Yogesh
Parikh stares forlornly at his prized possession. It's a German
five-colour offset printing machine worth Rs 1.8 crore. Well, it
was. It's now a blackened hulk of metal, like the camera and plate-making
unit. Just so much scrap sitting inside his half-burnt factory at
Vatwa, a grimy industrial suburb, 20 km from Ahmedabad. Parikh,
50, brought the machine costing Rs 1.8 crore in 2001 to profit from
Gujarat's industrial boom: he used to print international quality
packing material and publish local books. His only solace is that
his entire staff of 70 survived-but that's only because Gujarat
was shut down when the mob descended on his pride, profits and joy.
He's just totalled up his losses: Rs 2.7 crore.
Insurance will cover Rs 1.32 crore, but his workers, both Muslim
and Hindu, are only just trickling in, themselves traumatised. "It
took me four years to build up to this scale," says Parikh
softly. "But it took just four hours to destroy everything."
Set up in 1964, Parikh's company, Gujarat Offset, had never witnessed
problems in Gujarat's previous big communal riots of 1969, 1984
and 1992. "While there were Hindu-Muslim conflicts before,
never have I seen a bitterness so all pervasive," says Arvind
N. Lalbhai, Chairman of Arvind Mills.
|
"Business is down
to 10 per cent of what it used to be during this peak season"
Shah has lost sales worth 60 lakh in two months, and recovery
will not happen until free movement of transporter, suppliers
and retailers in possible
Bharat Gopal Das Shah, 59,
Textile Manufacturer |
Both psychologically and socially, there has
never been a more testing time for Gujarati businessmen.
Instead of the 72 hours that the Gujarat government
claimed it took to subdue the riots, parts of the state continued
to flare up 72 days later. And as the riots cleaved Gujarat's industrious
society bloodily into Muslim and Hindu, thousands of businesses
either burned to the ground or lost workers, orders-and credibility.
|
"I had built the
business in the last four years and I lost it in four hours"
Damage of Rs 2.30 crore. He's started work with some machines
that his workers managed to save and is banking on insurance
to rebuild everything from scratch.
Yogesh Parikh, 50, Managing
Director, Gujarat Offset |
If you have to understand the future of business
in Gujarat, here's the first thing to remember: don't believe the
numbers. "The direct damage to industry will not exceed Rs
60 crore, at the most," declares R.J. Shah, Chief Industrial
Advisor to the Government of Gujarat. His boss, Industries Minister
Suresh Mehta, told BT (See ''Gujarat Is The Ultimate State For Investments
Even Today'') that the effect on business has more to do with propaganda
and less with reality. "The total damage in terms capital expenditure,
production loss, and turnover loss is estimated to be Rs 664 crore,
according to a survey that I commissioned in the fourth week of
March," says Mehta dismissively. "It is negligible."
And as he points out, the riots did not by any means ravage the
entire state.
But by the government's own figures, made available
to BT (See Ravages Of The Riots) by bureaucrats, the damage to thousands
of small businesses that form the backbone of Gujarat's entrepreneurial
society hasn't even been counted. Areas that have faced the worst
ravages continue to be out of bounds for Gujarat officials. In fact,
the Gujarat Industries Corporation office has already been attacked
thrice, so data collection is a risky-and mostly ignored-proposition.
And it's here that the maximum collateral damage of the bloodletting
(the official toll is 900, but it could easily be more) was wrought-on
small-time traders, shopkeepers, home industries and service providers
like garage owners. ''The effect on large industries is negligible,''
confirms Sunil R. Parekh, Senior Director, CII. ''Smaller businesses
faced the brunt.''
Gujarat's bureaucrats and politicians refuse
to look beyond statistics to see the state's-and India's-bigger
problem: its image as an industrial powerhouse and safe investment
destination; the absolute communal divide that has formed in an
economy where Hindu and Muslim (10 per cent of the population) are
inextricably linked; and the fact that Gujarat's problems affect
India's economic stability.
''If the riots stop right now, there is some
hope of retrieving Gujarat's lost image,'' says Ganesh Nayak, Executive
Director of pharma firm Zydus Cadila, which wasn't too badly hit,
aside from having to send some shipments by air instead of road.
''Otherwise it will take a serious toll on (the state's) perception
as a safe destination.''
CORPORATE VOICE |
"It is likely to have an adverse impact on FDI.
But how long it will last is difficult to guess. Would any
politician invest his own money in such a hostile environment?"
Rahul Bajaj, Chairman, Bajaj
Auto
"The situation today is such that investors have
to explain to their managers why they are not getting out
of India before the others do. There is virtually a race to
get out of India."
Surjit Bhalla, President,
Oxus Fund Management
"If (Gujarat) distracts the government from economic
priorities of the day, which it appears to be doing ... the
implications from a rating point of view could be significant."
Paul Rawkins, Senior Director,
Fitch Ratings
"We've done reasonably well. (McDonald's) being
a family restaurant, people have been coming here to cheer
themselves up given the gloom due to the riots."
