India
accounts for a sixth of the world's population. But only a sixth
of India's billion people have access to affordable healthcare.
The rest are neglected much like the diseases that afflict them.
Medical help is inaccessible and simply beyond their means. In
fact, the cost of staying alive pushes one quarter of Indians
below the poverty line. Those who require hospitalisation are
perennially repaying debts and it is important to note that rural
indebtedness caused by illness is far greater than that caused
by crop failure.
India's disease profile features 8.5 million
patients infected with tuberculosis (TB), 5.1 million people who
are HIV+, 2.1 million suffering from malaria and an estimated
35 million diabetics, which makes India the world's largest in
all these disease segments. In the area of metabolic diseases
and cancer, India's patient profile mirrors that of the Western
world. Such a disease burden could bankrupt even the most affluent
of nations.
Developing and maintaining sustainable healthcare
delivery for people in the poorest countries of the world is,
indeed, a gigantic, if not an insurmountable, challenge. There
is an urgent need to provide access to affordable healthcare in
a sustainable manner. Furthermore, this should be based on an
underlying strategy of preventive, rather than curative, medical
care if we are to improve India's health indicators. The only
viable proposition is an insurance model that will support millions
across India's rural hinterland through a large network of hospitals
and clinics. Roughly translated, it means "Insuring Affordable
Healthcare".
India's demographics reflect a young population
with a median life expectancy of 57 years and a median age of
26 years. This has the potential to provide a workable basis for
a sustainable and affordable healthcare model. As Winston Churchill
said: "Insurance brings the miracles of mathematical probability
to the rescue of the masses." This is in sharp contrast to
the aging populations of Western economies where healthcare bills
are mounting to unsustainable levels.
In recent times, several low cost health
insurance models have taken root. The most visible programme is
the Yashaswini Health Insurance scheme introduced by the Government
of Karnataka in 2003. Under this programme, members of various
co-operatives in the state receive an insurance cover against
an extensive list of surgical procedures (1,650 in all) for a
nominal premium of Rs 120 per annum. Another private initiative,
Arogya Raksha Yojana, is a comprehensive health insurance scheme
that goes beyond surgeries and encompasses hospitalisation, free
medical consultations and low cost medicines all for a modest
premium of Rs 180 per annum. Both these programmes rely on a network
of established government and private hospitals and clinics (as
the case may be), to provide quality healthcare to rural communities.
Theoretically, at an annual insurance premium of Rs 180 or approximately
$4, India should be in a position to provide basic healthcare
to its billion people for an unbelievable $4 billion (Rs 18,000
crore)! This is a hypothesis well worth establishing.
The Indian market is known to offer the
cheapest generic drugs in the world. Eliminating marketing
and distribution costs reduces this even further |
Success in the long-term battle against illness
and disease in developing nations is increasingly becoming more
dependent on education and efficient infrastructure. It is, therefore,
critical to create awareness on health and hygiene and provide
efficient systems by leveraging information technology. Preventive
healthcare is more sustainable than undertaking the life-long
treatment of a disease that has already declared itself. It is
often the simplest essentials that are required in order to break
out of the vicious circle of infection and ignorance.
Information technology and telecommunications
have an increasingly enabling role to play in healthcare management.
The importance of telemedicine and electronic data capture in
providing enhanced medical information for diagnosis and treatment
is key to building an efficient model. Additionally, building
databases and disease registries will enable such insurance programmes
to evaluate the incidence and diversity of diseases at an epidemiological
level and, thereby, allow for better optimisation.
The cost of drugs is another key factor in
addressing affordable healthcare. The Indian market is known to
offer the cheapest generic drugs in the world. Eliminating marketing
and distribution costs reduces this even further. Arogya Raksha
Yojana, for instance, sources low-cost generic drugs and makes
them available at between 30-50 per cent of retail prices through
a network of in-house pharmacies. Spurious drugs are another factor
that is severely detrimental to affordable healthcare. Programmes
like the one mentioned above are addressing this through a quality
control system that aims to create a controlled supply chain that
is designed to eliminate any devious intrusion from fakes.
India provides a unique platform for affordable
drug development. Up until now, Indian industry has built a globally
competitive generic pharmaceutical business. The time has come
to research and develop improved and new medicines. This intrinsically
challenges Indian industry to balance the high cost of R&D
with market affordability. In this context, it is prudent to highlight
that patented drugs, especially biotech drugs account for less
than 5 per cent of the total market purely on account of unaffordability.
The challenge is to provide new and advanced medicines, especially
biotech drugs, to patients at the bottom of the pyramid. This
will only be possible if Indian pharma and biotech companies step
up their innovation-led research programmes and pursue an indigenous
development path that allows for affordable and cost effective
drug development routes.
Public-private partnerships are integral
to building efficient, sustainable and quality healthcare models
in rural India. The government's Primary Healthcare Centres (PHCs)
are inadequately designed and ill-equipped to deliver such objectives.
Today, it is non-governmental organisations, the World Health
Organisation and private initiatives like those of Rotary, Lions
and others that have addressed mass immunisation programmes more
extensively than PHCs. Others like the Gates Foundation, MMV,
IAVI, etc., are investing in health education as well as research
initiatives in the area of aids, malaria and infectious diseases.
PHCs are simply not providing comprehensive healthcare efficiently.
India's changing demographics call for changing and contemporary
healthcare delivery models. PHCs need to form linkages with the
private sector if they are to function as contemporary and effective
health providers to the nation. One such initiative involves Arogya
Raksha Yojana being entrusted with the management and operations
of PHCs on existing government budgetary support. The strategy
is to link it to an insurance programme that value adds to the
PHC concept.
The backbone of future healthcare programmes
needs to rest on hygiene awareness campaigns that cover water,
sanitation and personal hygiene. The ultimate goal should be to
help people move towards a better quality of life. Good hygiene
means good health. There exists a sharp disconnect between urban
and rural healthcare in India and if we continue to ignore this
deepening divide, we run the dangerous risk of destabilising our
social and economic fabric. The time has come to provide basic
healthcare to our billion people. Accessibility and affordability
need to be integral to this mission and any low cost health insurance
model will ensure rural Indians a better quality of life.
The author is Chairman & Managing Director,
Biocon Limited
|