The concept
of the family-owned business is as old as that of commercial enterprise
itself. Yet, popular myth, which informs the opinions of some people,
deems these enterprises as capricious, short-lived and small. None
of this is by and large true. Worldwide- as in India-family-owned
businesses have survived multiple generations, have grown to become
multi-billion dollar corporations, and have continued to make significant
contributions to the economy.
It will surprise many readers to learn that
the oldest family-owned business still in operation is the Japanese
construction company Kongo Gumi, founded in 578 ad. It is currently
managed by the 40th generation! Kongo Gumi is no one-off exception.
There are more than 100 family businesses that are more than 200
years old. Many family businesses have attained considerable size
too: The largest company in the world, Wal-Mart, is a family business.
Some of the largest businesses in the world, and in India, are family
businesses. Worldwide, there are around 200 family businesses with
annual revenues of at least $2 billion (Rs 8,800 crore) each.
Family-owned businesses play a crucial role
in the economy of most countries. Much of the retail trade, the
small-scale industry, and the service sector is run by family businesses.
Worldwide, family-managed businesses employ half the world's workforce
and generate well over half the world's GDP. In the United States,
24 million family businesses employ 62 per cent of the workforce
and account for 64 per cent of the GDP. In India, it is estimated
that 95 per cent of the registered firms are family businesses.
In India, family-owned businesses have played
and will continue to play a central role in the growth and development
of the country. In the next few paragraphs, I shall outline why
I believe that Indian family businesses have been and will continue
to be key drivers of the economy, and what changes these businesses
need to undertake to continue to succeed.
Most commercial enterprises are born as family-owned
and family-managed businesses. A large number of family-owned and
managed enterprises remain that way-planets in the family-centric
planetary system. A smaller number, on the other hand, need access
to public equity capital and in the process become non-family owned.
Others could remain family-owned but professionally-managed, either
due to lack of interest on the part of the family or due to practical
necessity. There is, unfortunately, no Rubicon that differentiates
a business owned and managed by the family from a business that
isn't so. Family ownership and management versus non-family ownership
and management is a continuum; and arguably, some firms lie in the
grey area of this continuum. For the sake of simplicity I shall
assume that firms where a family (or, perhaps, a few families) exerts
significant influence over the firm's strategy and its destiny are
family-owned; and, firms where family members-unless professionally
qualified-do not hold executive positions, are professionally-managed.
Family businesses were an integral part of
the Indian freedom movement. Firms were created specifically
to pursue ideals such as import substitution and economic freedom
from the colonists |
Family businesses have existed in India since
as long ago as recorded history. With time, the contribution of
family businesses has gone beyond simply paying taxes and employing
people. During the last 100 years or so, Indian family businesses
have made significant contributions in three areas:
The freedom movement: Family businesses
were an integral part of the Indian freedom movement. In the early
years, firms were created specifically to pursue ideals such as
import substitution and economic freedom from the colonists. The
Godrej enterprise, for instance, was started by Ardeshir Godrej
in 1897 with a vision to promote India's economic freedom.
Spirit of entrepreneurship: Family businesses
have done an excellent job of keeping the spirit of enterprise alive
especially through the 40 years of quasi-socialism. The spirit survived
onerous taxation and repeated government attempts to undo supposed
'concentration' of economic power. Today, as India competes in an
increasingly globalised economy, family businesses are playing a
major role in turning the engines of growth.
Philanthropy: Lastly, Indian family
businesses have played a significant role in giving back to the
community. To the average Indian, names of large Indian business
groups are synonymous with philanthropic efforts in education, environment,
health, culture and heritage conservation. And it is not just the
large groups that have been active-numerous foundations engaged
in charitable work are supported by scores of small and medium family
enterprises.
Also, family businesses in India (and elsewhere)
have several inherent advantages that provide them with unique strengths:
Trust lowers transaction costs: It is
a well-documented fact that 'trust' lowers transaction costs, corruption,
and bureaucracy. Trust can be a source of significant competitive
advantage to a family business. In India, family businesses have
often revolved around large joint families. Joel Kotkin has documented
the families of Palanpuri Jains from western India, who have established
commercial colonies in diamond centres as dispersed as Tel Aviv,
Antwerp, Mumbai, London and New York. Today these families account
for roughly 50 per cent of all purchases of rough diamonds in the
world.
