The
issue of water and its availability is not merely a question of
economics or the physical challenge in the satisfaction of very
basic human needs, but it also has cultural and, in several respects,
religious dimensions. To evaluate what needs to be done for making
water available to all in this country, we need to go back in
time perhaps several thousands of years and also go across the
globe to fully comprehend the global nature of the challenge of
making water available to every citizen of this planet.
Policies and strategies for new forms of
management of water resources and any attempt to bring in principles
of good business management in this sector in India evoke an extreme
emotional response. We have to appreciate that this is so largely
because our ancestors who settled on this subcontinent essentially
set up habitations around the major waterways, which provided
sustenance for human beings as well as cattle and other animals
that were seen as a source and symbol of prosperity. It is no
surprise, therefore, that the very first centres where civilisation
flourished on the Indian subcontinent were those that were located
around the major river systems of this land. With an extremely
favourable ratio of water resources to the number of human beings
whose needs were to be met, water scarcity was totally unknown
to those who inhabited this land. This vital gift of nature that
was bestowed in abundance on the India of 5,000 years ago became,
therefore, a God-given blessing that no government or management
structure had any right to interfere with.
This situation unfortunately has changed
drastically over the years, and more so in the last few decades
with rapid growth of our population, a much more resource intensive
form of agriculture and rapid development of the Indian economy
as a whole. The balance between generous water availability and
modest human needs that justified total absence of market forces
in the management of water was fully justified perhaps a century
ago. But things have changed drastically since. In the short period
of 50 years between 1947 and 1997, the availability of water per
year in India declined from around 6,000 cubic metres per capita
to a little over 2,000 cubic metres in 1997. Projections for the
future as carried out by TERI in its major study called green
(Growth with Resource Enhancement of Environment and Nature) India
2047 indicate that several areas of the country that have adequate
water resources and availability today would suffer from water
scarcity by the year 2047 and large areas would become water-stressed.
Clearly, a very different approach to the management of our water
resources is called for if we have to meet the growing demand
of our expanding economy and meeting the very basic needs of an
expanding population.
The rapidly increasing demand for water
by Indian society can be met neither in quantity nor quality
unless a radical departure is made to the existing policies
and practices |
In some respects, the words of Samuel Coleridge
in his famous The Rime of the Ancient Mariner of "water,
water everywhere nor any drop to drink" is relevant across
the globe. Less than the 3 per cent of the world's water is fresh,
while the rest is seawater and, therefore, undrinkable. Of this
3 per cent, over 2.5 per cent is in a frozen form, locked up largely
in Antarctica, the Arctic and as glaciers on our mountains, generally
inaccessible to the human race. What we are left with is the balance
0.5 per cent from which not only do we have to satisfy the needs
of the human race, but also the demands of an increasingly stressed
ecosystem, which needs water to survive. Water problems across
the globe are, therefore, likely to become far more serious than
we have experienced thus far.
The largest use of water in this country
is for irrigation in the agricultural sector. We use well over
80 per cent of our water for agriculture as opposed to a slightly
lower percentage in China and Egypt. In contrast, France uses
a little over 10 per cent and the UK well under 5 per cent for
agriculture. This, of course, is a direct function of the pattern
of rainfall, which is far more uniform in several parts of the
world and abundant enough to permit agriculture round the year.
Other sectors in India that are major users of water are the electric
power industry, which requires water for hydroelectric stations
and as a coolant in thermal power stations. An increase in industrial
activity has placed growing demand for water for several industrial
processes. Similarly, many industries such as those dealing with
food, beverages and pharmaceutical products require water as an
ingredient in finished products for human consumption. Finally,
water is also used as a medium for waste disposal. The excessive
abuse of our river systems and lakes is an unfortunate example
of excessive use of water for waste disposal.
Water
quality in our river systems has reached crisis proportions. The
quality of river water as pointed out in the green India 2047
study is monitored at 480 stations under different programmes
in the country. On the basis of these measurements, the quality
of water is classified along five different classes, with class
A representing water fit for drinking without conventional treatment
but after disinfection. Class E, on the other end, is fit only
for irrigation, industrial cooling and controlled waste disposal.
The total coliform count in Indian rivers, has risen steeply in
recent years, and standards are being violated in a large number
of cases. Some of the worst affected rivers in the country are
Sabarmati and Khan, in which the biochemical oxygen demand (BOD,
a measure of food for bacteria found in water) values were greater
than 20 milligrams per litre in 1997. The BOD value of water in
Elangabeel lake in Assam and Ulsoor lake in Karnataka is more
than 7 times the maximum permissible limit. Major sources of water
pollution in India are city sewage and discharge of industrial
waste. The sewage released from cities increased from an estimated
5 billion litres a day in 1947 to around 30 billion litres a day
in 1997. Facilities for effective treatment of sewage represent
only 10 per cent of the quantity generated.
Based on these facts, it can be concluded
that the rapidly increasing demand for water by Indian society
can be met neither in quantity nor quality unless a radical departure
is made to the existing policies and practices established in
this sector. In general, government departments responsible for
water management and supply have largely bred ineffective and
inefficient management of this resource. As a result, not only
is there unhealthy overuse of water for several applications,
but polluting industries and cities dumping sewage are able to
get away in the absence of effective penalties for violating standards
and regulations and a lack of incentives for proper action.
Technological possibilities that can bring
about revolutionary improvements in water usage range from
drip irrigation in agriculture to water conserving toilets |
The introduction of market principles for
the management of water is generally resisted and condemned by
civil society and various communities, because the availability
of water is seen as a God-given right which no operators of markets
or business have any licence to interfere with. Yet, in the absence
of proper pricing signals, it is unlikely that the right technological
solutions will emerge and be disseminated widely enough in any
society. Technological possibilities that can bring about revolutionary
improvements in water usage range from drip irrigation in agriculture
to water conserving toilets that use recycled water in our towns
and cities. Yet, none of these is likely to be adopted and persevered
with by consumers, unless there is a price attached to inefficient
consumption. There are also massive leakages and wastage in the
public supply and distribution of water, which again would get
plugged effectively if agencies responsible for the management
of water evaluate and act to reduce the economic loss involved.
In other words, some business principles must govern the supply
and distribution of water.
The
big challenge in moving to such a scenario lies in convincing
the public that in the ultimate analysis, they would be the main
beneficiaries of market principles applied to water management.
Another aspect that requires the use of appropriate market instruments
is in respect of pollution of water. The huge economic loss that
society incurs because polluters only evaluate their narrow private
gains while dumping large quantities of pollutants into our waterways,
needs radical change. Penalties for water pollution must match
if not exceed the cost imposed on society. The worst sufferers
in this regard are a large number of poor people who cannot buy
bottles of factory processed water and poor fishermen who have
nothing to catch other than tonnes of sewage in our dead rivers.
There is enough legislative back-up for effective action and punitive
measures for polluters in this country. The major weakness lies
in an effective institution that can transparently and honestly
ensure compliance with the law, and thus ensure net benefits to
society.
As a concluding concern, it might be mentioned
that the impacts of climate change on India could adversely affect
the availability of water resources and their even distribution
during different periods in the year. Hence, there is an urgent
need for adapting measures by which Indian society can minimise
the adverse effects of climate change, particularly as they relate
to the water regime in the country. Water for all would remain
an unfulfilled dream unless the government, the media, business
and civil society work in partnership to bring about a total revolution
in our thinking about this vital resource and in its essential
management. If there is a sector where public-private partnerships
need to be put to test, it has to be in the water supply system
in our country.
The author is Director General
of TERI
|