|
"A borrower should
stay put as there are costs involved in moving from fixed
to floating"
Sudhin Choksey/Managing Director/Gruh Finance |
When finance professional
Viral Mehta, 35, bought a 1,200 sq. ft three-bedroom apartment in
a Mumbai suburb, he pocketed a deal as the interest rate on his
home loan was merely 7.25 per cent. His equated monthly installment
(EMI) on a loan of Rs 38 lakh worked out to Rs 30,034. But that
was two years ago. The interest rates then were at their lowest
and Mehta got lucky with the bargain. Since then, the story has
taken a turn. Rates have now crawled up to 9.75 per cent, pushing
up Mehta's monthly outflow by 20 per cent to Rs 36,043. For Mehta,
it was a surprising revelation. "Back then, I didn't foresee
that the rates could go up so much," he says, "it has
upset my monthly calculations." Mehta's is not an isolated
case. Scores of individuals have seen their monthly numbers go
haywire due to the steady surge in interest rates. It's not just
the
housing loan rate that has been affected. Loan rates on cars
and bikes and even travel have surged, especially in the last
year. The effect of the rate hike has been particularly sharp
as corporates have borrowed big, which has resulted in credit
growth of over 30 per cent, while a dearth of depositors has squeezed
the loanable funds of banks. Little wonder then, that retail loan
giant, ICICI Bank, has affected two rate hikes this year and other
public and private sector banks have followed suit. Rates are
up by 50 to 150 basis points over the last year. Says V.S. Rangan,
Senior General Manager, HDFC: "Housing loans are long-term
commitments and during this tenure, there will be times when interest
rates will move up and times when they move down. Two years saw
the interest rates prevailing at an all-time low of 7 to 8 per
cent. Today, the rates are hardening and are currently around
9.5 to 10 per cent."
The Rate Relationship
DOS AND DON'TS |
Dos |
Keep a tab on the interest rate and
what your resultant outgo is Always
read the fine print when going in for a loan. You could
be in for a nasty surprise. And if you have doubts, ask
someone who knows the subject
Go in for pre-payment of loan if you think
you are sufficiently liquid. It is not a bad idea to get
a big loan off your back early
Cater for contingencies. Your increased outgo
each month is rarely the only significant outgo
Finally, prepare yourself for fluctuations
in interest rates. It helps in better financial planning |
Don'ts |
Confuse yourself as being a real buyer when
you could just be an investor. This really means that when
you buy a house, for instance, make sure how long you plan
to hold on to it Acquire another asset without reason
when rates are dropping. Make sure you need the asset and
that you are liquid enough for a significant outgo
Move from fixed to floating or vice versa without a proper
reason. There is a switching cost that is involved
Go in for savings without a proper reason. Remember, high
returns on savings are the ones with high risks as well
Finally, never panic when interest rates are going up.
If you are well-cushioned, you will be comfortable
|
Typically, there is little or no control that borrowers have over
the rate of interest and this depends on the liquidity in the system
and at what rate the lenders are borrowing their own money. For
Mehta, the apprehension is understandable. "I hope the interest
rates will not go beyond 10-10.5 per cent," he says with more
than a bit of caution.
|
"There is typically
a cycle in interest rate movements and they will not rise
forever "
Jitender Balakrishnan/ Deputy Managing Director/ IDBI Bank |
So, what does someone like Mehta now do? After all, increasing
interest rates will impact every loan that he has borrowed. According
to Puneet Chaddha, Head (Card and Retail Assets), HSBC, a borrower
should always keep in mind the end use. "Any borrower should
realise that rates can go up any time. It is important for him
to cater for contingencies as well," he adds. By contingency,
one is not always referring to an emergency but even something
like going on a holiday. The basic idea is to keep some spare
cash handy over and above a couple of EMIs to adjust the outstanding
loan, so that the monthly installment is at a manageable level.