Amit Jatia, Managing Director,
Hardcastle Restaurants
|
Singed By The Fires
For upwardly mobile Ahmedabad, the bloody riots
seem a distant memory. The crowds are returning to Fun Republic
and its six cinema screens, department store and speciality restaurants
on Satellite road. It is the first such mega-entertainment centre
set up by the Essel group, which is taking the concept to 12 other
cities. Of course Darshak Mehta, Business and operations Head of
Fun Republic, will tell you how his revenues took a hit as the multiplex
and its 400 staffers were idle during four of the worst blood-soaked
days, and how visitors are down to, oh, just 1,000 a day (from 7,000
on week days, 12,000 on weekends).
Ahmedabad's reputation as a hard-working, hard-playing
city-and the Gujarati's reputation for bouncing back from earthquakes,
cyclones and riots-is legendary. Nowhere is this more evident than
at the city's spanking new 175-seat McDonald's (the launch was on
April 21, delayed by 21 days because of the riots), already drawing
customers on a daily basis. "I think people have been coming
here to cheer themselves up given the gloom due to the riots,"
says Amit Jatia, Managing Director, Hardcastle Restaurants.
But behind the veneer of normality-sometimes
bizarre-there are hundreds of businesses struggling to stay afloat,
hidden from the casual visitor's eye. "Our industry has been
virtually wiped out," says Jahangir R.J. Cama, Managing Director
of the Cama Group and owner of the 110-year-old landmark, Cama Hotel.
His occupancy rates hover between 15 to 20 per cent. Obviously,
visitors are few for now. Many Muslim-owned hotels were of course
simply razed.
Apart from these and numerous roadside businesses,
the greatest immediate impact is on the industrious little factories
that have made Gujarat India's number one in exports.
About 60 per cent of textile industries, which
exported Rs 2,425 crore ($5 billion) last year, are located in and
around riot-hit Ahmedabad areas. Most of them will tell you how
workers, mostly from the tense walled-city areas, simply aren't
turning up. Orders have been cancelled because raw material supplies
have been set back by more than a month. Raw material fabric prices
are rising because of a terrorised transport sector, and worse,
foreign buyers aren't coming to India, not even to Mumbai and Delhi,
putting a big question mark on future earnings. Numerous countries
in the neighbourhood and as far afield as Latin America are waiting
to fill the breaches.
The core of Gujarati enterprise-the small-scale
sector of 2.65 lakh units-was the very badly hit, but only 128 damage
claims have been filed so far by owners too busy or traumatised
to do so. Many of these units manufactured chemicals, pharma products
and dyes. "The riots were a nightmare for us," says Satish
Shah, Managing Director of Indocol Chem, a 100 per cent export unit
making dyes and dye intermediates. Shah believes his sector will
earn Rs 600 crore less than the Rs 3,000 crore it exported last
year.
"Gujarat Is The Ultimate State For Investments
Even Today" |
|
Suresh Mehta, Industry Minister, Gujarat |
A seemingly eternal No. 2 in any BJP ministry in Gujarat,
moderate Suresh Chandra Roop Shanker Mehta, a
former Chief Minister and now Industry Minister has always spoken
up. His latest was to urge Narendra Modi to crack down on the
endless rioting. Nevertheless, he firmly dismissed all visions
of doom in an interview with BT's Vinod
Mahanta. Here's what he said:
On the impact to Gujarat's image: There is more propaganda
and less reality. The adverse publicity has affected Gujarat's
economy more than the riots. But the impact is short term;
sooner or later the world will know the reality. Even today
Gujarat is the ultimate state for investment. After the initial
four days of rioting there has been no targeting of industry.
There is a liquidity crunch as within Ahmedabad the walled
city is the heart of business. So due to tension, the circulation
of money is constricted, and that has brought down a slowdown
in the local economy.
On foreign caution: These governments have their
own agenda. They have formed an impression that if their nationals
invest in Gujarat, their investments will be hurt. They will
then have to pay for the insurance of these investments.
On the financial burden of the earthquake and riots:
The earthquake was a blessing in disguise. Kutch has developed
from an industrially backward area into an area with potential,
after the Centre and the state government announced sales
tax and excise incentives. There has been a rousing response
from industry. And the communal scenario will not be a problem
for the state either.
On Modi's right to remain as chief minister: (smiling)
Narendra Modi is our leader.
On where Modi has failed: (laughing) If I tell you
this, I will be saying it all. No comments.
On repairing the damage: First of all let the situation
calm down. Then let people think without prejudice. Gujaratis
are Gujaratis. Time will prove that Gujarat is a state with
its own glory.
|
Not only did exporters fail to fulfil export
obligations because of transport disruption and absent workers,
raw material prices shot up by as much as 25 per cent. Even if the
tenuous peace holds, many foreign customers may already have signed
up with competitors on the Pacific Rim.
