|
COVER STORY
The New CEO Centre
(cont.)
THE PEOPLE |
The New CEO Centre must be staffed
with people with unique skills as well as responsibilities, transcending everyday line
management.
CEO
Chief Strategy Officer
Chief Economic Officer
Chief Information Officer
Chief Finance Officer
Chief Technology Officer
Chief People Officer
Chief Coaching Officer
Chief Facilitation Officer
Chief Evaluation Officer
Chief Quality Officer
Chief Knowledge Officer
Chief Culture Officer |
IDENTITY-BUILDING. The second activity
that the CEO's office must use the conglomerate's vision, mission, and values as the basis
for is building a corporate identity. Without encroaching on the preserve of
business-unit-level brand management, the New CEO Centre must forge a persona that the
individual businesses can relate to when synergising with each other. Otherwise, the
benefits of being a collective entity will be lost. For instance, raising capital for the
conglomerate or group as a whole will no longer be possible. Nor will different units be
able to cash in on common resources like, say, brands or people.
Managing the external environment will become part of this
portfolio, too, since it is the corporate entity--and not individual businesses--that
exists as a unit in the customer's, the stakeholder's, and the policy-maker's perceptions.
Thus, the Corporate Centre of the Wipro Group--its Corporate Executive
Council--assiduously builds its corporate brand with precisely this objective, besides
orchestrating customer satisfaction and employee satisfaction surveys across the
organisation. Says Azim H. Premji, 53, CEO, Wipro Corporation: "The Corporate Centre
is involved in creating processes and systems which drive performance across the
corporation."
THE HCL GROUP
The Synergy Management Centre
Shiv Nadar's 3-business, 4-company, Rs
2,400-crore empire--a.k.a. the HCL Group--is synonymous with entrepreneurship. Is there a
role for a Corporate Centre here at all? Sure, as the agenda of the group's apex body--HCL
Corporation--reveals. Its self-set mandate is to identify new business opportunities, set
standards, create management policies--such as which school of TQM to follow--maintain
financial and accounting discipline, and manage synergies between the 4 companies that
constitute the group.
The HCL Centre oversees alliances and new business
strategies, and minimises the overlaps in the large group to ensure that each company
focuses on a particular business area. It defines work areas and handles project
integration by making group companies collaborate when necessary. In addition, the
Corporate Centre creates institutionalised resources to meet contingencies. For instance,
it set up the Institute of Quality Learning specifically to act as a consultant to all
group companies.
The Council is headed by Group CEO Nadar himself, and
includes the technology, finance, and personnel heads of the group, in addition to the
CEOs of the individual businesses. Avers Ajay Choudhury, the 48-year-old President &
CEO of hcl Infosystems: "From just providing broad directions, restructuring the
organisation, and monitoring key business fundamentals, the role of the Corporate Centre
has evolved into a completely process-oriented activity spanning far more areas." And
that makes the HCL Group a classic showcase for the Corporate Centre at work. |
SYNERGY-EXTRACTION. Caught up in their
own operations, managers at the business-unit level will, obviously, not have the
meta-business perspective that can look for synergies between units. This will be the
responsibility of the New CEO Centre, which must explore and expand synergies through
several mechanisms. First, the CEO's Office must co-ordinate the sharing or transfer--as
the case may be--of resources between units. This, indeed, is its primary task--its raison
d'étre. If the resources are so-called public resources, which can be used simultaneously
by several businesses--brands, for instance--the New CEO Centre will have to only
cultivate them. If, on the other hand, they are private resources--which can be used by
only one unit, to the exclusion of another, at any given time--the CEO's Office must
perform the more complex task of creating the rules and systems for allocation. For
instance, it may choose to simulate a market in the group, thus forcing every unit to
compete for the use of internal resources.
Second, the New CEO Centre must facilitate the seamless flow
of information, knowledge, and best practices across the boundaries of different business
units. This it can do by creating a suitable culture, rewarding knowledge-building and
sharing activities, organising formal and informal fora where knowledge can be shared, and
using people-mobility as a means for spreading the learning around. Consider Global
Telesystems, a 10-year-old telecommunication-solutions company. Already, the two
first-generation entrepreneurs who started the company have realised the importance of a
value-adding central function in an industry where technology obsolescence rates are very
high. Its Corporate Centre manages the processes of sharing of best practices, management
development, and management initiatives, and terms the heads of its 4 businesses
entrepreneurs instead of business heads. Says Fritz d'Silva, 34, Vice-Managing Director,
Global Telesystems: "We include a business head's risk-taking ability in their
appraisals. So, the organisational structure is fully supportive of minimum
interference."