Fixed or Floating
There is, of course, the option to move from floating to a fixed
rate if the rate hike is too much. "For an existing borrower
at this stage, I think he should stay put since there are costs
associated with moving from one option to another," says
Sudhin Choksey, Managing Director, Gruh Finance. He agrees that
2006 was quite volatile as far as interest rates were concerned
and for now, a "wait and watch" attitude from the borrower's
side seems like a smart thing to do. "For a new borrower,
I would suggest a semi-fixed option as the best bet," avers
Choksey.
|
"Any increase in the
loan tenure should not go beyond one's earning years or one's
retirement period"
V.S. Rangan/ Senior General Manager/HDFC |
These days banks have started a hybrid of fixed and floating
rate home loan products where a part of the outstanding is fixed
and the other is floating. Says Rangan: "The loan will be
broken up into two parts-one on which interest is charged at a
fixed rate and the other on which interest is charged at a floating
rate." Such products will help reduce the impact of the rising
interest rates.
For the likes of Mehta, "wait and watch" seems a prudent
thing to do before switching. Sunil Rongala, Group Economist at
the Chennai-based Murugappa Group, is of the opinion that when
it comes to home loans, he would still go for floating. "I
think rates will come down since India is not a classic inflation
case like that of Argentina. Besides, inflation is certainly not
out of control here in India," says Rongala.
Alternatively, an individual has the option of increasing the
tenure of the loan as most banks are doing. But one must always
keep a tab on the outstanding and pre-pay a part of the loan or
increase one's EMI so that the extended tenure does not stretch
for too long. Says Rangan: "Most institutions reset the tenure
of the loan if there are any interest rate fluctuations rather
than change the EMI to avoid any immediate impact on the customer.
However, in such a scenario, the customer should be cautious that
the increase in the loan tenure does not go beyond one's earning
years or one's retirement period."
On the Rise
Most industry observers are clear that while the interest rates
are hard to predict, the phenomenon of them rising continually
is equally unlikely. "There is typically a cycle in interest
rate movements and they will not rise forever," maintains
Jitender Balakrishnan, Deputy Managing Director, IDBI Bank. On
the issue of fixed versus floating rate of interest, he points
out that while the rate of interest is normally higher on fixed,
the rate on floating can be changed according to the Prime Lending
Rate (PLR). "Interest rates could probably increase by a
quarter-to-half-a-per cent and then stabilise over the next few
months," predicts Balakrishnan. That should sound good to
the borrower since his actual outgo through the EMI will most
importantly be predictable. So, even while there's a chance that
it could stay stable, borrowers could do well to brace themselves
for the hike.
The need for the borrower to think smart and opt for a loan
amount that is within his capacity can never be exaggerated. Pre-payment
of a loan is surely an option if the borrower has a larger amount
of disposable income at a particular time against what he requires.
"Yes, pre-payment of a loan is an option if there is a difference
in the rate of interest," cautions Balakrishnan.
All this would depend not merely on the current level of liquidity
but also on the future cash flows of the borrower. After all,
a hefty outgo in case of Mehta and several thousands of others
would lead them to take a closer look at this unpredictable area.
"Salary increases may not be that high," states HSBC's
Chaddha. On the issue of pre-payment of a loan, he maintains it
depends on the mental make-up of a person. "For instance,
if a person is close to retirement, it is a good idea to pre-pay
a loan," he adds.
At the end of it, the India story looks real and that is clearly
the reason for this kind of liquidity. As far as the interest
rates story goes, the consensus seems to be that we are entering
a zone of stability, which is good news for the borrowers. However,
like any other phase in a country's development process, a certain
amount of caution is not only a good idea, but also necessary.
A basic degree of financial planning acts as a good cushion for
any individual against interest vagaries and that could well be
the answer this time around as well.
Don't
Churn Your Funds
The high
incidence of churning in equity funds is alarming and is detrimental
to long-term wealth building.
By Mahesh Nayak
|
"You have to give time to your
fund manager to perform and have faith in his investment call"
Sanjay Sachdev/ Country Manager/ Shinsei Bank |
If there's an alarming side to the fund flows of equity mutual
funds, it's this: a high churn ratio suggesting that short-term
investors far outstrip the long-term ones. Last year, a record
Rs 64,169 crore was redeemed from equity schemes by investors
flipping out of funds, nearly twice as much as Rs 35,000-odd crore
garnered by new fund offerings (NFOs), and more than 66 per cent
of the entire inflows of Rs 97,834 crore during the year (see
The Churning Ground). For equity fund investors, that's a worrying
sign. First, there's a tremendous amount of pressure on the fund
manager to perform. And secondly, excessive churning does more
harm than good to your long-term wealth building.
