If
ever there were to be a consumer market utopia in India, we are
surely on our way there. For not only does the Business Today-Indica
Research Index of Consumer Sentiment (BT-IRICS)-that measures
sentiment across 10 major cities-for May 2005 stand at its all-time,
three-year high (BT-IRICS started out in August 2002) of 206,
it has leapfrogged almost 22 per cent in a matter of just four
months, from an already high 169 in January this year. And remarkably,
all 11 index variables have moved up in tandem and reached new
peaks.
From the consumer's sense of her current
economic situation, future economic expectations and consumption
mood, everything is gung-ho. Current income is up 28 per cent
and expectations of rise in future income up a whopping 42 per
cent. Not without reason. For, salaries across the board in corporate
India have jumped over 15 per cent in FY 2005 (see cover story
Skyrocketing Salaries on page 48). Business conditions look upbeat,
and it will only improve in the next 12 months.
"We're getting a loud and clear message
from the consumer. And it's not just on increased consumption,
but more importantly on change in the fundamentals that drive
consumption," says Nakul Chopra, Group President of ad major
Publicis India. He is right. Take the case of eternal consumption
bugbears such as job insecurity and price rise. Just about a fourth
of all consumers are pessimistic about employment now compared
to two-thirds to three-fourths almost six months to a year ago.
And price negativity is down to just 15 per cent of all consumers
compared to over 80 per cent all these years.
Not that prices aren't going to go up, but
it has more to do with consumer mindset change than price per
se. For, inflation is still over 5 per cent and there is risk
of manufactured goods prices escalating if the artificially subdued
oil prices were to be upped by the government. And quite a few
manufacturers are already taking prices up or at least calling
off long-running prices wars, such as in detergents, toothpastes
and two-wheelers. But by all indications, demand across consumer
market in durables, autos, expendables and entertainment remains
strong and headed north.
"There is belief in the country, across
government, industry and the consumer that if high global oil
prices did not impact growth anywhere else, why should it be different
for India?" says Indranil Pan, Chief Economist at Kotak Mahindra
Bank. Little wonder the most pessimistic forecast of economic
growth for 2005-06 (surprisingly coming out of the Prime Minister's
Economic Advisory Council) is a good 6.7 per cent, with a caveat
of 0.5 per cent bonus growth if the monsoon turns good and the
government took some proactive policy initiatives in the infrastructure
sector.
"A high index (BT-IRICS) is coinciding
with the upward economic and investment cycle across the economy,"
says Rajiv Kumar, Chief Economist at CII. Non-food credit growth,
a measure of industry borrowings, remains strong. Interest and
lending rates are expected to remain stable. The only real concern
is the monsoon, because manufacturing and services growth is pretty
much on auto-pilot, predicted to grow over 7 per cent and 8-9
per cent, respectively.
It is the volatility in agriculture growth-up
more than 10 per cent in 2003-04, but down to under one per cent
last year-that makes the difference between average, good or great
economic growth. "For some time now the two-wheeler market
has grown on the strength of cities," says S. Shridhar, Vice
President (Marketing & Sales), Bajaj Auto. With over 60 per
cent of 4.9 million two-wheeler sales coming in from rural and
semi-urban markets, agriculture growth will be critical in reaching
the 15 per cent growth that the industry is gunning for in FY
2006.
"Our major concern from here on is not
so much growth but its distribution across various income segments,"
says Kotak's Pan. A fact borne out by BT-IRICS new parallel track
on socio economic classification (SEC) C consumers (see The SEC
C Effect and A World Of Difference). For just about everything-from
current economic status, economic expectations to consumption
mood-SEC C consumers are somewhat restrained compared to an out-and-out
bullish SEC A & B consumer.
Perhaps this explains why marketers who are
now tapping upcountry and middle-to-lower income consumers in
big cities, though positive on growth, are still shy of committing
big and bold marketing investments. The silver lining though is
that new SEC A, B & C BT-IRICS is still 4 per cent higher
at 176 compared to 169 in January 2005. And there is an almost
30 per cent increase in even SEC C consumers who are spending
more now compared to even four months ago. "The outlook for
all cafe chains is rosy," says Brotin Banerjee, COO, Barista
Coffee Company. Obviously, more and all manner of consumers are
walking into the 450-odd coffee cafes that dot the country. A
rising economic tide, it seems, will set everyone's boat clipping.
Indica Research Index of Consumer Sentiment:
The Indica Research Opinion
The Great Indian Elbow Point |
The
BT-IRICS index has crossed 200 with a whoosh, and moves to
206 from 169 in Feb. 2005. The SEC A & B householders
expect their financial status to improve and prices to behave
well-so the perception of income relative to price has improved
a lot. And they are in a mood to spend.
Looking from a consumption standpoint, the summer is traditionally
a period when nothing much happens. Categories that have
a direct relation to summer witness a seasonal peak-ice
cream and soft drinks-for instance. Another category that
enjoys its seasonal high is education-be it the formal one
or the informal sector of tuitions or preparations for cat.
But these no longer seem to hold true. Indeed the anecdotal
evidence is that in several categories the peaks and valleys
are getting evened out-another indication of spending that
is not specifically constrained or timed.
This is driven by the larger pricing regimes too. The
data suggests that it's the perception of price where the
improvement is pronounced-and hence the translation into
a better expectation on the income relative to price. The
prices have temptingly dropped in some categories like home
theatre systems and consumer electronics. But they have
most visibly dropped on air travel, a service that is both
functional and aspirational to the middle class.
HOW WE DID IT |
»
Total sample 1,220
» 10
cities: Delhi (135), Mumbai (120), Chennai (120), Bangalore
(120), Hyderabad (120), Kolkata (120), Ahmedabad (120),
Lucknow (125), Cochin (120), Nagpur (120)
» Purely
random sampling process; 609 male and 611 female; SEC
A 414 respondents, SEC B 402 respondents and SEC C 404
respondents
» Face-to-face
interviews using a structured questionnaire
»
The questionnaire covered three core areas: current
assessment of economic situation, expectation about
the future economic situation and overall consumption
mood
»
Besides key variables for indexing, the survey measured
explanatory measures
»
All data was weighted; each variable first indexed for
Nett optimism
»
Data then indexed as proportion of total score possible
»
This index then weighted to arrive at All India Index
of Consumer Confidence |
The budget did have some oddities like the FBT, but it
does not affect the larger set of SEC A and B. On the other
hand, the stock markets and the successful IPOs, one would
expect, would have actually released spendable amounts into
the wallet.
Moreover, the data also suggests that the penetration
of mobiles has crossed the 50 per cent mark (the sample
average is 51 per cent across all markets). It is nowhere
close to what the international evidence would suggest as
being the potential, so one can expect the action to shift
to the smaller towns. This would then yield some discretionary
monies to flow into a variety of other categories in the
metros and larger cities as well.
Amidst all this optimism amongst SEC A and B, we must
note the difference in SEC C, which we included in this
round (the future IRICS measurements will include SEC C).
They are not that optimistic-the index when SEC C is included
is still higher but not that much-176. The notable disquiet
is in the North, where the optimism amongst the traders
and small businessmen, who also constitute a part of the
SEC C, is dampened by the vat implementation.
We daresay that this data would lend support to the 'tipping
point' theory that we hypothesised in February. If the monsoons
are also good, we should look forward to a buoyant year
of consumption.
So a range of factors are working together, some ephemeral
perhaps, but some fundamental. All in all it certainly points
to exciting times ahead-what with even the other Great Indian
Elbow now seemingly well on the way to complete recovery
in a few weeks.
|
|