Under
ordinary circumstances balancing a linear equation-that is what
the Budget is all about-is a simple task. But these are extraordinary
times. The ruling United Progressive Alliance is a coalition of
14 partners, some unlikely bedfellows. Then, there's the Common
Minimum Programme, a vision statement of the new government put
together by the 14 and vetted by the communist parties that support
this government without being part of it-at once both a guideline
for policy making or a plain old-fashioned millstone around the
neck.
These are the constraints reformist-at-heart
Palaniappan Chidambaram, the country's Finance Minister, will have
to take into account when he sets out to balance the fiscal equation
the best he can. It won't, as we have implied before, be easy: little
money is likely to flow in from the government divesting its stake
in public sector companies (the CMP all but rules out the disinvestment
of profit making government companies); subsidies, an important
component of non-development expenditure cannot be reduced; and
the need to increase public investment in agriculture and rural
infrastructure, one that has been articulated and articulated and
articulated, will only exacerbate the situation.
Taxes, then, are the great white hope. With the economy on a roll,
tax collections in 2003-04, at Rs 252,162 crore were 18 per cent
higher than the budgeted estimate, the first time such a thing has
come to pass since 1995-96. There's always the threat of a slide
in the manufacturing sector's fortunes impacting this-despite accounting
for a quarter of the Gross Domestic Produce, manufacturing accounts
for 66 per cent of total tax collection-but the UPA's stated objective
of attracting investments in manufacturing reduces the chances of
this happening. However, much of India's tax revenues (as opposed
of that of any developed country's) comes from indirect taxes such
as excise and customs. In the long run, these have to be rationalised
(read: reduced), should India wish to be part of the World Trade
Organisation. Ergo, Chidambaram may have no option but to look at
increasing revenues from direct taxes. That could explain the buzz
emanating from North Block about an additional 20-30 services being
brought under the service tax net.
If the Finance Minister is able to convince
the communists about the need to rationalise income taxes-this would
be in keeping with the spirit of the Kelkar Committee report that
suggests the scrapping of most exemptions-he may well be able to
achieve the twin objectives of increasing consumer spending (less
taxes equals more money to spend) and increasing tax revenues (an
easier tax regime should lead to greater transparency and help bring
more people into the tax net). That, though is easier said than
done. As far as Budget 2004 goes, this writer expects a mathematical,
not strategic approach to addressing the fiscal deficit. P.S: He
will be happy to be proved wrong.
-Ashish Gupta
BLACK MONEY
Will The New VDIS Work?
The short answer to that
is yes, but only just. As Arvind Virmani, a former advisor to the
Finance Ministry, and now the CEO of the Indian Council for Research
on International Economic Relations puts it, every Voluntary Disclosure
of Income Scheme, targeted at helping the fat cats of the parallel
economy turn their treasure hoards legit, albeit after paying a
penalty, "is a zero-sum game because after the initial blip
in tax collection there is no increase for the next two or three
years." Still, it is almost certain that the Finance Minister
will launch the 28th-odd such scheme in India's history to unearth
black money and increase the government's revenues.
-Ashish Gupta
What Can The FM Do?
A quick pre-budget tour of the possible and
the probable.
AGRICULTURE
Although this is a state subject, Finance Minister P. Chidambaram
can help the cause of agriculture by increasing government spend
in the sector (and in the development of rural infrastructure).
That will send a message to the states on the intent of the central
government.
MANUFACTURING
N. Srinivasan, the Director General of Confederation of Indian Industry,
wants the budget to facilitate investments in manufacturing. The
Finance Minister could well do that by focussing on the development
of infrastructure, doing away with procedural delays, and drafting
a roadmap of tariffs for the next three years.
SERVICES
The services sector has blossomed and thrived without state patronage
(or intervention). A world class infrastructure (think airports,
power, and the like) and a continued supply of talent (think engineers,
biochemists, and others) are requisites for the boom to continue.
The Finance Minister can help by focussing on infrastructure and
primary and secondary education.
EXPORTS
Most export-subsidies are gone, but Rafeeque Ahmed, the President
of Federation of Indian Export Organisation, maintains that tax
rebates on export income should continue till transaction costs
in India are down to global averages. That's something the Finance
Minister can well do.
CAPITAL MARKETS
The bulls will be back, claims Ajay Bagga, the Chief Executive Officer
of Kotak Mahindra Mutual Fund, should the Finance Minister make
one important announcement in the budget. "He can impact the
capital market significantly by reducing or eliminating capital
gains tax on share transactions." Will he dare?
-compiled by Ashish Gupta
Heiress Tracking
Vanisha Mittal isn't the only heiress of note
out there.
Schauna
Chauhan
Daughter of: Prakash
Chauhan, Director, Parle International
AGE: 27
SIZE OF BUSINESS EMPIRE: Not Disclosed
EDUCATION: Bachelor's degree in International Management
from the Lausanne Business School
DESIGNATION: Executive (Operations), Parle International
Private Limited (Parle Group)
HOBBIES & INTERESTS: Movies
For someone who grew up frequenting dad Prakash
Chauhan's factory in Andheri in suburban Mumbai, it was understood
that Schauna, the eldest of the three daughters, would take over
the reins someday. Today, as Executive (Operations), Schauna has
set her eyes on the globe. While Frooti is already being exported
to the US, Canada, the Netherlands and Maldives, she now wants to
set up plants or get into franchisee networks overseas. She is engaged
to Bikram Saluja, a former model and actor.