Family businesses that can clearly distinguish
between family interest and company interest, and make hard
decisions when the two are in conflict, will emerge winners |
Small, nimble, and quick to react: Family
businesses, both small and large, tend to be quick to react to threats
as well as opportunities. There are fewer decision-making gates
and constituencies to deal with. Very often, the survival of the
family depends on the survival of the business. This results in
sharp and decisive action in the face of threats that could be potentially
fatal for the business.
Information as a source of advantage: Many
family businesses are private enterprises. This is an advantage
since a private company can see the strengths and weaknesses of
its public competitor and act accordingly while the converse is
not true. Further, private companies can have private strategies
to which analysts and the competition are not privy. And, private
family businesses have the freedom to pursue truly long-term strategies
that are not constrained by 'quarterly reporting'.
However, continued success for the family businesses
is not guaranteed. I believe that family businesses that prosper
on to 2020 will have three clear characteristics:
- The highest standards of corporate governance;
- Modern management and technology; and
- Long-term, performance-focussed strategies.
Corporate governance and the family business:
Family businesses that can clearly distinguish between family
interest and company interest-and make hard decisions when the two
are in conflict-will emerge winners. Good corporate governance in
family business should promote the long-term good of the company
and not necessarily of the majority or minority stakeholders. It
is well understood that neglecting or bypassing the interests of
stakeholders like shareholders, employees, vendors, customers, consumers,
the government, or the society at large is likely to adversely affect
the long-term interests of the company. Good corporate governance
entails a strong performance ethic framework leading to a true meritocracy.
It is essential for family businesses to acknowledge the distinction
between ownership and management: Only qualified family members
should be engaged in the management of the business and there should
be clear roles and rules of engagement for both owner-managers and
professional managers. Above all, the perception of fairness should
reign. Prof. John L. Ward, an international expert on family businesses
at the Kellogg School of Management, confirms that family businesses
with "effective governance practices are more likely to do
strategic planning and to do succession planning. On an average,
they grow faster and live longer".
Modern management and technology: In
line with my thoughts on performance ethic, I believe that family
businesses should strive to hire the best people, and be capable
of recruiting and retaining outside professional talent. In a competitive
world this is a sine qua non. The inability to professionalise management
can lead to family businesses being shut out of sectors that require
complex management, scale and constant technological improvements.
Family businesses should be willing to seek and acquire assistance
when required. The 'not invented here syndrome' and ego must not
stand in the way improving the organisation's capabilities. The
successful family businesses will seek collaboration-be it with
consultants or with other firms-to imbibe new strategies and skills.
In addition, family businesses will need to constantly seek and
embrace the latest technology and productivity enhancing techniques
such as improvements in information technology, communications,tqm,
Six Sigma, et al.
Long-term, performance-focussed strategies:
I mentioned earlier that one of the potential strengths of family
businesses is its ability to draw up plans focussed on creating
long-term value. However, there has been a sea change in what truly
long-term strategy is and what is often falsely deemed as long-term
strategy. Family businesses tend to build 'long-term strategies'
that assume that today's business model and assets will not be valuable
tomorrow. Long-term strategy goes beyond survival: it means investing
in technical capabilities, employees, R&D, brand building, and
acquisition of customer knowledge. As I mentioned earlier, many
family businesses are privately held and are not susceptible to
the pressures of quarterly results. A family business can choose
to measure its success in terms of years and decades, not merely
quarter by quarter. The smarter ones, I believe, will use this as
an advantage to create truly long-term strategies, which may not
necessarily yield results in the short-term.
Clearly, for Indian family businesses, the
path to sustained excellence is one that requires willingness to
change, learn and excel. However, there is no doubt that Indian
family businesses will be able to make the transition and, thus,
play a vital role in contributing to India's development and make
India an economic power to reckon with by the year 2020.
|