|
Risk Management
2000
ContinuedOf course, the treasurer must ensure that the timings of foreign exchange
inflows match those of outflows. If they do not, payments have to be rescheduled to create
the natural hedge. Other foreign currency earnings could be generated by way of interest,
dividends, and royalties on investments abroad by corporates. Although the regulations
restrict the amount of such investment outflows at present, the move towards capital
account convertibility will per force ease these constraints.
CURRENCY DIVERSIFICATION. The basic lesson of portfolio
theory, which underlies most of today's finance, is simple: a diversified mix of
commodities is less risky than a single commodity. So long as currency movements are not
highly correlated, conducting transactions in multiple currencies will reduce the impact
of a sudden, and substantial, depreciation in any one currency. Agrees Anil Jaggia, 36,
head (trade finance distribution, Asia), Citibank: "To protect their bottomlines,
corporates will have to diversify their exposures by borrowing in different currencies, or
by importing from different countries."
Sure, the downside of such a strategy is limited, but the upside is truncated as well.
The gains of a sudden rupee appreciation vis-a-vis other currencies will be diluted. More
subtly, it creates exposures in currencies with which the company may not be familiar. The
treasury team will then have to track a host of cross-currency movements to gauge the
impact on the rupee. Says Suresh Kumar, 35, the general manager of the Rs 702-crore Ruchi
Soya: "If a company has only dollar exposures, it should confine itself to the dollar
rather than trading in a third currency. But it can opt for a third currency depending on
its appetite for risk." Concurs Yeswant Rao, 46, the deputy general manager of the Rs
982-crore Arvind Mills: "In future, firms will have to choose their borrowing
currency carefully."
The Synthetic Hedges
FORWARD CONTRACTS. The simplest of the derivative
securities, the forward contract is an agreement to buy, or sell, an asset at a certain
time for a certain price. Since forwards--unlike futures--are not traded on exchanges, the
only exit option is through the cancellation of the forward cover. To cover its short-term
foreign currency obligations, a company expecting the rupee to depreciate can lock in a
rate at a specified premium over the current spot rate.
Clearly, the decision to hedge, and the extent of hedging, will depend on the
comparison between the current forward premiums and the extent of the depreciation, or
appreciation, expected. One of the more famous maxims of economics, the interest rate
parity theorem, states that in perfect capital markets, forward premiums mirror interest
rate differentials. In the advanced economies, the forward rates are a function of such
differentials. In our imperfect, and shallow, foreign exchange market, such premiums have
gyrated in response to supply-demand mismatches.
Blame, in part, the restrictions on the money market. For instance, the imposition of a
Cash Reserve Ratio (CRR) on inter-bank borrowings caused call market rates to collapse
every reporting Friday as bankers scrambled to minimise their liabilities. Fortunately,
the Monetary & Credit Policy for the first half of 1997-98 (M&CP, 97) has done
away with the inter-bank reserve requirement, paving the way for the evolution of a term
money market with varying maturities.
Not only will the emergence of a rupee-yield curve lead to the more realistic pricing
of forward contracts, it will also extend the duration of those contracts. At present,
although authorised dealers are permitted to offer forward cover for durations upto a
year, forward deals that stretch beyond six months are rare. To hedge their long-term
exposures, treasurers often have to roll over six-month forwards--a hedging strategy that
only partially reduces the exchange rate risk since the forward rate at the time of the
roll-over is uncertain. Explains S.S. Kelkar, 57, the executive director of the Rs
1,105-crore Bombay Dyeing: "With increasing liquidity at the far end of the yield
curve, corporates will find it easier to manage their long-term foreign exchange
exposures."
CURRENCY OPTIONS. While the potential of the upside is
limited since forward contracts are tied to a particular rate, options grant the holder
the right--not the obligation--to buy or sell the asset at a specified price known as the
exercise price. An exporter due to receive deutsche marks (DM) three months from now can
hedge against the risk of its depreciation by buying a three-month DM put option. If,
contrary to expectations, the DM appreciates, the exporter will not be denied the windfall
gains since the option does not have to be exercised. Effectively, the put sets a floor on
the DM to be received. Conversely, a company that has to make a DM payment can insure
against its appreciation by purchasing DM call options. This caps the cost of the DM to be
paid.
Naturally, this flexibility does not come free. Options, unlike forwards, require the
payment of a premium upfront. In that lies the explanation for its surprisingly rare use
by the Indian treasurer. Complains Hari Mundra, 47, the CFO of the Rs 5,641-crore RPG
Group: "Despite their flexibility, options are not a viable alternative because of
their large upfront cost." Premiums are fat because the banks that write such options
are faced with a paucity of alternatives to hedge their exposure.
Ergo, there are very few players in these markets. The numbers, however, will jump
since capital account convertibility will allow corporates and banks to access the foreign
exchange and money markets abroad, increasing the hedging possibilities. Further, as a
proper rupee yield curve begins to take shape, the banks can price such options more
appropriately.
CURRENCY SWAPS. A swap is a simultaneous spot
transaction combined with a series of forward contracts that exchanges one set of
recurring obligations for another. While forwards and options are essentially short-term
tools, the swap enables the CFO to hedge his longer-term exposures. Corporates with ECBs
can slough off the foreign exchange risk for the entire life of the loan by simply
swapping their foreign currency liabilities for rupee liabilities.
The counter-party to this transaction: corporates that are not able to tap the markets
abroad, but are willing to assume the currency risk. Swaps are offered on a routine basis
by banks abroad. Here, however, their growth has been stunted. Until the M&CP, 97,
allowed dealers to run swap books and offer rupee-foreign exchange swaps without having to
obtain the prior approval of the Reserve Bank of India (RBI), there was a virtual ban on
swap arrangements. Already, volumes are climbing in response. For example, while the Rs
9,004-crore Reliance Industries and the Rs 3,508-crore ipcl have entered into a five-year
swap arrangement, totalling $17 million, in a three-year deal brokered by Citibank, the Rs
1,865-crore bses is swapping a Rs 18-crore rupee liability for a $5-million dollar
liability linked to the LIBOR.
More |