|
(Clockwise) Jagdish Khattar, MD, (front),
Yuichi Nakamura, Joint MD, Shinichi Takeuchi, Director (Production),
K. Kumar, Advisor (Engineering), MUL: Scripting a new roadmap |
Jn
August 1, at 9.30 am, the executive committee of the Automotive
Component Manufacturers Association (ACMA)-the apex body that represents
the interests of the Rs 15,000-crore Indian auto components sector-drove
into the Gurgaon plant of the Rs 9,410.3-crore automobile giant,
Maruti Udyog. Comprising 38 members (some of them past presidents,
others CEOs of component manufacturers) the committee, which makes
periodic visits to auto makers, first met the new-look Maruti Board
of Directors: other than Managing Director Jagdish Khattar and two
part-time directors, the rest are all Japanese. After exchanging
the routine pleasantries, the ACMA team was taken around on a plant
visit-another standard procedure.
If the ACMA honchos were comfortably settling
into yet another visit to an original equipment manufacturer, it
all changed dramatically an hour after the plant visit, when Khattar
made a presentation. The Maruti chief's short point: cut costs by
30 per cent over three years. If you can do that, Suzuki will increase
its sourcing from you, perhaps even treble it, by making you a part
of the global supply chain.
SUZUKI HAS PLENTY GOING FOR IT IN INDIA... |
Huge Vendor base
Suzuki can leverage Maruti's 350-strong vendor base to source
components for its global ops cheap, even for its motorcycles
business which will enter India in 2004
Small car hub
Given that it costs between $4,000 and $4,500 to produce a small
car in India (it does $6,000-6,500 in Japan), Suzuki could make
India the global hub of its small car business
Low-cost producer
Suzuki keeps costs low. The fourth generation Alto costs Yen
5,50,000 (Rs 2.2 lakh) in Japan; a non-AC first GEN Alto did
450,000 Y (Rs 1.8 lakh at today's rates) in 1979
Purchasing power
Most Maruti vendors are willing to lower costs further and step
up investments if Suzuki dangles the carrot of sourcing components
from India. No other company can do this.
Dealership network
Maruti has the widest network of 256 sales outlets and 180 authorised
dealers. Suzuki plans to step this up to 350 sales outlets over
the next three years.
Vintage
Depreciated plants, easier availability of spares, brand loyalty,
and a wider network will continue to work in favour of Maruti
for a long time. |
...BUT THE ROAD ISN'T SMOOTH ALL THE WAY |
The Diesel Disadvantage
Suzuki doesn't make diesel engines. Sourcing engines cheap may
prove to be a challenge
Not Enough Utility Vehicles
Suzuki's stable doesn't boast many utility vehicles. It may
have to rely on its global synergies to launch a product like
Isuzu Panther in India
Few Big Cars
Suzuki isn't known for its big cars. The segment is set to grow.
It may want to cash in on its global synergies here.
Poor Marketing
Maruti has not been positioning its products correctly, especially
in terms of price. It invariably ends up reducing the price
in order to push volumes.
Cash-Strapped Dealers
Allowing dealers to give discounts larger than margins could
backfire, especially in the backdrop of a 15-25 per cent drop
in after-sales servicing.
Low success Rate
The last successful model Maruti launched was in 1993. None
of its five recent launches have recorded spectacular sales.
Reactive Image
Maruti is seen more as a follower than a leader. It launches
products in reaction to competition. And it hasn't introduced
a segment to the Indian market (barring Zen and Versa). |
A routine ACMA-OEM interplay did we say? The
vendors for their part should have expected something significant:
after all, this was the first time the Maruti top brass was catching
up with such a large number of vendors since the Japanese auto major
acquired a controlling stake in it in mid-May. But few counted on
such an ambitious target-wrapped along with the juiciest of carrots-being
thrown at them.
The instant reaction amongst the vendors was
that of disbelief. It's unrealistic, some felt, as their knees jerked.
But once they stepped out of the Gurgaon plant by 5.30 pm, cool-headed
analysis took over. A 30 per cent cut in costs was workable. It
had to be, for the benefit-the outsourcing opportunity-would be
huge. ''Two years back, our costs were 20 per cent higher. At that
point, we never thought we could lower them. Given Maruti's volumes,
we may succeed this time as well,'' says A.K. Taneja, Senior Executive
Director, Shriram Pistons & Rings.
