|
Apothecaries' Brijesh Regal (centre) with
co-promoters C.P. Popli (left) Madhulika Kaushal: Clinical
research apart, the firm has made tentative strides into an
emerging area---training |
Vidur
Kaushik, the 49-year-old chief Executive Officer of SRL Ranbaxy,
was not quite expecting a standing ovation when he went on a routine
client visit to one of the largest drug companies in the US last
year along with his colleague Dr. Sumedha Sahni, Director (Operations
and Clinical Trials). But that is what the surprised duo got for
supporting trials of a new drug out of India that saved the multinational
three years in time and millions of dollars in costs. But Kaushik
does not have time to fill in the details of the story because he
is just about to leave for what promises to be an interesting trip
to Britain. Barely managing to hide his excitement, he says in a
hushed tone: "We have been approached by some international
companies for providing diagnostic services in India."
That's not just a first for an Indian network
of labs, but also proof of the world pharma industry waking up to
an entirely new potential of India: As a huge market for testing
of new generation drugs, or clinical trials in the industry parlance.
What happened to all the concerns about India being a logistics
and bureaucratic nightmare? Well, the concerns have been wiped away
by the sheer beauty of economics. Consider this: In the world pharma
industry, it takes about $900 million (Rs 4,140 crore) and 10-15
years to get a new drug to market. About two-thirds of this amount,
or about Rs 2,700 crore, is spent on testing the drug to prove its
efficacy and safety through an elaborate process of clinical trials
(See Clinical Trials For Dummies). Bring the test drug to India
and, voila!, a company can halve the cost and time. "The USP
for the country is world-class services at Indian prices,"
says Kaushik.
Small wonder then, a bevy of drug giants including
Pfizer, Aventis, Glaxosmithkline, Novartis, and Eli Lilly is making
a beeline to India. While specific numbers are hard to come by,
almost everybody agrees that the number of trials in India is increasing
with each year. Currently, there are 80 trial sites across the country,
and more than one trial could be happening at each of these sites.
"The most exciting thing going for India is the large pool
of patients who have never used any drug (referred to as treatment-naïve
in medicalese)," says Brijesh Regal, Managing Director of Apothecaries
Ltd, a contract research organisation (CRO).
WHY INDIA?
A host of reasons makes Inida an attractive
market for clinical trials. |
ECONOMY
Clinical trials in India cost half or a third of a developed
country's and take as little time to complete
SUPPLY
India has a large population that has not received any medication
or, in industry lingo, is treatment naïve
SKILLS
India has a large pool of qualified, but inexpensive technicians
required to carry out clinical trials
REGULATION
Norms are to be eased, besides which product patent starting
2005 ensures greater security of data
TECHNOLOGY
An increasing role of software in clinical trials further
helps strengthen the India advantage
|
Regal's firm operates in both the main facets
of contract research: a data intensive and logistics part (patient
recruitment, data capture, data organisation and its submission
to the regulatory authorities) and one that focuses on chemical
analysis (of the kind provided by SRL Ranbaxy). The company has
made tentative strides into a third emerging area: training. Doctors,
nurses, research managers, and medical writers associated with clinical
trials need to be trained in good clinical practices (GCP) to meet
the norms required by the international drug regulators.
In fact, the mantra for success in the business
is a high-flying GCP flag. Since the clinical trial data needs to
be submitted to drug authorities in Europe and the US (the US Food
and Drug Administration, for example), there are impromptu audits
by their representatives and also by the companies that have outsourced
the trials. SRL Ranbaxy, for example, is certified by the College
of American Pathologists, the Indian government's National Accreditation
Board for Testing and Calibration Laboratories and has been audited
by clinical study sponsors like Pfizer, Smithkline Beecham, and
Eli Lilly. It is expecting a direct audit from the US FDA soon.
A Game Of Precision
While the typical investment required to set
up a full-fledged CRO is not too high at $2-2.5 million, or Rs 9.2-11.5
crore, (Ernst & Young estimates), a clinical trial is a game
of precision and the cost of one blip in administering the drug
or documenting the impact can be very severe. In fact, it could
nullify the entire trial. "It is not a back office function.
It is state of the art. There cannot be any differences in clinical
trial done at Detroit or Delhi. Both are similar in nature, complexity
or position in the value chain," emphasises the president of
Neeman Medical International, Dr. Vijai Kumar. A division of Max
India set up in technical collaboration with Harvard Medical International,
Neeman has seen a five-fold jump in patient trials over the last
two years. It is currently managing clinical trials at over 30 medical
institutions around the country for multinational pharmaceutical
companies in the fields of ophthalmology, infectious diseases, and
gastroenterology.
CLINICAL TRIALS FOR DUMMIES
Trials are aimed at establishing the safety
and efficacy of a drug. Typically, after pre-clinical testing
on animals, there are four phases that each drug has to go through. |
Phase 1
First trial of a drug on humans, usually healthy volunteers,
to establish basic safety of drug
Sample size: 20-80
Phase II
Study for side-effects, risks and efficacy of drug
Sample Size: 100-300
Phase III
Aimed at establishing safety and determining ideal dosage
of the drug on a wider patient population
Sample Size:1,000-5,000
Phase IV
Post-marketing trials
|
The upside for the country is that there are
enough patients here for diseases that are top of the concern list
in the developed countries like HIV/AIDS and cancer. India is home
to 25 million diabetic (type II) patients, which is 20 per cent
of the world's diabetic population. The pediatric population is
over 15 million. Says Rabo India in its latest research on the Indian
pharmaceutical industry: "We believe cost savings arising due
to faster patient accrual will be a bigger factor than lower operating
costs."
Pfizer, the world's biggest drug company, is
currently involved in about 20 studies in India and has an in-house
team of more than 100 clinical research professionals. "We
believe that this number reflects the current potential that India
has in clinical R&D," says Shekhar Potkar, Director (Clinical
Research) at Pfizer India.
Pfizer alone spends a staggering $7 billion
(Rs 32,200 crore) on R&D, and of that 70 per cent is spent on
clinical trials. The number of studies is expected to spike sharply
over the next one to two years-product patent comes into force in
2005-as enablers such as IPR and data protection, training and accreditation
of investigators and labs and upgradation of hospital infrastructure
kick in.
The estimates of the addressable opportunity
globally for India vary from $10 billion (Rs 46,000 crore) to multiples
of that. "It is widely believed that by 2008 India can annually
capture about $1 billion of the global contract research opportunity,"
says Utkarsh M. Palnitkar, Partner and head of the life sciences
practice at Ernst & Young. Indeed. Of the eight million patients
involved with 80,000 clinical trials conducted world over last year,
less than a thousand are estimated to be from India.
CROs that have set up shop in the country include
the world's largest, the $2-billion Quintiles, which has ramped
up to 450 employees since it ventured into the country six years
ago. It plans to expand substantially over the next 24 months. "There
is a rather ambitious plan in place," says President of Quintiles
Narges Mahaluxmivala. It has about 20 clinical trials active as
on date.
Another large international player, Covance,
tied up with India's siro Clinpharm earlier this year. Clingene
(part of Biocon group), Wellquest, Lambda, Lotus Labs, Synchron...the
list is expanding. Today clinical trials in India are on for cancer,
diabetes, Parkinson's, cardiac ailments, vaccines, anti-infectives,
psychiatric problems, and a host of other therapeutic areas.
To make India better prepared for the outsourcing
run, the government is slated to allow easing of the norms for clinical
trials. Go ahead. Give it a try. You have nothing to lose but your
ailment.
|