It's
late on a scorching Sunday afternoon but a couple of hundred people
are going crazy on the first and second floors of Sahara Mall, a
yet-to-be-fully-completed shopping complex in Delhi's satellite
township, Gurgaon. The mall's cinema halls and food courts aren't
ready yet, but upstairs, at Big Bazaar, the mall's sole tenant,
shoppers are in a frenzy. Dodging someone here, tackling someone
else there, like a mad pack of rugby players the otherwise perfectly
well-heeled customers are going crazy trying to grab stuff. What
stuff? Polypacks of atta, pack-of-three hand towels, shirts... anything.
The guppies (this magazine's epithet for Gurgaon's upwardly mobile)
have taken to the bare-bones, no-frills hypermarket like, well,
fish to water.
|
Cheaper than the rest: the Big Bazaar
outlet in Gurgaon |
"The organised retail business is on the
verge of take-off here," gushes Kishore Biyani, the Rs 175-crore
Big Bazaar's maverick promoter, who refuses to travel to the USA
as a matter of business principle, lest he is influenced by big
brand retailers whose models, he claims, are not up to scratch for
the Indian market! Almost a decade after Shoppers' Stop put the
flag out for organised retail with the launch of its first department
store in Mumbai, hypermarkets promise to mass-roll organised retail
in India. "Department stores like Shoppers' Stop and speciality
retailers like FoodWorld, have touched just 40-50 million people.
Organised retail's potential to reach 300-million people has barely
been scratched," says Vivek Mathur, Partner at Bangalore-based
Integrated Retail Management Consulting. For the record, just under
2 per cent of the Rs 90,000-crore retail industry in India is organised.
A hypermarket is essentially a large retail
space (upwards of 20,000 square feet) where shoppers can buy groceries,
food, garments, home appliances, durables, toys, cosmetics, toiletries,
even books and music in some cases, at a price always lower-from
5 to 50 per cent- than the market price. At hypermarkets, it's not
the brands, labels or the ephemeral shopping experience that drives
business but products and prices. And consumers are voting with
their feet across the country, in Gurgaon, Delhi, Hyderabad, Kolkata,
Chennai and Mumbai.
|
"My business plan
is to sell to customer at the price that a retailer would buy"
R. Subramanian, MD, Subhiksha |
Each of Big Bazaar's six outlets gets 6,000
footfalls on a weekday and 20,000 on weekends. RPG Group's Giant
in Hyderabad gets nearly 15,000 every day. And The Home Store's
(THS) two Super Sabka Bazaars in Delhi manage 30,000 between them,
every day. "This is the retail format where every second urban
Indian consumer can shop," adds Arif Sheikh, President of the
Rs 639-crore THS. So while supermarkets mostly sell food, and department
stores, branded apparel, hypermarkets' all inclusive product platter
appeals to consumers.
|
Biz Bazaar
6 stores
20,000 footfalls per day per store
Rs 175 crore sales (2002-2003)
Giant
1 store
15,000 footfalls per day per store Rs
85 crore sales (2002-2003)*
Super Sabka Bazaar
2 stores
15,000 footfalls per day per store Rs
120 crore sales (2002-2003)*
*Industry Estimate
|
Hypermarket Boom
Little wonder then, hypermarkets are springing
up like mushrooms. THS is opening its third Super Sabka Bazaar,
a mammoth 1,20,000-square feet store in Faridabad, later in the
year. RPG group company, The Great Wholesale Club (it runs Giant)
plans to open a Giant each in Mumbai, Bangalore and Chennai in the
next 12 months. And Biyani talks about another three Biz Bazaars
in the next three months-in Nagpur, Bhubhaneshwar and Ahmedabad-and,
in all, 14 by end 2004. Joining the fray is b2c India, which runs
the Adani supermarket chain, with plans for four hypermarkets in
Ahmedabad early next year. And Ahaar International plans 30 hypermarkets
in and around the national capital region by next year. Even Trent,
the Rs 40,000-crore Tata group's retail venture, has plans for a
chain of hypermarkets.
That Indian consumers are taking to hypermarkets
is clear from the way all three existing chains (with nine stores
amongst them) are thriving, making cash profits within a year of
their launch. And yet, this business is not for the faint-hearted.
It literally means ploughing money into real estate and working
capital (for managing upwards of 25,000 stock-keeping units). And
guarding every penny of cost, for margins are low, at 11 per cent,
against 14-15 per cent for department stores and supermarkets.
