You
ain't heard nothing yet." forget al Jolson, those words could
well have been uttered by a D-street sharp trying to gull an investor
into putting his little all into media and entertainment stocks.
Given us Indians' proclivity to suspend that disbelief some, and
then more, entertainment stocks should be hot. Last year, 1,000
motion pics, in 10-odd languages vied for our attention. As did
countless soaps across 25-odd channels. Surely, all those numbers
must translate into something tangible on the bourses?
They don't, not even when we stretch that definition
a bit and include media stocks. Not that there are all that many.
The best media companies are unlisted: Bennett, Coleman & Company
Limited, Kasturi & Sons, Living Media India, The Malayala Manorama
Group, Dainik Jagran, you name it, they're unlisted. That's a sharp
contrast to global markets where most large media and entertainment
companies (read that without a pause, for the best of them, globally,
are conglos) are listed: AOL Time Warner, Walt Disney, Viacom, News
Corp, and Sony.
Indian publications then, may be among the
best in the world, but investors can't partake of that. Indian motion
pics such as Lagaan (Tax) and Kabhi Khushi Kabhi Ghum
(Sometimes Happy, Sometimes Sad) may do well in global markets,
but that's of no relevance to investors. And Information & Broadcasting
Minister Sushma Swaraj-with her view on foreign direct investment
in print media she is actually part of the problem, not the solution-may
lead a delegation of 40-plus to the Cannes festival, but investors
won't benefit from it.
The media domain can at least boast of some
pan-Indian corporate entities; the Indian motion picture industry
can't. Dominated by independent producers-the studio system hasn't
worked-and financed by funds of uncertain origin, its status as
an industry is in itself suspect.
"Transparency, honesty, and integrity
in dealings are the first steps it needs to exhibit to be termed
an industry and taken seriously as one by investors," says
Anoop Bhaskar, Associate Vice President (Research), Pioneer iti
Mutual Fund.
Apart from Zee Telefilms-and it has a clutch
of problems all its own-there is little choice for investors. Most
listed companies are those that provide software to broadcasters.
Entry barriers in this business are low and with the notable exception
of Balaji Telefilms, the companies don't amount to much in terms
of either market capitalisation or revenues. Indeed, the aggregate
market capitalisation of Adlabs, Mid-Day, Balaji Telefilms and Mukta
Arts still falls short of Zee's. So there.
You Ain't Seen Nothing Yet
That's not to suggest the media and entertainment
businesses are fundamentally flawed. Rather, private channels rule
the roost in the broadcasting business. Last year, 75-80 per cent
of the Rs 3,600 crore companies spent on advertising went to these
channels.
Then there is the possibility of raking in
subscription revenue once the regulatory regime related to conditional
access becomes clearer.
Last year, broadcasters earned Rs 1,000 crore
through this avenue, no chump change whichever way you look at it.
"We expect subscription revenues ro rise over the next five
years," says Ramachandra Hegde, a media analyst with ENAM Securities.
"With better reporting by cable operators, broadcasters will
get a larger share of a larger pie."
Broadcasting may be the mother lode but there
are other, smaller, significantly lucrative avenues.
We've profiled some, not all of them. Still,
it would do you a world of good to remember two things. One, most
initiatives in the entertainment space involve huge capital expenditure-upfront.
And two, factor in a certain amount of sector-risk
when you invest in entertainment stocks. "Concerns on cash
flow, corporate governance, and the sustainability of earnings are
factors that have limited our exposure to the industry," says
Bhaskar. Read on, and Caveat Emptor.
Zee Telefilms
It is the largest listed media company and
one of the Big Three Indian broadcasters. The channels, the cable
venture Siticable, and the film-and music-label all come under Zee
Telefilms. The channel may be trailing on most fronts-Star Plus
is the leading entertainment channel, AajTak (part of the India
Today Group that owns Business Today), the leading news one-but
the ratings game, especially among entertainment channels, is unpredictable.
Even now, thanks to its regional channels and niche English language
ones, advertisers find it difficult to ignore it. Zee's revenues
from subscription services were Rs 120 crore last year and likely
to go up to Rs 150-170 crore this year. And advertising revenues
in 2001-02 stood at a not insignificant Rs 640.02 crore.
This is a must-have stock in your portfolio,
but the scrip has a tendency to be volatile, so maybe it wouldn't
hurt to wait for the next crash and then pick it up.
Mukta Arts
It's a script that would do a Bollywood flick
proud. After churning out an almost unending (the key word is almost)
series of hits, man decides to do his bit to improve the image of
the Indian film industry and lists his production house.
Then, like a true Russian tragedy things go
wrong. That's the story of Subhash Ghai and Mukta Arts.
Still, Mukta remains the only option for investors
to grab a piece of the silver screen. Ghai's last motion picture,
Yaadein, may have flopped in the domestic circuit but it did pretty
well in the NRI-one.
Don't evaluate this company on a quarterly
basis, warns Nikhil Vora, a research analyst with Alchemy Share
& Stock Brokers, in his recent report on the company. "As
Mukta consolidates its business model and revenue streams, the potential
re-rating could far outweigh the present risks."
Ghai may have managed to sell his library of
blockbusters to Sony for Rs 16.1 crore, but motion picture production
remains a risky business and Mukta has made no efforts to hedge
its risks by diversifying. Consider it only if you consider yourself
brave.
Balaji Telefilms
The name that is on everyone's lips, Balaji,
may be the maker of the programmes with the highest ratings across
channels, but does that warrant a price-earnings multiple in excess
of 20.
At Rs 600-plus, the stock does seem a trifle
over-valued, but the company's financials are healthy and there
are no obvious competitors in sight. Inexplicably, the company seems
to have got its soap-assembly-line working just fine-one block-buster
after another rolls off it.
"Volume growth will take a back-seat to
value-growth," says Vora, but he believes the company is still
a good buy. So go ahead and buy this stock but take it slowly.
Adlabs
Blame your reading habits if you haven't heard
of Adlabs. It is the largest film processor in the country and has
now ventured into the business of multiplexes.
It also proposes to diversify into film production.
However, the new ventures do carry considerable risk. The multiplexes,
for instance, involve considerable capital expenditure: the company
is estimated to have burnt Rs 50 crore on them already. Strictly
for the brave.
Mid-Day
The publishing industry is far more professional
than the business of film-making (accepted, we're biased). And people
are, as a rule, reluctant to change their reading habits.
Unfortunately, the Indian publishing industry
has only two options on offer to investors, Gujarat Samachar and
Mid-Day. The first is a great value buy, but is plagued by poor
institutional interest and low investor awareness. Mid-Day is more
visible but has two fledgling businesses, fm radio, and outdoor
advertising to nurture. Besides, it could face competition in the
afternoon-paper category from BCCL and the India Today Group. Wait
and watch.
|