Shriram Pistons is one of Maruti's 350 vendors
that Suzuki will ride on in the years to come. And don't forget
the 257 sales outlets developed along with the vendor base over
the past 19 years. "With competitors finding it difficult to
increase their reach amidst low profitability, this network of distributors
and service stations could emerge as a key strength for Suzuki,''
says Amul Gogna, Executive Director, ICRA.
Say hello to the new Maruti. Suzuki's Maruti.
A Maruti whose 350-strong vendor network will be used to source
lower-cost components for Suzuki's global operations. A Maruti that
will become the global hub for the Suzuki small car. A Maruti that's
turning the heat on its vendors to lower costs, but also luring
them by dangling the juicy carrot of sourcing. And, yes, a Maruti
that plans to consolidate its leadership in the Indian car bazaar
by playing the volumes game.
The Numbers Game
Last year, Maruti sold 3.52 lakh vehicles. Vijay
Mehta, Vice Chairman & Managing Director, Clutch Auto, says
it should work towards increasing volumes to 1 million over the
next five years, with exports contributing significantly. Kinji
Saito, Director (Marketing & Sales), has set a more "realistic''
target of 0.5 million cars over the next three-to-four years.
That figure could increase if Suzuki uses India
as an export base in a big way. The current year's export target
for completely-built units is ambitious: from sales of Rs 240 crore
clocked last year, Suzuki wants to more than double that figure
to Rs 500 crore by more than doubling volumes from 12,230 to 27,000.
Maruti's volumes coupled with India's status
of being the lowest cost producer of small cars in the world give
it an edge. What's more, the trend worldwide is shifting towards
smaller cars, packed with the gizmos and luxuries of a bigger car.
So it makes plenty of sense for Suzuki to encourage economies of
scale in India by sourcing cars and components from its operations
in the country.
Maruti's volumes ensure that the effect of
cost reductions is far greater in India than anywhere else. Suzuki
Motor is anyway known for keeping costs low over years. In Japan,
the price of a 550cc Alto for the last 23 years has increased by
barely Rs 40,000. "Prices don't increase in Japan," adds
Saito.
Khattar has been doing his bit on the cost
front back home. Last year, thanks to localisation, costs were trimmed
by Rs 70 crore, and another Rs 65 crore was shaved off by increasing
efficiencies on the vendor side. Overall, Maruti Udyog's operational
efficiency in 2001-02 improved by Rs 364 crore.
THREE'S COMPANY
|
With Suzuki in
the driver's seat, Maruti Udyog can now make use of its global
alliances to strengthen its position in India. General Motors
has a 20-per cent stake in both Suzuki and Fiat. Says Jagdish
Khattar, Managing Director, Maruti Udyog: "The alliance
can work for us in the future in more ways than one."
For starters, Maruti can source diesel engines from either
GM or Fiat at lower costs and also manufacture some bigger
cars from their stable at its Gurgaon plant. Suzuki may also
want to introduce an SUV like the Isuzu Panther through the
three-way alliance. GM and Fiat, for their part, can make
use of Maruti's vast dealer network and vendor base to sell
their cars and source cheaper components.
In other countries, Suzuki manufactures the Mazda and Nissan
models for GM. Suzuki developed a small car for GM in 2000,
known as the Asia car or YGM-1, launched in March this year
as Chevrolet Cruze. This is to be manufactured at Suzuki's
Kosai plant near Hamamatsu. In Canada, GM and Suzuki have
entered into a joint venture, CAMI. So, what will it be in
India?
|
Setting Things Right
Perhaps it's these cost-reduction initiatives
that have enabled Suzuki to correct some of the inequities that
existed on the pricing front. That could explain why, despite its
apparent dominance, Maruti's volumes don't come proportionately
from all its models. And Saito is pretty clear that Maruti has to
get its act together first on the domestic front, before contemplating
overseas opportunities. ''I am not satisfied with Maruti today,''
he shrugs. ''We have many models, but each one doesn't bring in
big volumes. We need to enhance volumes of each model."
That's why a little over a month after getting
into Maruti's driver's seat, Suzuki began setting things right.