Last year, however, the market regulator, the Securities and
Exchange Board of India (SEBI) came down hard on new mutual fund
offerings. SEBI even mandated that the trustees should endorse
new funds saying that the fund house does not already have a similar
type of fund. The Association of Mutual Funds in India (AMFI)
too reintroduced the reduction of a fund's initial expense upfront
as against amortising it over a five-year period. But that does
not seem to have deterred the mutual fund investor from switching
between funds-often at an additional cost that's detrimental to
him.
How Churning Hurts |
What you should know before you churn
your funds. |
Sustained churning disturbs the investment
rhythm of the fund manager forcing him to make aggressive
choices and increase risk to the overall portfolio
Short-term churning erodes maximum gains for investor
due to short-term tax of 10 per cent and higher loads
Churning should be considered as a tool to rebalance or
realign an investor's portfolio
|
As far as the mutual fund industry goes, the blame game is passed
around. The mutual fund industry points a finger at the distributors
for mis-selling a product, which later pushes an investor to move
out while the distributor passes the same on to the retail investors
indicating that the mutual fund investor is now more demanding
and therefore is willing to shuffle between funds. Even as the
industry squabbles, more investors are pulling out of new funds.
Interestingly, the corpus of 27 open-ended equity NFOs launched
in 2006 dipped by 18 per cent to Rs 20,641 crore from Rs 25,271.9
crore, despite the market rising. Kotak's Lifestyle Fund saw its
corpus reduced by 55 per cent or Rs 385 crore from a mobilisation
of Rs 856 crore. In the same period, the Sensex has surged by
35 per cent (see Corpus Capers).
Often investors get carried away by the booming market making
aggressive investments by churning their existing portfolio. Says
R. Swaminathan, National Head (Mutual Fund), IDBI Capital: "It's
a herd mentality. When returns aren't good and markets are rising,
investors tend to change from one fund to another. Secondly, profit
booking has also kept the churns at higher levels." Adds
Sanjay Sachdev, Country Manager India & Regional Manager (Fund
Management), Shinsei Bank: "The industry is still dominated
by large investors, who have short-term goals adding to the churning,
thus spoiling the real purpose of investment."
The Cost of Hopping
Among the many drawbacks of switching funds, the foremost is
the pressure of performance on a fund manager. They have to be
constantly on their toes to deliver returns that can hold back
their investors and they can't simply be patient with solid long-term
investments. If a fund is lagging behind in performance, investors
tend to cash out which therefore forces a fund manager to look
for far riskier equity investments. Says Swaminathan: "It
disturbs the investment rhythm of the fund manager." On the
other hand, some investors have also begun to speculate in mutual
funds. A small percentage rise in the NAV (net asset value) sees
an exodus from the high net worth individuals to other NFOs.
But nowadays, apart from an entry load of 2.25 per cent, investors
also pay an exit load. It's the investor who bears the additional
costs which shave off close to around 4 per cent in his overall
returns. Additionally, investors also have to bear the brunt of
the initial issue expenses which are reduced in the NAV of the
fund.
Much of the churn seems to arise from the myth of whether a
Rs 10 NAV is cheaper than say a Rs 100 NAV. In reality, both are
the same because the underlying investments are at the current
market price. More launches of new funds have been among the reasons
for a high churn rate. It's the level of the market (Sensex) that
determines if investors have entered at lower or higher levels,
not the NAV of a fund. Says Sachdev: "It's not that investors
aren't feeling the pinch of churn, but being financial illiterate,
they blindly follow distributors and are always caught on the
wrong foot."
Also, consider taxes. Every time you churn your portfolio by
moving from one fund to another in less than a year, there's a
liability of short-term capital gains tax at the rate of 10 per
cent. For instance, assume an investor enters a fund at an NAV
of Rs 20 per unit at the index level of 10,000 in the month of
June. If the market rises by 10 per cent in September, the NAV
surges to Rs 22 per unit. If the investor decides to move out
by booking profit and entering another NFO at Rs 10 per unit at
the index level of 11,000, he is a clear loser. Here's how? An
investor will have to pay a 10 per cent tax, which will result
in net returns of 9 per cent post-taxes. Add to that the exit
load that can range from 1 to 2 per cent.
