid
2002.
-Ashutosh Sinha
TWIN CITIES NETWORK SERVICES. Hyderabad,
Andhra Pradesh
Launched in 2000, the project provides a one-stop online shop for
18 services, from issuing licences to paying property tax. It has
19 centres citywide. Now renamed E-seva, Twin Cities Intelligent
Network Services will be extended to other parts of the state, first
in February 2002 when centres will be opened in Ranga Reddy district
adjoining Hyderabad. These will be eventually integrated with the
Andhra Pradesh portal (www.aponline.com) to be launched in January
to facilitate 24x7 services. Central government departments are
being linked. Electronic payment of telephone bills started on December
1. All this cost Rs 6 crore; each centre costs around Rs 30 lakh.
However, the state government has managed to keep its own spending
down to just Rs 5 lakh for each centre, tying up with hardware and
software companies for the investment and maintenance of the centres.
-E. Kumar Sharma
ELECTRONIC LAND RECORD SYSTEMS. Karnataka,
Punjab, Andhra Pradesh
Farmers at the mercy of the village patwari (revenue official) for
their land records can now breathe easy in Andhra Pradesh, Punjab
and Karnataka. Andhra Pradesh's card (Computer-Aided Administration
of Registration Department) is the pioneering effort in registering
real-estate transactions. Starting with two centres in 1997, the
Rs 25-crore project now covers 239 offices and some 24 lakh transactions
have been registered till date. The registration process takes just
an hour, against three to four days earlier. Punjab took a leaf
out of Andhra's book and launched the prism (Punjab Registration
Information System Module) project. Instead of pleading with and
bribing the patwari for registration documents-needed when applying
for loans-farmers now pay Rs 10 and instantly get the necessary
documents. In Karnataka, thanks to the Bhoomi (land) project, most
of the 17 million land records have been put on the internet since
July 2000, at a cost of Rs 1.8 crore. Farmers now pay just Rs 15
for an instant printout of their papers, a far cry from the Rs 100-500
bribe they had to pay the patwari earlier. n
-E. Kumar Sharma & Venkatesha Babu
Five Bureaucrats Who Tried
HARSH
MANDER
1996: Commissioner, Bilaspur division, Madhya Pradesh
Now: Country Director ActionAid India
Born: 1955. Batch: 1980
In October 1996, Harsh Mander, then commissioner of the Bilaspur
division (now in Chhattisgarh), issued an order giving people the
right to information about supplies to and offtake from the Public
Distribution System (PDS). Almost half the foodgrain and sugar supplies
were found to have been siphoned off into the open market. Mander
then extended the scheme to the departments of public works, transport,
employment, and pollution.
S.R.
RAO
1995: Municipal Commissioner, Surat
Now: Chairman, Vizag Port Trust
Born: 1954. Batch: 1978
When S.R. Rao was sent to plague-ravaged Surat in May 1995, he was
given one brief: don't let this happen again. Rao divided the municipal
administration into six zones and delegated powers. Officers were
penalised for laxity. Senior officers supervised sweeping of the
streets.Unauthorised structures were demolished ruthlessly. Illegal
hawkers were told they would be allowed to ply their trade if they
kept their surroundings clean. Citizens groups were formed to ensure
cleanliness. Tax collection was tightened.
JAYKAR
JEROME
Commissioner, Bangalore Development Authority
Born: 1946. Batch: 1983
When Jaykar Jerome was given charge of the Bangalore Development
Authority (BDA) in 2000, it was a moribund and corruption-ridden
agency. Jerome toned up the administration and eliminated touts.
Today, BDA is sitting on a cash pile of Rs 297 crore, earned through
allotment of sites. ICRA has given the BDA a LAA (high safety) ranking
without any sovereign guarantees. The BDA is now constructing flyovers
and ring roads, technically the responsibility of the Bangalore
City Corporation.
R.
GOPALAKRISHNAN
Secretary to Chief Minister, Madhya Pradesh, and Mission Co-ordinator,
Rajiv Gandhi Mission
Born: 1955. Batch: 1979
The credit for Madhya Pradesh's developmental success story goes
not just to chief minister Digvijay Singh but equally to R Gopalakrishnan,
the sounding board and driving force of many of Singh's ideas. He
has conceptualised the entire employment guarantee scheme (EGS),
the Padhna-Badhna Andolan (Each One Teach One), and the watershed
development programmes. His interest in watershed schemes goes back
to the mid-1980s when, as Collector of Habua district, he initiated
water harvesting programmes.
ARUN
BHATIA
1999: Pune Municipal Commissioner
Now: Deputation to UNDP
Born: 1942. Batch: 1967
In his 34-year career, Arun Bhatia has been transferred 24 times.
Bhatia has a history of battling corruption. In 1982, as Collector
of Dhule district, he unearthed a multi-crore scandal in the Employment
Guarantee scheme. He also took action against multinational companies
for violations of the Drugs Act. As Mumbai Collector, he went after
prominent builders violating floor-space index regulations.
|