The
storm isn't here yet, but the lull seen in January has certainly
given way to reasonably strong winds. In February, diversified
equity schemes on an average generated a healthy 9.8 per cent
absolute return, with its fund managers outperforming the benchmark
indices, Nifty and Sensex, which gave 4.72 per cent and 4.59 per
cent return respectively. Out of the 90 schemes considered in
this category, 71 beat both the Sensex and the Nifty. Not every
sector benefited, though. FMCG, the best performers in January
riding on the appreciation in the FMCG index, went into negative
territory this month. Balanced schemes on an average gave 4.64
per cent absolute return compared to negative 0.89 per cent return
last month. A positive budget announced by the Finance Minister
on the last day of the month did not just help the Sensex close
at an (then) all time high of 6,713.86 points, but also brought
smiles to the Indian mutual funds industry, since the budget opened
the gates for the introduction of gold-linked exchange traded
funds. Gold can now find its way in portfolios of small investors
through the MF route. The introduction of Sec 88C also helps the
MF industry as the investment limit of Rs 10,000 in Equity Linked
Savings Schemes (ELSS) has been removed, and investors can now
invest up to Rs 1,00,000. Debt funds also recovered and generated
higher returns this month. The average annualised returns from
income schemes moved up from around 4 per cent to 7 per cent,
while MIPs moved from a negative territory to give 13 per cent
simple annualised return.
How They Performed
Among diversified equity schemes, the low-profile
SBI Funds Management continued to do well, with three of its schemes
figuring in the toppers. SBI Magnum Sector Umbrella (Emerging
Business) topped the list with 13.36 per cent absolute return
against a negative return last month. It had a high exposure in
the electronics and textile sector. Tax saving schemes this month
on an average gave 6 per cent absolute return in the ELSS category,
which was a good bit high compared to January. SBI Magnum Tax
Gain topped with 12.83 per cent return, even though it has a relatively
small fund size. Havell's India finds the highest allocation in
the scheme at 8.3 per cent. Among sectoral funds, Reliance Diversified
Power Fund was the runaway leader with 16.46 per cent return,
way above its peers, none of whom could manage a double-digit
return. The average return in this category was approximately
4.5 per cent. With a decent fund size, Reliance Diversified Power
had the highest exposure in Siemens Ltd., while last month it
was in Crompton Greaves.
Then, in the balanced funds category, Escorts
Balanced retained top billing in February, with 49 per cent exposure
in the equity segment and highest exposure in acc Ltd. Tata Balanced
and HDFC Prudence remained marginally behind. Balanced schemes
gave 4.64 per cent return on an average for the month. Compared
to other categories, MIPs remained in favour since they generate
higher returns with lesser risk. This time the topper was HDFC
MIP LTP with 26.47 per cent simple annualised return. A sterling
performance, given that the category average was almost half that
at 13.55 per cent. HDFC MIP has 21 per cent exposure in equity
and 65 per cent in debt. Finally, income funds gave 7 per cent
annualised return on an average in February, but Grindlays dbf,
with an average maturity of 201 days, managed to give double that
at 14 per cent, which was a huge improvement from a low 3.15 per
cent in January. Grindlays was followed by two UTI schemes.
The positives coming out of the month of
February are expected to continue, if not improve further. With
the budget giving the markets much cause to cheer, the outlook
remains extremely positive. Mutual funds are able to continuously
mobilise money in equity funds and have been net buyers. With
new tailor-made products, such as derivative funds, coming up
for investors, the good times are set to roll through the next
month.
The Arbitrage
Opportunity
Lay investors, with small sums of money, can
now take advantage of arbitrage opportunities through mutual funds.
By Shilpa Nayak
In
theory, arbitrage sounds simple. Buy stock of a company from one
stock exchange and sell it in a different exchange or market (say,
futures) where it is trading at a higher price, and you earn a
profit. In practice, though, it's not so simple. Variations in
stock prices in different exchanges or markets happen for very
short periods of time (a couple of seconds), and for you to be
able to spot it, and cash in on it, requires expertise, and sophisticated
software. Then, the price difference is usually negligible, which
means unless you are willing to put in huge sums of money, what
you earn is not worth the effort, or the broker commission. All
this time, therefore, arbitrage opportunities were provided by
prominent brokers only to high net-worth clients.
How You Gain
Assume you have Rs 15 lakh to
invest. Here's how you gain if you go in for arbitrage as
against a traditional bank fixed deposit (FD). |
What you do:
1. Buy shares
of a company, say, XYZ Ltd., for Rs 9 lakh
2. Sell XYZ Ltd.
futures for Rs 9.10 lakh
3. Use Rs 3 lakh
for margin deposit (against the futures)
4. Invest the
rest (Rs 3 lakh) in a bank FD for one month
What you earn:
» On
XYZ Ltd. (arbitrage): Rs 10,000
»
On bank FD (@5% annual interest): Rs 1,250
»
Total earning: Rs 11,250
What You Gain
Had you instead deposited the entire Rs 15 lakh in a bank
FD for a month, you would have earned Rs 6,250 only. By
leveraging the arbitrage opportunity, therefore, you earn
Rs 5,000 extra.
Investor Tip
If the transactions were carried out through a broker, the
income (Rs 11,250) would be added to your taxable income,
but not if you went through an MF. Fixed deposit returns,
of course, are taxable.
|
Now, with mutual funds (MFs) entering the
fray, the picture could change. On December 18, 2004, Benchmark
mf launched Benchmark Derivative Fund, the first-ever arbitrage
(derivative) fund in India. Sanjiv Shah, Executive Director, Benchmark
mf, explains: "The idea is to generate market-neutral returns
by exploiting the arbitrage opportunity in Indian capital markets."
Globally, such funds are seen as an alternative to debt investments
for investors who don't have the stomach to handle stock-market
gyrations. According to Shah, investments for up to a year can
mop up tidy returns. Investors appear to have taken up the cue,
with Benchmark's fund having received Rs 51.79 crore of investor
money as of January 31, 2005, and generated absolute returns of
0.64 per cent, which translates into annualised returns of 7.68
per cent, higher than what debt instruments routinely return.
Then, on February 4, 2005, JM Mutual launched
its version of a derivate fund called JM Equity and Derivative
Fund. Tagged an "income-oriented interval scheme", the
fund "would generate returns by capturing MIS-pricing in
the cash and the futures market", according to its fund manager
Biren Mehta. Since the fund would take advantage of price differences
in two markets, JM expects to yield around 7 per cent returns.
The only hitch with arbitrage could be that
opportunities may dwindle in the event of a stock market crash.
However, in such an eventuality, these derivative funds would
invest their corpuses in money market instruments (such as government
securities or t-bills), just like a normal liquid fund would,
and generate 4-5 per cent returns, ensuring that you don't lose
out totally. But given the current boom in the stock markets in
India, a bearish phase seems an unlikely scenario, despite the
interim corrections. So, go ahead, do your arbitrage.
|