SUPER-OPERATIONS. Providing the glue between
diverse activities, or the grease that lubricates the parts and enables them to move as a
whole, will be the operational contribution of the New CEO Centre. When co-ordination is
needed between different functions, it will come from the CEO's Office. More significantly
for the strategic perspective, the responsibility for evolving performance-evaluation
standards--jointly with the business units--for conducting these assessments, and for
re-aligning business priorities according to the results will also lie with the New CEO
Centre. At the Steel Authority Of India Ltd (SAIL), for instance, the success of the
business plan depends on the interaction between the Corporate Centre, Central Marketing
Organisation (CMO), and the plants and the R&D centre for iron and steel. Once the
annual business plan and financial budget are finalised by the plants, the process is
reviewed and monitored at the CEO meetings.
The CEO's Office will have to swing into action whenever
combining the might of different units may prove more beneficial. At the GIC Group, it's
GIC, the holding company, that makes collective long-term investment decisions for its 4
subsidiaries: National Insurance, New India Insurance, Oriental Insurance, and United
India Insurance. Says P.M. Venkatasubramanian, 59, CEO, GIC: "Investment decisions
are taken jointly so that the bargaining power is not frittered away by the individual low
surplus." sail's CMO manages the marketing for its integrated steel plants
collectively to capitalise on the volume and variety of the combined output, pooling which
gives greater flexibility in meeting customer needs. Adds C.P. Krishnan Nair, 73,
Chairman, Hotel Leelaventure: "Cost management is another area that needs to be
co-ordinated by the Centre." The CEO must remember, however, that the crucial issue
here is not the actual task of execution--which need not be done by the New CEO Centre
itself--but of the institutionalisation of the centralised service.
STEEL AUTHORITY OF INDIA
The Customer Management Centre
A financially troubled industrial behemoth
like the Steel Authority of India Ltd (SAIL) may seem an unlikely candidate for a
corporation with the New CEO Centre. Yet, that is just what the mega-public sector unit is
smelting to add value to the operations of its 5 integrated steel plants. The innovation
quotient is evident in the presence of not 1 but 2 centres--the first being a corporate
one, while the second concentrates on marketing.
THE CORPORATE OFFICE. The focus of SAIL's core is on
ensuring that work at the different plants adds up to implementing the corporate strategy.
This task is crucial because, in the absence of co-ordination, the pursuit of their own
agendas by different units may make it difficult for the organisational goals to be
achieved. Says Shoeb Ahmed, 48, Chief (Corporate Affairs), SAIL: "Given SAIL's
apparently competing and conflicting priorities, it is necessary for a central management
system to blend all the abilities harmoniously into a single cohesive functioning
entity." SAIL's Centre realises its role by drafting the vision, facilitating the
transfer of raw materials, standardising procedures and technical knowhow, and providing
common supporting resources.
For instance, since the steel industry is
raw-material-intensive, its techno-economics is sensitive to price and quality of
supplies. Thus, the corporate office deploys teams for supply-chain management for all the
units. Elimination of duplication across plants is achieved for the Corporate Centre by
the Operation Directorate, which plans the inter-plant transfers of semi-finished items
such as slabs, billets, and raw materials. Similarly, it is the Centre that facilitates
the horizontal transfers of technology between plants.
THE CENTRAL MARKETING ORGANISATION. The second major
contribution of sail's Centre to its businesses is the provision of an integrated
marketing mechanism. The logic is simple: since individual plants are production-oriented,
they need a super-co-ordinating structure to use the output to meet customer needs. Thus,
the CMO manages sail's customers, thereby adding value to the output of its different
plants. Specifically, it uses 3 teams: the Market Management Group, which co-ordinates
activities across the region; the Market Research Group, which manages market research;
and the Application Engineering Group, which solves technical problems for customers.