Disquiet Beyond The Embers
Gujarat has some big-ticket investments lined
up-and they aren't going anywhere (one reason of course being that
given the locational advantages, there's nowhere else to go). Rs
5,200 crore is coming from the Royal Dutch Shell Company at Hazira
Port; Rs 500 crore by General Motors, British Gas is coming in.
Production hasn't been affected at all at biggies like Essar Steel,
Reliance, IPCL.
As the Gujarat government so shrilly likes
to point out in full-page newspaper ads-which routinely accuse the
media and unnamed enemies of propaganda-life goes on. Indeed it
does. Apart from a four-day shutdown at GM's plant in Halol and
a few Corsas burned, heavy industry was largely untouched.
So why do so many see a problem in the future
for both Gujarat and India?
"Pictures of marauding mobs looting and
burning shops even in distant Ahmedabad is enough to scare away
the bravest of investors because it is perception that drives investments,"
says C. Jayaram, Executive Director of Kotak Mahindra Finance in
Mumbai. "The situation is such that investors have to explain
to their managers why they are not getting out of India before others
do," says Surjit Bhalla, President, Oxus Fund Management, Mumbai.
Uttam Dave, CEO, PKF Consultants, points out that the typical foreign
tourist-the riots occurred in the off-season months-who can barely
distinguish between neighbouring countries is unlikely to distinguish
between Gujarat and India. ''The damaging images of Gujarat are
hardly likely to enthuse the foreign tourist to come to India on
vacation," says Subhash Goel, Chairman, Stic Travels, dryly.
The tourism sector was going through a crisis because of instability
in India's neighbourhood over the last year. There's little doubt
that Gujarat will further impact tourism arrivals in India.
''The events in Gujarat have overshadowed the
reform process,'' says Shelly Shetty, Director, Fitch Ratings. Shetty,
who draws up ratings for India, says Gujarat, combined with the
high and persistent fiscal deficits, ''will continue to have an
adverse impact on business confidence, potentially holding back
rapid economic growth''. Any slowdown in economic growth, say experts,
will have adverse repercussions for governments revenues. Gujarat
comes at a very bad time. Already FDI inflows fell from Rs 1,766
crore in March 2001 to Rs 329 crore in March 2002. April has seen
a net investment of Rs 140 crore, indicating a continuing nervousness
on the part of foreign investors.
Gujarat's politicians, bureaucrats and businessmen
understand the power of perception only too well. In order to maintain
the façade that things are back to normal, many business
houses in Gujarat even hide their real losses. Many whom BT contacted
were unwilling to speak out, admitting there was tremendous pressure
from the government to underplay violence and losses.
The Importance of Community
Perception is important. But more important
is reality. And the reality is that whatever the previous ill-feeling
and violence, Hindu-Muslim economic bonds were never broken. Now,
with the steadily hardening religious divide and segregation, the
business community is only just beginning to realise the consequences
of broken bonds.
Rajesh Gandhi, Managing Director of the Rs
150-crore Vadilal Ice Creams, knows just how deeply Hindus and Muslims
are intertwined, how violence against one affects the other. He
lost 100 ice-cream vending machines when at least 90 restaurants
of the non-controversial Shia Chelia community were targeted by
rioters Ahmedabad.
The Chelia community often run restaurants
with names like Tulsi and Radha, but none of that mattered. The
lists of Muslim-owned businesses were methodically drawn up. "This
is the first time we were targeted economically as well," says
Naseer Khan, a Chelia, who lost one of three hotels to arson. He
says he cannot even think of rebuilding until peace is restored
and the threats recede. Here's the irony: almost all his staff consisted
of Hindus, Rajasthani workers who fled or migrated to other cities.
So too with owners of the burned out hulks of the "Edwards"
stores, quiet Dawoodi Bohras who used the name as a common brand
for their dry cleaning stores.
At the other end of the spectrum is Nimish
Patel, owner of Shri Somnath Carriers, a transport company forced
to sell 10 of his fleet of 60 trucks because this terrified drivers-most
of his drivers and mechanics were Muslims-haven't yet reported for
work. "If the problem continues for some more time, we will
be out of business," says Patel.
The transport sector continues to bleed even
though the riots have subsided. More than 500 trucks have already
been burned, mostly on highways, resulting in what R. Seshasayee,
Managing Director of Ashok Leyland, says is "a fear psychosis
among truck drivers, mostly Muslim". Ahmedabad's biggest transport
companies are now moving office from the riot-racked, old-city areas
to industrial suburbs, but they haven't yet figured out how to get
support services like mechanics-again, mostly Muslim-to move there.
The one sector that is realigning itself to
the polarisation is real estate. Property rates are falling in the
old-city areas-warrens that easily become battle grounds-and rising
in areas where migration is going on, Hindu and Muslim. If the process
of tearing apart Hindu and Muslim societies spreads through other
sectors of the economy, expect some serious displacements and rising
costs.
But the truth is that whatever happens, the
economy will bounce back-eventually. Only, there will be a few bitter,
and brutal, new truths to live with.
additional reporting Abir Pal, Moinak
Mitra, and Subhajit Banerjee
|