The
future of Indian stockmarkets and stock exchanges actually began
in November 1994. That was the year National Stock Exchange (NSE)
introduced screen-based trading across the country. Not only did
this make trading far more transparent, it ensured that trades in
India were done much the same way they were in other parts of the
world.
The country's premier exchange then, Bombay
Stock Exchange (BSE), had to perforce respond to this with a screen-based
trading system of its own. It managed to do so within the following
six months.
That the quality of this response wasn't very
good is evident in the fact that trading volumes on BSE fell behind
those on NSE within a year, and have lagged behind ever since. But
that's another story, for another forum.
The fate of India's regional exchanges has
been worse: they have increasingly become irrelevant in a scenario
where it is possible for an investor even in a small town to trade
on NSE.
Statistically speaking, by 2000-01, NSE accounted
for nearly one-half of trading volume of all the exchanges in the
country put together.
If 1994 marked the first chapter in the future
of Indian stockmarkets, then July 2001 did the second. The month
saw the introduction of a rolling settlement system for major stocks,
as well as the institution of a uniform weekly settlement cycle
for all the other stocks.
Apart from rendering regional exchanges even
more irrelevant-one of their touted benefits was the arbitrage opportunities
they presented-this move was a prophylactic against payments crises
in the future.
Remember, it was the unwillingness of Securities
and Investment Board of India (SEBI) to introduce rolling settlement
in time that considerably added to the seriousness of the stockmarket
crisis of March 2001.
Today, only four of the exchanges-NSE, BSE,
CSE and DSE-matter for investors; there's insignificant trading,
or no trading at all, in other exchanges. The cash market trading
volume of NSE now averages 63 per cent of the aggregate trading
volume of these four exchanges. BSE averaged 35 per cent.
There are enough signs that CSE and DSE will
be forced to down their shutters in the not-too-distant future as
their operating levels-less than 2 per cent of cash trades-result
in huge revenue deficits. Worse, neither exchange has the money
to upgrade its it infrastructure, a key requirement for any exchange
that wants to prepare for the future.
What is the future of Indian stock exchanges?
First, only two exchanges may be expected to survive. The lead National
Stock Exchange has gained over BSE will only increase in the coming
years. Already, NSE is perceived to be more investor-friendly than
BSE by most of the investors.
Second, derivatives trading will have a significant
positive impact on the volume of cash-trading. The foundations for
this were laid by NSE as far back as 1996. However, it was only
in June 2000 that SEBI cleared trading in derivatives.
The clutch of instruments that have been introduced
since-index futures, index options, options in select individual
stocks, and futures in select stocks-and the rapidity with which
they have been accepted, bode well for the markets.
They also indicate that the Indian stockmarket
is ready for the next big leap-derivatives are important constituents
of trading volumes on major exchanges across the world.
The fact that NSE is a preferred derivatives
destination-on December 6, while the National Stock Exchange logged
derivatives trading of Rs 956 crore, Bombay Stock Exchange did only
Rs 8 crore, less than one per cent of the former-is just another
reason why I think it could soon become the only exchange that matters
in India.
In the future, the trading volumes of a stock
exchange in its cash and derivatives markets will increasingly feed
off each other in a synergistic relationship.
Investors seeking to building up positions
in the cash market will be able to hedge them using derivatives
and those building up positions in derivatives will be able to do
the reverse.
|