In June-end, it lowered the price of the Versa by over Rs 1.15 lakh
through a promotional scheme. In late-July, Khattar slashed the
price of the flagship Maruti 800 by Rs 15,000-Rs 18,000. A few days
later, the Suzuki think-tank launched the WagonR Pride, opting for
the tried and tested marketing gimmick of winning more buyers through
the launch of limited editions. And last fortnight, Suzuki scored
another brownie point by flagging off a new-look Esteem along with
a diesel variant.
Says Hormazd Sorabjee, Editor, AutoCar India:
''I have always felt Maruti's problems have been internal. Now Suzuki
will really begin to flex its muscles.''
Competitors dismiss the recent price cuts and
model upgradations as a desperate attempt to arrest drooping sales.
During the first four months of the current fiscal, Maruti's volumes
have dropped 21 per cent, whereas Fiat, Hyundai Motor, and Tata
Engineering have seen their volumes surge. "They didn't have
a choice," says a competitor. "Suzuki undoubtedly has
acquired a market leader. But this is a market leader whose products
can't take a price hike, and that hasn't launched a successful model
since 1993 (the Zen), let alone taken the leadership in opening
a segment.''
|
"I am not satisfied with Maruti today.
We have many models, but we need to enhance volumes of each
model ."
Kinji Saito, Director (Marketing
and Sales), MUL |
Harsh words, those. But not incorrect. And the
Suzuki-heavy management is well aware of the lacunae in its India
operation. To be sure, many of Maruti Udyog's weaknesses emanate
from the manner in which the company has been functioning over the
last 19 years. Most dealerships and vendors were appointed more
on the basis of political considerations than entrepreneurial skills.
Along the way, Maruti acquired a lot of flab (which Khattar has
been working on reducing for the last two years).
A more serious problem for Maruti is the financial
health of its dealers. "If Maruti Udyog doesn't mend its policy
towards dealers, 30 per cent of them will shut shop over the next
couple of years,'' says a Delhi-based dealer. Maruti dealers often
compete with one another, rather than fighting competition. Unlike
companies like Hyundai Motor India, which don't allow dealers to
sell cars at discounts greater than their margins (in a bid to meet
their sales targets and earn more incentives), Maruti Udyog dealers
often subsidise discounts with income from their service stations.
THE SUZUKI PIPELINE
|
Ignis
A hatchback that will take on Fiat Palio and Hyundai Getz
Expected price: Rs 4-5 lakh
Engine capacity: 1,300cc
Expected launch date: 2002-end
or early 2003
Grand
Vitara
A sports utility vehicle to be positioned against Hyundai
Terracan and Honda CR-V
Expected price: Rs 14-15 lakh
Engine capacity: 2,400cc
Expected launch date: 2002-end
or early 2003
Liana
Suzuki's new mid-size car will take on Opel Astra and Mitsubishi
Lancer
Expected price: Rs 8-9 lakh
Engine capacity: 1,300cc and 1,600cc
Expected launch date: 2003-end/2004
|
Another weakness-which is actually a Suzuki
problem-is the inadequate diesel-model presence in the portfolio.
Maruti needs to focus more on diesel cars, agrees Khattar. The runaway
success of Indica v2 Diesel and Palio diesel has proved that this
segment can't be ignored. But Suzuki doesn't make diesel engines.
Maruti sources engines for Zen diesel and Esteem from Peugeot. In
future, Suzuki may want to rely on its alliance partners-Fiat and
General Motors-to source cheaper diesel engines (See Three's Company).
Big cars is another weakness of Suzuki. And
the C segment (Ford Ikon/Maruti Esteem/Hyundai Accent) is bound
to grow once B-segment car users (Maruti Zen/Hyundai Santro/Fiat
Palio) graduate to bigger cars. Suzuki has one new product-Liana-which
it could bring to India. Liana was launched in 2001, in Japan and
comes in 1,328cc and 1,586cc engine capacities. It's a bigger car
than the Esteem and Suzuki may want to launch it after a year, depending
on the size of the segment and the state of the economy. For now,
Maruti is more likely to address the market with products like the
Grand Vitara and the Ignis.
When Osamu Suzuki decided to set up shop in
India in 1982 along with the Indian government, his Japanese counterparts
thought he was crazy. Today the Suzuki Chairman is earning royalties
many times over the Rs 66 crore he initially invested in the company.
From now on, though, with Suzuki in the driving
seat, Osamu will have to pump in big money to consolidate his leadership
in the Indian market even as he draws out plans to make Maruti a
global sourcing base for his global operations. His time starts
now.
|