|
XYZ Ltd, a BT 500 company, is looking for
Mr John Doe of IIT Kharagpur, IIM-Ahmedabad, and Harvard Business
School to take its billion-dollar division to new heights.
FINDERS PLEASE CONTACT THE CEO.
GENEROUS REWARD. |
Come
placement season early next year, and the top business schools
in India will play host to at least one unlikely recruiter: Korn
Ferry, a global headhunting firm. Traditionally seen as an industry
that could make do with accidental talent, headhunting, or executive
search as it is more formally known, is getting serious about
recruiting early on and nurturing top-class talent. It's easy
to see why. As Indian companies go global, learning to play by
global rules of not just marketing but corporate governance, executive
search is no more about simply finding a willing candidate. The
headhunter of today must consider a variety of factors ranging
from the company's values and culture to ownership dynamics to
future goals in order to draw up a list of attributes the candidate
must have and then go out find one and, invariably, sell him the
job. The other reason why the top search firms are getting their
act together is the sheer growth in the Indian market. Says Sanjiv
Sachar, Managing Partner: "When India talks, Egon Zehnder
International listens."
He isn't exaggerating. While the Indian search
market (for top management jobs) is a minuscule Rs 150 crore a
year compared to America's $4 billion (17,600 crore), it offers
tremendous growth potential. For instance, over the last two years,
the industry has been clipping at 48 per cent a year. Compare
that with what's happened globally in the search business. Between
2000 and 2003, it witnessed possibly its worst slump, brought
on by a slowdown in the US economy. Revenues of top search firms
shrank in double digits, average fee on mandates also dropped,
and hundreds of consultants lost jobs. Things improved worldwide
last year when revenue grew almost 20 per cent, with all the major
regions (North America, Europe, and Asia-Pacific) posting consistent
growth. But the search firms seem to have learnt an important
lesson during the slump, and which is to focus on booming economies
like India and China.
|
Egon's Managing Partner
Sanjiv Sachar: When India talks, says Sachar, Egon
Zehnder International listens |
To be sure, some of the big global players
like Egon and Korn Ferry (See The Executive Search Bandwagon)
have been around in India for a decade now. But it's only now
that the industry is witnessing a burst of activity. For one,
firms like Spencer Stuart and Russell Reynolds are getting interested
in India. For another, big companies seeking world-class managerial
talent are also willing to pay world-class salaries. Therefore,
with search for the employer becoming more expensive and crucial
(according to an international research, inappropriate hiring
can cost a company 24 to 40 times the candidate's annual salary),
there's greater willingness to invest time and money in it. "Today,
search mandates are being given out by operational heads rather
than hr heads," notes Bipaschit Bose, CEO of Prospect. Adds
R. Suresh, Managing Director, Stanton Chase India: "We are
taking greater time to close deals and fee structures are becoming
more complex."
Fatter fees and more complex assignments have
got the firms scrambling. The big guns of search are increasingly
training their sights on cross-border work because even as Indian
companies are going global, global companies are coming to India
to set up operations, back-end or otherwise. In fact, global work
(meaning a mandate that either originates abroad or is concluded
abroad) already accounts for 30 per cent of Heidrick & Struggles'
India revenue. "IT, manufacturing and pharma are the three
sectors that are driving the industry's global revenues,"
says Arun Das Mahapatra, Managing Partner at Heidrick & Struggles.
Stanton Chase, meanwhile, sees the Asia-Pacific region, where
multi-ethnicity is a requirement, opening up for Indian professionals,
and Egon claims to be doing a lot of repatriation work for companies
in manufacturing and financial services.
THE EXECUTIVE SEARCH BANDWAGON
A look at the top 10 search firms
in India. |
Accord Group India: Founded
by ABC Consultants' B.P. Agrawal, the search firm is affiliated
to the Accord Group worldwide. In India, Accord has 20 consultants
working on sectors such as consumer goods, retail, pharma,
IT, media and manufacturing.
Amrop Group: This search firm
started out in Delhi, and now operates out of Chennai and
Mumbai, with four consultants who focus on sectors such
as manufacturing, technology, outsourcing, financial services,
infrastructure and telecom.
Egon Zehnder International: The
top player in pure-play CXO level search, Egon completes
10 years in India this year. It operates out of Mumbai and
Delhi with 23 consultants, and has just added private equity
to its roster of industries served.
Executive Access: Hong Kong-based
Executive Access set up shop in India in 1995, and is now
looking at opening its sixth office in Hyderabad after the
other metros. Boasts of 50 consultants, and has service
lines covering a host of sectors including pharma, telecom,
IT, financial services and retail.
Gilbert Tweed Associates: Set
up in 1998 in Mumbai, it currently operates out of three
offices, manned by 22 consultants. It has service lines
in agro-processing, manufacturing, financial services, IT
and KPO. It's looking to expand into retail and biotech.
Heidrick & Struggles: World
#1, H&S came to India pretty late-in 2001. Its offices
in Mumbai and Delhi have just five consultants covering
sectors like aviation, financial services and real estate.
It plans to hire consultants for media, consumer goods and
IT.
Hunt Partners: An international
firm with just one office in India, Hunt was set up locally
by a breakaway faction from Horton International. Its three
consultants focus on banking, financial services, FMCG,
telecom and healthcare.
