FEB 15, 2004
 Cover Story
 Editorial
 Features
 Trends
 Bookend
 Personal Finance
 Managing
 BT Special
 Back of the Book
 Columns
 Careers
 People

Q&A Ratan Tata
The complete interview with the Tata group chief. What's on his mind, and what he makes of the under-Rs 1-lakh-car idea.


Moody's Upgrade
This debt rating agency has an image of being unpredictable. Yet, its recent upgrade of Indian debt is no surprise, really.

More Net Specials
Business Today,  February 1, 2004
 
 
Bleeding Hearts Galore!

A Woodstockesque mass of humanity including assorted Nobel laureates social activists and peaceniks descends on Mumbai, drawn by an ideal even headier than Free Love or Rock and Roll: a New World Order.

This motley crew of activists from across the world has one common foe: Globalisation

Yepp Or No?

HIC CALIX

Health Notes

BOOKEND

Down with the imperialism. Say no to Globalisation," hollers C.Y. Park into a bullhorn, furiously waving a gigantic red-on-white placard. The slogan is picked up by a motley crew of angry activists. Were it not for their designer shades, New Balance trainers and pronounced accents, Park and his comrades might be mistaken for a bunch of rabid reds exercising their vocal chords on a wintry afternoon in Kolkata's Brigade Parade ground. Only, Park is South Korean, the venue is not red-citadel Kolkata but India's financial capital, Mumbai, and Park and Co. have flown half way across the world to unite with thousands of their ilk in the fight against globalisation.

To a bird, it must look as if a sea of humanity has washed over the 65-acre Nesco ground in Mumbai suburb Goregaon. On the ground, it is sheer bedlam. Sights and sounds explode in a chaotic cacophony as 100,000 people simultaneously try to sing, dance, talk, shout, wave, eat, and be heard. A group of ecstatic tribals waltz down one road, elaborate headgear swaying to the beat of the drums. Another group, this composed of bewildered map-clutching middle-aged Japanese, scurries off the road as three men on 10-foot stilts rush towards it. Petite silk headband-clad Tibetan girls hand out 'Free Tibet' leaflets. And tactile Italians hug everyone around like long lost friends. Drums pound, cymbals clang, pipes do whatever pipes are supposed to do and somewhere a solitary bugle lets out a soulful wail. An incessant stream of messages pours out of the pa system. The air grows heavy with cries of "Zindabad, Zindabad; No War, Only Peace; Stop the Killing", the alarmist content further reinforced by gigantic flags, cardboard cutouts, and ubiquitous placards.

In some ways, the World Social Forum is a bit like the Matrix: no one can really tell you what it is, you have to experience it yourself. One organiser calls it "A mobilisation of public opinion". Another, "A platform for mass organisations across the world to build alliances and raise a resounding cry against globalisation and neo-liberal economic policies." Conceived as an alternative (a word oft used during the five days) to the yearly fat-cat World Economic Forum in the Swiss resort of Davos-scheduled to start after the WSF ends-the first WSF was held in the Brazilian town of Porto Alegre, the Jerusalem for all those into alternative causes, in 2001. "We knew we had to take the forum out of Brazil and India was the first choice," says Chico Whitaker, Founder, Convener, and the "moving spirit" behind WSF.

Peace and protests against war were recurring themes at the WSF jamboree

Under the gargantuan sheds of an abandoned engineering factory this hotchpotch coalition of protectionist labour unions, gender activists, card carrying communists, environmentalists, farmers, peasants, anti-sweat shop protesters, anti-genetic food activists, and antelope savers huddles, for five days and nights living out the WSF motto: Another World is Possible. Every fringe, alternative, minority, dispossessed group one can imagine is here; 2,660 organisations from 132 countries, participating in a staggering 1,200 events that span plenary sessions, conferences, panels, round tables, workshops solidarity meetings, street theatre, film shows, rallies, and marches.

There is no issue or cause that this rag tag bunch of activists doesn't attack with characteristic zeal and aplomb. From land, water, and food sovereignty, to patriarchy and gender discrimination, to militarisation, social security and workers rights, to gay activism and third world debt, everything is fiercely debated and dissected. It doesn't matter what it is as long as you are angry and not afraid to show it.