THS, for instance, pays no rentals for Super
Sabka Bazaar and works only on revenue sharing with its landlord
(shelling out 2-3.5 per cent of net sales) and sources over 95 per
cent of its 26,000-odd SKUs from 1,600 suppliers to keep supply
chain costs below 1.5 per cent. "We stock big brand FMCGs for
topline, but it is the groceries that give us the bottomline,"
adds THS' Sheikh. For FMCGs, these hypermarkets give discounts from
their margins, so it is like running a very tight ship.
Giant deals directly with its suppliers, while
Big Bazaar operates through buying agents or consolidators. In fact,
such is the dependence on high-margin commodity-level categories
in groceries (Super Sabka Bazaar) or own-label apparel (Big Bazaar),
that at least a third or more of store sales need to come in from
here for the business to be profitable. Big Bazaar thrives on massive
promotions, with almost 70 per cent of all merchandise on discount
between 2 and 60 per cent. The store already has private labels
for tea, salt and spices.
ADVANTAGE HYPERMARKETS |
» No
major brands, apart from fast-moving-consumer-goods; and bulk
sourcing means lower consumer price
» A all-under-one-roof
model-groceries, food, apparel, and fast moving consumer goods-makes
them a (monthly) destination store
» Bare-bones
infrastructure (no carpeted floor, fancy lighting, or piped
music) makes them 'accessible' to larger urban audience
» High average
(consumer) billing means property, staff and working capital
costs are utilised optimally compared to other retailers
» Attractive
for shopping malls as anchor stores, because they have stickiness
with large number of consumers |
"The main identification factor (of a hypermarket)
is the extent of consolidation that the format achieves and the
unique value proposition it offers," says Kruben Moodliar,
Chief Executive of The Great Wholesale Club. High volumes and larger
bargaining power with suppliers keeps the bottomline ticking. Giant,
in just under two years of operation and with just one store, is
amongst the top five retailers for many consumer durable products
in the country. And THS' Sheikh claims that within a year of Super
Sabka Bazaar's existence in Delhi, big brand marketers such as Hindustan
Lever or Coca-Cola have started delivery at individual stores and
even appointed key account managers to manage the relationships.
"No one likes to call themselves a discount
store, but they are just that," says Harminder Sahni, Associate
Director at KSA Technopak. The six-year-old Rs 365-crore Subhiksha
Supermarkets, which runs small 1,500-2,000 square feet outlets,
153 of them now in Tamil Nadu, is a pioneer of the discount format.
As is the Rs 450-crore Margin Free, which runs 150 stores in Kerala
and leverages its six lakh customer base for discount deals with
manufacturers. "My business plan is simple. Sell to customer
at the price that a normal retailer would buy for his store,"
adds R. Subramanian, Managing Director, Subhiksha.
|
"The identification
factor of a hypermarket is the value proposition it offers"
Kruben Moodliar, CEO, The Great Wholesale Club |
A Balancing Act
Hypermarkets are a compelling proposition.
For new players, it takes a large number of stores to make a superstore
chain a success. RPG's Foodworld started out in 1996 and broke even
only in 2000-01, when it had 80 stores. Shoppers' Stop, when starting
out in 1992-93, became profitable with just one store, but soon
slipped into the red and turned a profit only in 2001, after it
had two dozen stores. On the other hand, hypermarkets are stand-alone
businesses that can break even in one or two years. For existing
players, much like Pantaloons (Big Bazaar's parent), RPG or THS,
it is a natural extension of their business, with better amortisation
of their back-end costs. THS leverages its bulk-buying for Super
Sabka Bazaar with its 19 Sabka Bazaar food supermarkets. Ditto for
RPG's Giant, with its superstores for food (FoodWorld), music (MusicWorld)
and cosmetics (Health & Glow). Likewise, Big Bazaar benefits
from Biyani's core competence in textile production and apparel,
with Pantaloons.
Yet the business is fraught with risks. "With
wafer-thin margins, even a half-a-percentage slip in costs can be
life threatening," cautions THS' Sheikh. For the rash of new
players that means playing the volumes game is not always easy.
Enticing consumers with ease of shopping, product range and sharper
pricing is one thing. Keeping a check on costs and driving up volumes
is another. The key is in keeping a balance. Through the hype about
hypermarkets, retailers will need to ensure that this new business
model doesn't keel over under its own weight.
inputs from Nitya Varadarajan and
Dipayan Baishya
|