Korn Ferry International: A
top three player globally, Korn Ferry came to India a year
before Egon did. It has offices in Mumbai and Gurgaon, and
has 22 consultants, three of them recently hired for consumer
markets, industrial markets and IT.
Stanton Chase: Another global
player, it's been in India for the last six years, and has
40 consultants catering to various industries such as pharma,
financial services, IT and manufacturing.
Transearch India: Launched
in 2004 by Atul Vohra and Uday Chawla after they broke away
from Heidrick & Struggles, it has ramped up from 10
people in Gurgaon to 24, with offices in Mumbai and Bangalore.
Media, automotive and insurance are some of the industries
it focusses on.
-The listing is alphabetical
|
|
(From left to right) Soumen Basu, Executive
Chairman, Manpower India; Shiv Agrawal, CEO, ABC Consultants;
Iain Herbertson, MD (Asia-Pacific), Manpower; and Tarun Bali,
Executive Director, Manpower: Manpower goes shopping in
India with ABC for opportunities in the direct staffing business |
With a variety of new industries arriving
on the scene (private equity, retail, life sciences, KPOs are
some of them), search firms are busy recruiting domain specialists.
Executive Access recently hired Rajiv Tewari, who's done stints
at Zee TV and The Indian Express, to head its newly set up media
vertical. Egon is adding private equity to its portfolio of offerings,
and Gilbert Tweed is looking at retail and biotech. Some are even
offering niche services like recruiting independent directors
(called board consulting in industry lingo), and often the consultant
on the job is the managing partner himself. "The money in
it is small because board members don't get top dollar, and correspondingly
we get paid less, but it has tremendous potential," says
Deepak Gupta, Country Head and Managing Director, Korn Ferry India.
The Opportunity Downstairs
Despite the boom, there's just one problem
with the search business. It will never be as big as the opportunity
in middle or lower-level recruitment. For example, the largely
unorganised business of mid-level recruitment is estimated at
Rs 400 crore-that's 2.5 times the size of search. What's more,
it's growing at 50 per cent a year-a fact not unnoticed by global
players. Early October, us-based Manpower Inc.'s Indian subsidiary
tied up with ABC Consultants to acquire the latter's junior-to-mid-level
placement business relating to IT, ITEs and retail financial services.
ABC, one of the oldest home-grown placement agencies, gets 26
per cent in the joint venture in return for transferring the Rs
20-crore worth of business to the joint venture. It will, however,
continue to operate independent in its other verticals such as
manufacturing, engineering, pharma, and media. "In India,
we see tremendous growth in the direct hire (read: junior to mid-level
hires) space, as quality has become increasingly important in
countries banking on services," explains Soumen Basu, Executive
Chairman of Manpower India.
The Top Placements
Big-ticket mandates have now become commonplace
in India Inc. Here's a sample: |
Who: S. Surya
For Whom: Infineon Technologies
By Whom: Russell Reynolds
For How Much*: Rs 3 crore
Who: Siddharth Pai
For Whom: Technology Partners Intl
By Whom: Hunt Partners
For How Much*: Rs 1.6 crore
Who: Dinesh Chandiok
For Whom: Anil Dhirubhai Ambani Enterprise
By Whom: Stanton Chase
For How Much*: Rs 1.5 crore
Who: Neelam Dhawan
For Whom: Microsoft
By Whom: Egon Zehnder
For How Much*: Rs 1.5 crore
Who: Padma Ravichander
For Whom: Perot Systems
By Whom: Stanton Chase
For How Much*: Rs 1.3 crore
*Indicates annual salary package Source:
Industry estimates
|
Right at the bottom of the recruitment food
chain is the temping or contract staffing business. Unlike executive
search, which is partner-driven and small-volume, staffing works
like a recruitment factory-low profit margins, but high throughput.
Most of the international staffing companies in India-be it Manpower,
Vedior, Kelly Services or Adecco-have acquired local businesses
to get a toehold in the market. For instance, Vedior entered via
Ma Foi, Kelly Services through BTI Consultants, Adecco acquired
PeopleOne, and Manpower bought ABC's direct hire business.
|
|
Stanton Chase India's R. Suresh: Stanton
is looking at Asia-Pacific, where it says Indian managers
are in great demand |
Korn Ferry India's Deepak Gupta: Board
consulting is
another thing Korn Ferry does in
addition to executive search |
Today, the size of the temporary workforce
in India is estimated at about 100,000-a fraction of the organised
sector's 280 million headcount. Globally, say experts, 3 to 4
per cent of the workforce comprises temporary workers. Therefore,
with companies hiving off non-core activities, temping is expected
to grow by leaps and bounds in India. By some estimates, it could
soar to 8 million by 2010. Because the temping agencies take on
the role of an employer, companies find the deal very convenient-never
mind that temping is still a regulatory grey area. "We greatly
help in reducing frictional unemployment and also reduce attrition
because of the organisational support," says Ashok Reddy,
Managing Director, TeamLease, India's biggest temping firm. "We
add liquidity to the labour market," adds Ajit Isaac, Managing
Director (India and Middle East), Adecco PeopleOne.
As companies in India expand, the recruitment
industry on the whole will continue to grow. The executive search
firms will do more of cross-border and value-added work, while
the direct staffing and temping agencies feed the service sector's
hunger for workers. But whether the industry's heady growth is
good enough to lure talent from India's top B-schools is something
Korn Ferry's Gupta will soon find out.
|