The
future of the Indian IT/BPO industry has never been brighter.
The most recent nasscom-McKinsey report estimates the addressable
offshore opportunity at over $300 billion (Rs 1,350,000 crore),
$110 billion (Rs 495,000 crore) of which is realisable by 2010
and $60 billion (Rs 270,000 crore) by Indian players. Analysts
report over $100 billion (Rs 450,000 crore) in outsourcing contracts
are up for renewal over the next two years and several of these
customers seek to "multi-source" large contracts. Finally,
our billion-dollar babies, are increasingly invited to bid for,
and are winning, several $100 million-plus deals. We seem almost
destined to win, but do we know what we're winning?
There are two dimensions to this uncertainty that vendors need
to understand more fully. First, a deeper look at the nasscom-McKinsey
projections reveal that over 70 per cent of the growth in it and
80 per cent in BPO come from areas relatively new to Indian offshore
vendors, including systems integration and infrastructure outsourcing
in it, and several industry-specific processes in areas like travel
& hospitality and automotive manufacturing in BPO. Do these
new areas require skill or scale-based competition? Do you have
to adapt or separate your existing commercial and operating model
to compete? Second, a recent review of several large outsourcing
deals by McKinsey's Business Technology Operations practice reveals
that approximately 50 per cent of large deals fall short on customer
and vendor expectations, failing to deliver intended results.
Companies are often so focussed on getting rock-bottom prices
and vendors on winning big-ticket deals, they both often agree
to risky arrangements with uncertain cost projections. What will
Indian vendors do differently to avoid pure price-based competition
in larger deals?
Indian vendors need to think about two key elements: managing
uncertainty and deepening specialisation. The management's ability
to deal with the uncertainty of larger deals, whose economics
are less clear at the outset, will require at least three new
skills. Knowing how to organise for mega deals, whose pursuit
costs can be very high involving multiple stakeholders and advisors.
Making economics on large deals work in your favour, especially
when multiple parts of the technology stack including business
process, applications and infrastructure are included and abilities
in one or more of these areas may be weak. The ability to underwrite
calculated risks, especially when customers demand fixed price
guarantees and there is no clear line-of-sight to future economics.
Next, deepening specialisation is an industry imperative, in
the face of commoditising generic Application Development/Application
Maintenance and voice-based bpo service lines, and cost-based
competition from other low cost countries. Options to consider
under specialisation are:
The IT specialist(s): A focussed it-oriented service
provider focussed on one or more major industry verticals like
financial services, travel & hospitality, or automotive manufacturing,
with a deep understanding of industry-specific enterprise applications
and integration issues. Alternatively, building an industry agnostic
service line like desktop infrastructure management and provisioning,
or horizontal application integration and off-license support.
The ADM factory: A global low-cost provider of applications
development and maintenance services enabled by a 'lean' operating
environment. Built with a manufacturing mindset of superior operations
scalability, such a player would employ over 50,000 developers
in India and other low-cost geographies and produce the lowest
unit-cost developer. An ADM factory would have relationships with
large/mid-sized enterprises, and consulting and systems integration
firms that cannot afford to build low-cost global delivery.
The BPO Specialist(s): There are three flavors of specialisation
among BPO providers. First, an operator of industry-standard transaction
or platform-based services, like card or payroll processing, relying
on standardisation and scale to achieve the lowest unit-cost per
transaction possible. Second, a business reengineering provider
that has industry-specific expertise on improving productivity
via both process and it redesign. Third, highly specialised services
that require professional training/certification, such as legal,
chip design or radiology services.
The Global Champion: A full service integrated global
it and BPO provider offering multiple service lines to large global
companies. Their specialisation is the ability to integrate services
across multiple units/providers and manage large and complex accounts,
delivering several services seamlessly. These companies will have
global delivery centers/partners across India, China, Eastern
Europe and Latin America.
So, we're back to the classic question of where to compete and
how to secure superior returns while meeting customer and market
expectations. We're drunk on the fumes of potential, growth is
baked into promising valuations, and we've seen global it services
majors sacrifice profitability at the altar of growth. Our future
has arrived, how can we avoid being blinded by it?
Vivek Pandit is a Partner in McKinsey's
Mumbai office, leader of McKinsey's Software & Services Practice
in Asia, and a co-author of the NASSCOM-McKinsey 2005 report
|