-Priyanka Sangani
Vismaya
Firodia
Daughter of: Arun
Firodia, Founder and Chairman, Kinetic India
AGE: 28
SIZE OF BUSINESS EMPIRE: Approximately Rs 1,200 crore
EDUCATION: Graduated with honours from Princeton University,
NJ, USA, in 1997 with a Bachelors degree in Management Systems
DESIGNATION: Vice President (Corporate Communications), Kinetic
India
HOBBIES & INTERESTS: Scuba diving, marine life preservation,
reading (mostly fiction)
Having literally grown up with the company-it
was founded around the same time she was born-it wasn't surprising
that Vismaya Firodia always nurtured a dream of eventually working
there. Although older sister Sulajja is more active in the actual
management of the company, Vismaya handles most of the marketing
support functions and corporate communications.
-Priyanka Sangani
Akshata Murty
Daughter of: Narayana
Murthy, Chief Mentor, Infosys Technologies
AGE: 24
SIZE OF BUSINESS EMPIRE: Owns 12,65,981 shares (valued at
around Rs 665 crore)
EDUCATION: Under Grad Major at Claremont McKenna College,
LA. Majored in Economics and French. Goes to Stanford for an MBA
this fall
DESIGNATION: Consultant, Deloitte and Touche (USA)
HOBBIES & INTERESTS: Reading and music
Akshata Murty makes it a point not to highlight
whose daughter she is, so as to avoid any 'undue advantage' or publicity.
On occasion has been heard mentioning that her father "just
works in the IT industry in India". Not that he is the IT industry
in India.
-Venkatesha Babu
Vidula Khaitan
Daughter of: Manjushree
Khaitan, Director, Kesoram
AGE: 25
SIZE OF BUSINESS EMPIRE: Rs 4,500 crore
EDUCATION: MBA from Indian School of Business, Hyderabad
DESIGNATION: Head, Vidula Consultancy Services Ltd
HOBBIES & INTERESTS: N.A.
Grandpa B.K. Birla wanted her to learn the
ropes at Vasavdatta Cement, a unit of Kesoram, but that innocuous
move set the grapevine abuzz that he was training Vidula Khaitan
to take over the reins when he quit. He calls it "wishful thinking",
but the buzz refuses to die.
-Arnab Mitra
Q&A
"The Fee Issue Took Away Most Of Our Working Time"
|
Directorships
of the Indian Institutes of Management are usually pretty uneventful.
All it involves is a truckload of administrative work, handling
a few minor academic crises, and weathering the fallout of a less-than-complimentary
ranking by a magazine (several, including this one, rank B-schools).
57-year-old Bakul Dholakia, the Director of the Indian
Institute of Management, Ahmedabad (ranked #1 in Business Today's
roster of India's Best B-schools), and an industrial economist by
qualification, discovered there was more to it when former HRD Minister
Murli Manohar Joshi tried to get the IIMs to reduce their already-low
tuition fee. Dholakia and the other directors saw that as political
interference in the functioning of government schools that had always
enjoyed reasonable levels of autonomy. The man led the other IIMs
to battle, one that was settled by the defeat of the National Democratic
Alliance to which Joshi belonged, in the elections to the 14th Lok
Sabha in May 2004. Dholakia spoke to Business Today's Sahad
P.V. on the resolution of the fee imbroglio, and reports
of IIM-A's global aspirations.
Finally, the IIM fee issue has been resolved...
Yes. We have decided to retain the last year's
fee (Rs 1.58 lakh per annum). As for scholarships for the needy
students (whose family income is less than Rs 2 lakh a year), we
have increased the provision from Rs 25 lakh to Rs 1 crore a year.
The change in political dispensation has
helped your cause.
Of course, that has helped the resolution of
the fee issue. Our entire time had been taken up by this for the
last few months.
What next? Are you setting up a campus in
Cairo?
The reports about our setting up a campus in
Cairo are wrong. The Egyptian government has been talking to us
for helping them set up a management institute in their country.
This is part of institution building, and is entirely different
from setting up our own campus.
So, you have no immediate plans to go global?
We still haven't thought through it fully.
Currently, we are setting up a new campus in Ahmedabad, close to
our existing premises. We are also working on a campus in Mumbai,
which was decided sometime in 2002. However, we are not ruling out
any overseas campuses. In any case, we are expanding our global
presence through executive management development programmes, which
we conduct overseas from time to time. We have already done it in
Kenya and Sri Lanka. We are also exploring South East Asia and Europe.
FEE-WATCH
IIM Tracking
What the six IIMs have decided in terms of tuitions.
IIM-A:
Will retain old fee structure (Rs 158,000 a year). Has refused government
aid and will continue to offer assistance to students from families
earning less than Rs 200,000 a year. The corpus for this scholarship
has been quadrupled to Rs 1 crore a year.
IIM-B: Will retain
old fee of Rs 150,000 a year. And will increase the total value
of scholarships to Rs 75 lakh from the existing Rs 25 lakh.
IIM-C: Will retain
existing fee of Rs 127,000 a year and has decided to provide a need-based
scholarship along the same lines as the one offered by IIM-A. The
school plans to tap alumni and corporate donors for funds.
IIM-L: The school
has no plans to change the existing fee of Rs 1.3 lakh a year. It
has also decide to waive this in its entirety for students whose
families earn less than Rs 200,000 a year. However, it will accept
aid from the government as its corpus is a mere Rs 8.5 crore.
IIM-I: It has left
the tuition fee unchanged at Rs 108,000 a year. It plans to offer
assistance to students from families earning less than Rs 200,000
a year; money will be raised from industry and alumni; until then,
it will come out of government funds.
IIM-K: It has decided
to retain last year's fee of Rs 110,000 a year. Like the other IIMs,
it will offer a need-based scholarship for students with family
income below Rs 200,000 a year.
-compiled by Amanpreet Singh
|