Ecstatic tribals waltzed down roads, their elaborate headgear swaying to the beat of drums

With his flowing dreadlocks interspersed with multicoloured beads and psychedelic T-shirt, Marco Somma looks more like a Rastafarian than a member of Movimento Non-Violento, a Rome-based organisation inspired by Mahatma Gandhi. "We are against the war in Iraq and have come here to protest," says Marco's brother Andrea in faltering English. Tomokazu Kuroba, clad in a purple kimono, is trying to talk to me even as others from the 80-strong East Japan Railway Workers bang away gleefully on bowl-shaped Japanese drums. Between politely bowing and juggling a range of printed pamphlets, he gets me to sign up for a campaign supporting labour solidarity.

WSF 2004 doesn't boast sniffer dogs and stretch limos and Swiss chalets, but its roster of special invitees would be at home equally on the snowy slopes of Davos. Nobel laureates Shirin Ebadi and Joseph Stiglitz are here, as is anti-war activist and British Labour party mp Jeremy Corbin, author turned social activist Arundhati Roy, Medha Patkar, and Jose "Asterix" Bove, the French farmer and activist with a penchant for wrecking McDonald's outlets.

Delegates brave Mumbai trains, hard camp beds, and alien tongues to hear their heroes. The Evil Triangle of IMF, World Bank and WTO is ruthlessly attacked as are selfish and rapacious multinationals.

160 food stalls and 30 beverage outlets sold, among others, Chinese, Korean, Thai food

Then, there's the food court: 160 food stalls and 30 beverage outlets selling Chinese, Korean, Thai, South Indian, Maharashtrian, Konkani, you-name-it food. A blonde Finn sits on the ground, surrounded by illiterate farmers from interior Maharashtra, polishing off spicy curry-rice off a leaf plate. A South Korean coyly shares piping hot idlis with two vivacious French students. A middle aged Spanish lady is trying out a plate of pani-puris. Coke and Pepsi are banned (naturally!) and delegates have to be content with indigenous Kokum and bottles of mineral water.

Just across the busy Western Express Highway, and a few hundred metres from WSF's venue, Darshan Pal, clad in a white shirt and grimy khaki cargos is squatting in a corner of the dais. Full bearded, muscled, and swarthy it's not difficult to visualise the convener of Mumbai Resistance 2004 for the firebrand leader he is. "They (WSF) are separating globalisation from capitalism and imperial domination and that just can't be done," he rants. A loose confederation of 300 ultra-left national and international organisations, Mumbai Resistance is holding a forum of its own, to protest WSF's protest forum. Apart from being fed up with WSF's conciliatory approach, Mumbai Resistance is against the forum being funded by cash rich (and by extension, imperialist) bodies such as Oxfam and Action Aid. For the record, three organisations, the Netherlands-based Hivos and Novib and UK-based Oxfam are said to have contributed 60 per cent of the WSF's Rs 12 crore budget. Rebuts Nandita Shah, a member of WSF's Finance committee, "Forget cash rich, we're running a budget deficit of more than a crore."

Utopian dreams apart, views remained as divergent as ever when it came to offering alternatives

At the end of the day, WSF is obviously more about participation than prescription. Despite all the capitalist-bashing, very few alternative ideologies are proposed. High on rhetoric and sophistry, the speakers successfully pull down existing structures but are unable to articulate feasible alternative structures. Participants are convinced that if, in the past, protests against capitalism produced a whole new set of social and economic ideologies like communism, socialism, and fascism, there is no reason why a new, coherent, universal ideological alternative to globalisation cannot emerge.

With a goatee and wire-rimmed glasses Lev Gossman exemplifies the leitmotif of the meet. A 21-year-old Jewish student from California who swears by contemporary hip-hop artists like Dead Prez, Most Def, and Talib Kweli, he belts out his personal rap-inspired ode to WSF, set to a syncopated bass beat.

"Lyrically, I bring out the synergies,
Interaction of discrete agencies,
Bringing the sum of the parts together,
Am not so strong individually."

And the applauding throng around the dais clambers aboard, joining him in an impromptu jig.

 

    HOME | EDITORIAL | COVER STORY | FEATURES | TRENDS | BOOKEND | PERSONAL FINANCE
MANAGING | BT SPECIAL | BOOKS | COLUMN | JOBS TODAY | PEOPLE


 
   

Partners: BESTEMPLOYERSINDIA

INDIA TODAY | INDIA TODAY PLUS
ARCHIVESCARE TODAY | MUSIC TODAY | ART TODAY | SYNDICATIONS TODAY