PANKERLA ANJIAH/39
Marginal Farmer
Television has
reached Pratap Singhram village on the outskirts of Hyderabad-it
did that several years ago, actually-but Pankerla Anjiah, who has
taken five acres of land on long lease didn't get to catch the Finance
Minister on television. Anjiah, a father of four who grows paddy
on three acres and cash crops such as chillies, cotton, and vegetables
on the other two, begins his day at 4.30 a.m., milks the few buffaloes
he owns, does his rounds distributing milk, and then works his land;
it's hard work earning a living from land that is, like most in
the Telengana region, rain-fed, and the earliest each day ends is
8.30 p.m.. "It is good that the government wants to increase
agricultural credit," he says when told of the Budget's green
slant, "but there must be a mechanism whereby small farmers
who have leased out land are eligible for loans." Anjiah is,
however, unequivocally positive about the government's intent to
renovate water bodies as that could help rain-fed, un-irrigated
land like his own. In sharp contrast to Anjiah's good-but... response
is that of P. Chengal Reddy, the Chairman of the Federation of Farmer's
Associations in Andhra Pradesh, who spoke to this correspondent
while being driven to a TV studio in Delhi. "The Prime Minister
and the Finance Minister seem to have realised that a strong agricultural
sector and a healthy farming community is critical for the economy."
Reddy is obviously more sanguine than Anjiah about the Budget's
ability to change the lives of marginal farmers.
-E. Kumar Sharma
VASUKI SUNDARAM/38
Travel Agency Proprietor
Anyone
who has doubts as to whether small businesspeople track the Budget
need only look as far as Mumbai-based Sundaram. She and a clutch
of other small travel agents not only watch the Budget and assess
its impact on their sector individually, they "share notes". The
lady says she was curious as to what Finance Minister Chidambaram
could achieve given the unwieldy coalition he was part of, but admits
"the Budget looks pretty remarkable under the circumstances". It
should. Sundaram isn't worried about the rise in service tax (from
8 per cent to 10 per cent). "I would pass on these costs to customers,"
she says, adding that she is just a conduit for the government to
collect something from end-users. However, although Sundaram is
thrilled by the fact that tourism (along with airports and seaports)
has been identified as a focus area for infrastructure projects
(with the Finance Ministry catalysing the formation of a consortium
of banks that have earmarked Rs 40,000 crore for the same), she
would prefer to save her hosannahs till the specifics are laid out.
Ashwini Kakkar, the Head of Thomas Cook India and President of the
Bombay Chamber of Commerce and Industry is a tad more optimistic.
"Now we can do roads, restore monuments, and upgrade infrastructure,"
he gushes. And another travel industry exec, Arup Sen, Director,
Cox & Kings, expects the Budget's rural emphasis to translate eventually
into a rural market for his company's offerings. Now, that'd be
something.
-Priya Srinivasan
NEELU SHARMA/28
HR Co-Ordinator, Nokia India
From
the organisational point of view, Sharma cannot complain about the
Budget. It makes mobile phones cheaper (and should, therefore, help
her company sell more of them). And by allowing for an increase
in the ceiling on Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) in telecommunications
from 49 per cent to 74 per cent, it has increased the chances of
more investment coming the sector's way (not that the booming one
doesn't get enough already). That, again, will be to the benefit
of Nokia, which also sells mobile network equipment. However, from
an individual point of view, Sharma doesn't have much to cheer about.
"The budget has done nothing for salaried employees," she rues.
"We were expecting some tax relief that we haven't got; instead,
there's the 2 per cent education cess." And so, Sharma, who believes
the Budget has done well to bring the excise duty on computers down
to zero and provide for collateral-free educational loans, remains
negative about the Budget. None of the provisions, she says, affect
salarymen. That's not entirely a fair comment. Half of India's 2.7
crore tax payers earn Rs 100,000 or less a year. And this Budget
ensures that anyone in this category no longer pays any tax. The
Finance Minister has also articulated his desire to see the "benign
interest rate" regime continue, and this means salarymen can continue
to borrow money to buy consumer durables, cars, and houses.
-Sahad P.V.
SUBROTO BAGCHI/47
Co-founder and Chief Operating Officer, Mindtree
Consulting
Uender
ideal circumstances the budget should matter little to people like
Subroto Bagchi, both from an individual and an organisational point
of view. In 1998, Bagchi, then a hi-flier at Wipro, quit and with
a few other colleagues, founded MindTree Consulting. People in his
economic class do not lose sleep over what the Budget will do to
their finances, although Bagchi remembers that in 1976, when he
started his career, everyone used to queue up at the petrol station
the day before the Budget to fill up in anticipation of a hike.
"Now, no one cares," he says, "because petrol prices change every
few weeks." "This is true for most people, not just me." And circa
2004, the Budget is not supposed to do anything to (or for) companies
like Bagchi's. That's not because MindTree is into software; it
would have applied even had it been into any other kind of service,
even manufacturing (Now, had it been in an agri-business, that would
have been interesting). Bagchi is thankful that the Budget ignores
the software sector. "I know some software biggies have been calling
for scrapping the tax holiday," he says, "but the Indian it success
story doesn't owe its success only to the big players; there are
numerous small and mid-sized players who are its real pillar of
strength." He is happy about the zero duty on PCs, but adds that
apart from that he does not see the Budget "having any kind of impact
on me as an individual or the company". That's just the way it should
be.
-Venkatesha Babu
|