Apart from a direct loss of the investible surplus, there's
also an indirect loss of time besides an opportunity cost of staying
out of the market. Much of the gains go in vain as the deployment
of the money mobilised through an NFO takes at least two-to-four
months. If the market rises further during the process, a fund
manager is likely to buy the same stocks at a higher price only
adding to your costs.
If you must switch out of a fund, make sure that's it for a
long-term goal like rebalancing your portfolio rather than a short-term
one like profit booking. Says Hemant Rustagi, CEO, Wiseinvest
Advisors, "switching can be necessary at times. You can't
invest in equity and sleep over the investment. There is a constant
need to keep a watch on your portfolio, if there is a need to
rebalance asset allocation." For instance, in a situation
when mid-caps aren't doing well, investors should realign their
portfolio and move into large-cap stocks.
Short-term churning will only add to the constant pressure of
keeping a tab on your investments and worrying about its performance
daily. Says Sachdev: "Investors should determine their goals
and have a minimum investment horizon of three years, than speculating
in funds. You have to give time to your fund manager to perform
and have faith in his investment call." If you want to build
wealth over the long-term, stay put.
NEWS ROUND-UP
A Golden Opportunity
Gold ETFs
are set to debut in India. What does it mean for you?
By Mahesh Nayak
The market regulator has given investors one more reason to smile.
On January 17, the Securities & Exchange Board of India (SEBI)
gave the green signal to two Indian fund houses-Benchmark Mutual
Fund and UTI AMC-to launch Gold Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs).
India will be the fifth country in the world after Australia,
US, UK and South Africa to launch gold ETFs. What this means is
that investors can now invest in gold just as they do with mutual
funds.
Gold
ETF Basics |
Exchange-traded funds are mutual fund
schemes that are traded like shares on stock exchanges and
are a proxy for a market index, a sector or a commodity |
Gold ETFs will hold gold as the underlying
asset
These funds will be linked to gold prices
and will not be actively managed
Investors can opt for Gold ETFs instead of
directly holding gold bars or ornaments |
Paper Gold
A gold ETF is an exchange-traded mutual fund unit listed and
traded on a stock exchange, just like stocks. Gold is the underlying
asset for the units of that fund. Every gold ETF unit represents
a definite quantity of pure gold and the traded price of that
unit moves in tandem with the price of the metal. Unlike in the
commodity market where gold trades on a future date, trading in
gold ETFs is done on a spot basis in electronic form, and the
settlement period is T+2 (the day on which trading is done plus
two days). Another advantage: the gold ETF is a piece of paper
that can be dematerialised just like a normal share. In contrast,
the gold that investors buy from commodities exchanges comes in
the form of ingots, bars, biscuits and coins, making physical
transfers costly and risky. Says Rajan Mehta, Executive Director,
Benchmark AMC: "In principle, buying gold ETFs is similar
to buying securities in the equity market. The benefit is that
investors can buy really small quantities-as low as one unit,
which is the equivalent of one gram of gold-unlike in the commodites
market, where he has to buy minimum 10 gram, and that too, in
physical form."
Small Investors to Profit
ETFs aren't suited for those who want to buy gold for making
ornaments or for other manufacturing purposes as the securities
cannot be exchanged for the underlying metal. It is meant for
investors who wish to diversify their portfolios to minimise risk
from external factors. This effectively means that institutional
and high net worth customers, who want to consume gold, will not
enter this market. In 2006, India, which is the world's largest
gold market, imported an estimated 800 tonnes of the yellow metal.
According to the new regulations, gold ETFs will be treated
as debt MFs. This means short-term capital gains will be taxed
at 30 per cent and long-term capital gains at 10 per cent. Incidentally,
physical gold worth over Rs 15 lakh attracts a wealth tax of 1
per cent per annum. Apart from the investment angle, gold ETFs
are safer than buying gold from commodity exchanges as investors
don't have to worry about purity. The custodian will have to get
the 99.995 purity gold in his custody certified. Secondly, the
gold bought will also be insured to secure the value of the ETFs.
The valuation is done on the basis of the morning price quoted
on the London Bullion Markets Association (LBMA) in us dollars
per troy ounce for gold having a purity of 995 parts per 1,000.
It will be subject to the adjustment for conversion to metric
measures as per standard conversion of us dollars into rupees
according to the RBI reference rate declared by the Foreign Exchange
Dealers Association of India (FEDAI).
