|  
             The 
              year just gone by has been a good year for Indian business. Almost 
              every sector of industry has grown impressively, and this in spite 
              of spoilsports like higher global oil prices and a poor monsoon. 
              Of course, the full impact of the latter will be felt over the next 
              few months but still India Inc. should have few complaints about 
              2004. The hurrahs with which the stock market rang out 2004 are 
              good enough proof of that. 
             Yet, as we begin 2005 with cheery optimism, 
              corporate India will be remiss if it doesn't heed an important lesson 
              that 2004 (or rather the last two months of the year) brought to 
              it. I am obviously referring to the fight between the two Ambani 
              brothers. Mukesh and Anil Ambani's tussle for ownership of the Rs 
              99,000-crore Reliance business group may be the most visible and 
              high-profile fight that has ever taken place in any Indian business 
              family. Don't blame the media for that-after all, the fight first 
              spilled out into the open after a short sound bite that the elder 
              of the two Ambanis chose to give to a TV channel in the middle of 
              last November, and ever since it has been fought by the two largely 
              through the media. 
             The use of the media as the primary medium 
              for a fight by two of the wealthiest and most influential Indian 
              businessmen may seem unseemly, curious and even juvenile. And how 
              that fight will end is another matter and a subject of full-time 
              (at least for now) speculation among the media. But the more important 
              issues the fight has raised are all about corporate fairness. As 
              a new year begins, it may serve Indian businessmen well to heed 
              such a notion. So here's a pop quiz for Indian CEOs, promoters, 
              owner-managers and entrepreneurs. 
             Let's begin with a few simple questions: Do 
              your shareholders and stakeholders know who owns your company and 
              exactly how? Are those 'independent' directors on your company's 
              board really independent or are they all your own yes-men? Have 
              you been allotted shares in your company at a hefty discount that 
              your stakeholders are unaware of?  
             Should you want good corporate governance (my 
              apologies for using those last two words together-a phrase that 
              since November 2004 sounds numbingly clichéd), it's a no-brainer 
              what the answers to those questions should be. Yet, at India's largest 
              private sector corporation, the answers to all of those were all 
              wrong.  
             Through most of its three-decade-long existence, 
              Reliance and its founder Dhirubhai Ambani have been a source of 
              inspiration to hundreds of Indian businessmen, many of whom have 
              been so awed by their success and meteoric growth that they've strived 
              to follow that example. Now, 35 years after Dhirubhai founded the 
              business, the example that Reliance is setting is one that few will 
              want to follow. Let us hope 2005 becomes the Year of Corporate Fairness. 
               
             Have a great New Year! 
            Sanjoy Narayan 
           |