The objective of sail's Centre is explicitly to
provide additional expertise wherever they can add value to the business units' own
functioning. This Centre is a facilitator, not an interloper. |
CAPABILITY-CREATION. The 3 critical
resources that any corporation will need are low-cost finance, the best people, and a
powerful information infrastructure. Relegated in the past to support mechanisms, these
are emerging as crucial differentiators for competing. For the multi-business group in
particular, these are vital not just because they are enablers of success where every
other resource is easily duplicable, but also because they can help the parts of the
conglomerate add up to something that is greater than the whole. For, they can be used to
ensure that every business unit benefits from belonging to the same group as the rest. All
3 areas will demand direct participation from the New CEO Centre, and not just
arm's-length monitoring and delegation. Why do these need to be centralised operations in
a multi-business group which may well decentralise even traditionally-consolidated
operations like purchasing or distribution? The answer lies in the fact that all 3 are
critical to the New CEO Centre's mission of leveraging learning that may originate in one
pocket of the group for the benefit of all businesses. While some competitive advantages
can only be specific to a particular business--and do not need to be translated into
common competencies--the advantages of cheap capital, knowledge-workers, and streamlined
information-flow can be experienced across the group.
Thus, the New CEO Centre must comprise hands-on actors--not
off-the-stage directors--in building, improving, and distributing these resources. The
Tata Group, for example, has concentrated the finance function in a central department
reporting directly to the group CEO, Ratan Tata. At HLL, each of the 8 business groups dip
into the Corporate Centre's people pool instead of recruiting on a divisional basis, to
ensure both a distribution of knowledge and better fit between the individual and the job.
Says M.S. Banga, the 43-year-old Director (Soaps & Detergents) of HLL: "The
business units draw on the Corporate Centre for their people requirements. We have an
excellent tracking and monitoring system to trace each person's career-path." And at
Ranbaxy Laboratories, building and managing the information infrastructure is the direct
responsibility of the company's Head of Strategy, Vasant Kumar. Adds Alok B. Shriram, 38,
Deputy Managing Director, DCM Shriram Consolidated: "We are increasingly trying to
focus on our core competency. Competency-management is something that can be driven in the
new environment from the Corporate Centre."
BUILDING THE new CEO centre
The CEO of the focused conglomerate must structure the New
CEO Centre primarily in response to the manner in which his group uses its resources. That
the multi-business group can thrive only by leveraging a set of common resources is
understood. Indeed, the more the resources that its businesses share, no matter how many
businesses it is in, the closer is the conglomerate to following the principle of core
competence. The responsibility of the New CEO Centre is, obviously, to ensure maximum use
of the corporate resources. Says Arvind Pande, 56, Chairman, sail: "The corporate
office has delivered strategic support in providing synergies across the sail plants and
aided in enhancing the competitiveness of the plants through well-planned modernisation
programmes." The manner in which the CEO's office chooses to do so, however, is less
obvious. What are the alternatives? On the one hand, it may prefer completely centralised
resources, allocated by the New CEO Centre using whatever parameters it sees fit: these
range, typically, from freezing budgets to meeting emerging contingencies. On the other,
it may opt for completely decentralised resources--allowing the different units to access
the corporate resources in any manner they want to, without referring to the Corporate
Centre at all. The mechanisms of allotment might be market simulation--where units compete
for the same resources--or a spirit of mutual co-operation, or a combination. Says Bharat
Doshi, 49, Executive Director (Finance & Corporate Affairs), M&M: "Our
company regularly has a war-room review strategy where the president of a business unit is
an open target for anyone who wishes to use him as a resource and question his
decisions."
It is axiomatic that the choice will determine the dimensions
of the New CEO Centre. It will need more people in the first case--when it has to manage
the activity of allotment--than in the second. Thus, the CEO's Office may have no more
than 50 people in the latter eventuality, but up to 100 in the former--with the number
being ruled by the number of businesses and the complexity of the resources involved. In
either event, the cardinal rule is that the New CEO Centre must be manned by people who
have 3 critical characteristics. First, they must be accomplished line-managers, so that
they bring an understanding of different corporate functions to the New CEO Centre. Says
hll's Banga: "The members of our Management Committee hold the experiences of
exposure to a variety of businesses and functions in HLL."
THE PROCESS |
To build the CEO Centre, the CEO must use the
principle of reengineering: design his office as though he were starting afresh. Dismantle the old Centre completely
Decide on the functions to be centralised
Pick representatives from each business
Appoint technical specialists
Rebuild the Centre from scratch
Specify reporting relationships
Set performance standards for the Centre
Gather feedback from units on performance
Modify the practices on the basis of feedback
Institute a system to measure value-addition |
Second, they must enjoy high levels of credibility with
the managers in the business units. And third, they must thrive on change, and not be
addicted to routine. The wise CEO will staff his office only with people who have been
rotated around business units; have strong financial, analytical, and people management
skills; are fluent communicators; and, most important, are committed to leading rather
than doing. The second vital task for the New CEO Centre will be the design and creation
of process and system interfaces with the line-managers and business units. It has to
choose one or more interface mechanisms: task-forces, cross-functional top management
teams, management committees, centres of excellence, review meetings, dedicated managers
et al. The Reliance Group, for instance, uses task-forces to interface on short-term
projects, and executive committees for recurring issues--such as compensation review and
corporate governance.