Despite having approvals in place, the funds are still about
one-and-a-half months away from launching gold ETFs; so investors
who want to trade or invest in them will have to wait for a while.
Not
Just Another Binge
There's a cost to splurging. So before you
pull out your wallet, check what you could lose.
By Clifford Alvares
Want to know how you can turn unnecessary extravagance into a fortune?
It's not that difficult and it certainly is not hard work, but it
only involves a little sacrifice, particularly if you are among
the big spenders as Usha Thorat, 36, a businesswoman discovered.
Over the years, Usha developed a habit of buying, among many other
things, over 100 pairs of branded shoes of over Rs 1,000 each. She
also purchased over 50 pairs of expensive glares, 25 watches, and
more than 300 sarees. That apart, off late, Thorat has been flipping
mobile phones and she has changed about 20 models so far.
It's not that high-flying Thorat has used all the things she
has purchased. Some of the shoes and sarees have been lying unopened
for years. Besides, she also has the habit of buying books and
eating out at classy restaurants. And all this is costing her
a tidy sum of money. Not only is she spending about 50 per cent
of her current income of Rs 1 lakh, she's also blowing away capital
creation of the future.
Effects of Splurging
There's a far bigger loss of money for Thorat. In fact, a steady
accumulation of money into savings instruments such as provident
funds or equity mutual funds and stocks can turn to a tidy sum
over the years. Instead of buying your next new mobile phone,
just sock away that money regularly in a mutual fund. It's among
the most simple forms of accumulating money and it can turn your
thousands into crores over the long haul.
Consider this, if you are smoking a pack of Marlboro Lights
every day, your cost per day is Rs 80, which works out to Rs 29,200
per year. Instead, had you invested that money every year in,
say, a provident fund account that gives a return of 8 per cent
per annum, you would have a tidy corpus of Rs 33,07,870 over a
30-year period. The aggressive investor could instead choose to
invest in stocks where, if the returns are in the range of 20
per cent per annum for the next 30 years, the accumulation is
a little over Rs 3.45 crore (see The High Cost of Splurging).
One main reason for the growth in the corpus is due to the benefit
of compounding. Over the years, interest accumulates on the interest
which accumulates more interest and that helps to build a tidy
sum of money in the long run. The accumulation tends to multiply
rapidly as the years progress, which is why even a small sum turns
into a fortune over the long term. If you eat out every week and
spend around Rs 2,000 per week, it tots up close to Rs 1,17,81,453.
The magic of compounding works best over longer periods of time.
If you invest the same amount of money for, say, a period of 20
years as against 30 in the above example, you will accumulate
Rs 47,59,244. But instead, if you sock that money away for 35
years, you would have added more than Rs 1.79 crore to your net
worth.
One need not necessarily target only the big ticket items for
cost cutting. But you can also tackle other weekly routine areas
such as hiring a video or taking your car out for a long weekend
drive. It's a matter of finding that wasteful expenditure and
taking steps to cut it down.
Tackling it
But before you do that, you need to have a defined goal and
plan to find areas that require cost-cutting. If too much of money
is spent because of the credit card, then you should be willing
to give it up or risk spending more against it. Your plan can
identify the spending areas that are not important or which can
help you identify the debt that does more harm than good. It's
best to avoid making spontaneous purchases. When you go shopping,
go with a list and don't buy anything that is not on the list.
The next step is to find out how you can make investments easy
and hassle-free. These days, with most of the banking done online,
most websites offer a host of services to manage your money. So
in terms of alternatives, there are many options that you can
choose to sock away the extra savings. But among the easiest is
to regularly invest in a mutual fund through the systematic investment
plan (sip). It's not too much of a hassle as the funds will automatically
get debited from your bank account into the fund at that day's
NAV.
Start saving with small amounts and see it grow. Once you find
an investment that you are comfortable with and see how it accumulates
over, say, a six-month period, that will encourage you to stick
to your savings plan. If you do that for a 30-year period, even
with small amounts, the results are gigantic. Thorat's just begun
on the savings journey. So, start now.
Where
There Is A Will
Ensuring the right inheritance of your legacy
is easier with a will. Here's why and how you should write one.
By Nitya Varadarajan
|
"A will should be spelt out clearly
and should be without ambiguities-then there is no room for
the inheritors to squabble among themselves"
Kalyan Jhabakh/ Senior lawyer/Surana & Surana |
When you want to distribute your wealth according
to your wishes after you are gone, there's one thing that you
must write out: a will. There are obvious benefits to executing
a will well in advance. It ensures fair treatment of your property.
As is often the case where there's no will, the heirs squabble
among themselves for inheritance. You must spell out a will between
30-35 years, if you haven't done so earlier-since the unexpected
can happen any time. You can always re-fresh wills or alter the
existing one at later dates depending on changed circumstances.
And if you are older, it's never too late to make one.
The Process of Willing
There are two types of wills- oral and written. An oral will
is when a person speaks his intentions aloud in front of witnesses.
But in an oral will, there's a possibility of misinterpretation,
unless the witnesses are impeccable and fully understand what
the person wishes. Besides, it helps to articulate your will clearly.
Says Kalyan Jhabakh, senior lawyer at Surana & Surana: "A
will should be spelt out clearly and should be without ambiguities-then
there is no room for the inheritors to squabble among themselves."
And a written will goes a long way in ensuring that. "A hand-written
will, with some foresight and planning, is much better,'' he adds.
A will can be written on plain paper and needs two witnesses-
the last being compulsory. It has to be made under 'one's free
will and without pressure'. You can register it with the state
authorities for a nominal sum (around Rs 100) where you can be
sure that it will be safe. Usually a sealed envelope is given
to the registering authority, which makes note of the date. During
execution, the court will call for it and make the intentions
of the deceased known.
Why it is important to make a will |
Your property gets distributed in
accordance with your wishes |
It ensures that your heirs are not left with
a muddled state of affairs to decode and decipher
It ensures amity in the family even if there may be disappointment
in some quarters
It cuts down on additional and unnecessary legal expenses
by your heirs on account of squabbling and disputes in asset
distribution
Ensures that your heirs don't curse you just because you
neglected making a will even though they will eventually
inherit your property
In case of minor heirs, money can be fuelled into a trust
and handed over at an appropriate date |
If there are several registered, the last is always taken. Even
if the deceased is not able to register his final will, as long
as he makes it clear that this one is the last and is making amendments
to the previous will that was registered, the will should sail
through smoothly.
Every will needs an executor who probates the will and who is
quite often the key beneficiary. An executor could also be a neutral
member, usually nominated by the maker of the will. It is always
the executor who has to prove the validity of the will, if challenged.
If the assets are substantial, it is better that one consults
a lawyer and accounts for the same carefully. It's necessary that
the person remembers his assets and their value as any lapses
on this count could result in disputes among the inheritors.
The probation period before the will is finally accepted generally
takes five to six months-the court follows a formula so that people
are given enough time to make their objections. It also allows
the will to be viewed by all the parties concerned. The process
takes a little while, but not much can be done about it. If there
is immovable property involved, the court satisfies itself on
property assessment through its valuers. A court fee has to be
paid on that valuation-in a metro, it is usually 3 per cent of
the total value or Rs 3,000 for every Rs 1 lakh.
If the inheritor leaves behind a large house to the beneficiary
and executor, the latter will have to cough up high court fees,
but the same can be provided for in the will. (In today's spiralling
real estate and property costs, this has to be considered.) If
all the inheritors agree with the will (i.e., amicable acceptance),
then on that basis, a family settlement can also be arrived at,
which can be done out of court. A lawyer is not really needed
for this, but somebody with experience of arbitration and such
matters is a must. The other inheritors sign an affidavit releasing
their right to the immovable properties and make it over to the
'willed' inheritor. These affidavits have to be registered with
the local state authority-but this process could sometimes work
out cheaper. Tamil Nadu, for instance, has fixed a cap of Rs 10,000
for family settlements, irrespective of the value of the property.
However, it must be noted here that nobody can subvert a will
and arrive at a family settlement just because they don't happen
to like a clause by the deceased. If a real will crops up later,
that could lead to litigation.
Usually, wills get probated in the place where the deceased
resided last, but in case of NRIs, special provisions are made
for their property in India. If there's no will, the disputes
are heard in courts where the property is located, which, of course,
could be inconvenient for an outstation inheritor. If a person
has not left behind a will, then the estate is divided equally
among the family members. And if you don't want that to happen,
make sure you will your property to the people you want.
|