ASEA BROWN BOVERI
The People Management Centre
Few corporations embody the New CEO Centre as
typically as Asea Brown Boveri (ABB). Virtually all strategic and operational powers are
vested in the frontline managers of the 140-country, 35-business, 1,000-subsidiary
conglomerate, whose former chairman Percy Barnevik made it his avowed intention to turn
ABB into a confederation of hundreds of independent individual companies. Today, the
Executive Committee focuses only on those aspects of inter-business and inter-company
co-ordination that the business units cannot manage on their own. Functionally, these
include worldwide strategy, co-ordination of purchasing power, co-ordination of the
transfer of experience, design, and M&A. Most important, however, the Centre,
comprising 8 people besides CEO Goran Lindahl, acts as the human resource energiser,
building the appropriate atmosphere of trust and stretch.
As a stated objective, ABB keeps its Centre as thin as
it can, constantly sending people out to the individual businesses to manage them. As
Barnevik, 57, puts it: "We operate as leanly as possible. The closer we get to top
management, the tougher we have to be with headcount." To improve the quality of its
interface with the different companies within the fold, the Centre has just reorganised
the group to eliminate the layer of regional offices--comprising 100-and-odd
managers--which the country operations used to report to. This Centre believes that lean
isn't mean |
A subtle balancing act is involved here: specifying the
relationship between the members of the New CEO Centre and the CEOs and functional heads
of the individual businesses. Turning the managers of the business units into direct
reports of the managers in the New CEO Centre--using a direct functional mapping--will
clearly curb their independence. On the other hand, without an accountability structure,
co-ordination between, say, the group CFO and the CFOs of the different businesses--so
essential for value-addition--will be impossible. The happy middle-ground usually lies in
adopting 2 tactics. First, designate the reporting relationship as a peer-interaction
rather than a superior-subordinate issue. And second, flowing from the first, make
membership of the New CEO Centre as rotational affair, so that the functional heads of
different businesses are co-opted by it at intervals.
Perhaps no other form of organisational change demands as
radical a shift in the responsibility-set of the CEO and his office as the New CEO Centre
does. Says Narsim Shenoy, 67, Chairman, ABB Group (India): "The restructuring of the
group, and the Corporate Centre, was necessary to meet the challenges of the new
Millennium, making the company globally and locally competitive." The very notion
that individual businesses will chart their own strategic and operational course--while
the New CEO Centre's function moves from control to catalysis, from command to
co-ordination--is difficult to accept. The more so because the CEO is, after all,
accountable for the overall success of his group. To take on this responsibility, but to
exercise power primarily through context-creation and resource-management, requires a leap
of faith. And yet, it is one that the CEO has no choice but to make. As hll's Banga
describes it: "There are processes which are built in for inter-dependency, but,
ultimately, every business functions like a mini-company and is very self-contained in
terms of the decisions that need to be taken." The truth is that the best decision
today is the one that's taken at a point as near the customer as possible.
Equally, it is possible to combine disparate resources and
business units to create results that are far more than the simple sum of the parts--so
long as the relationships between them are constantly monitored and managed for best
results. That, ultimately, is what the New CEO Centre sets out to do. In its focus, it may
have shrunk to a small point at the very core of the corporation. In its effect, however,
it is sensed everywhere. It is, to borrow a punchline, all corporation, no centre.
THE PRIORITIES |
While the New CEO Centre has a
multi-item mandate, it must put a few activities high on its agenda so as to make its
effect felt immediately. BUILD
AN IDENTITY. Formulate a shared vision and values, and create a definite identity for the
company in every constituency
GROW CAPABILITIES. Act as a
market-maker for all businesses to ensure corporate-wide access to world-class low-cost
competencies
PROVIDE CAPITAL. Take steps to
minimise the cost of capital and fund growth at the lowest possible expense to each
business unit
GIVE STRATEGIC LEADERSHIP. Script a
convincing future for the business units to buy into and commit themselves |
|