Five
months after the sudden sell-off in May 2006, when speculation
and over-leverage undid even some savvy investors, the market
bounced back in quick time to its all time high. So swift was
this recovery that most investors were left sitting on the fence,
waiting for an opportunity to buy. As markets at all-time highs
usually go, it's no wonder investors are returning by the droves.
But behind the market's new milestone lies a note of caution:
rein in your excesses.
Sure, there's plenty happening to warrant
the confidence. Sure, corporate profits have been exceptional-indeed
as good as it could get-and foreign investors continue to be charmed
by the great Indian story, investing more than $4.3 billion (Rs
19,350 crore) in the last four months. Gross domestic product
(GDP) growth rates have never been better at 8.9 per cent in the
first quarter, driven by the booming manufacturing and steady
services sectors. Sure, the Sensex is looking better each passing
day.
But the truth is: valuations, that ultimate
barometer by which you gauge whether the stock you buy is cheap
or not, stands at 21 times trailing earnings for the Sensex. And
that's not really cheap. "Let's not forget that the main
strength of this market is foreign funds and strong liquidity,"
says R. Sreesankar, Head (Research), IL&FS Investsmart. But
signs are the valuations are beginning to look a lot more expensive
than say a year ago. "The valuations aren't that cheap,"
continues Sreesankar.
Not Easy Now
The stiff valuation of this market does not
make stock investing particularly easy for you. While a robust
second quarter earnings has prompted brokerages to pull out their
spreadsheets and re-calculate and upgrade the earnings estimates
for the Sensex, these higher numbers have yet to make the market
watchers feel comfortable enough. Even after the upgrades, the
consensus earnings estimate for 2006-07 is somewhere around Rs
690-700. Motilal Oswal, in a report, reckons it more precisely
at Rs 692 for 2006-07. But the all-important forward PE of the
market at the 13,190 level stands at a lofty 19 times earnings.
On the other hand, the market's historical average PE has been
just about 15 times.
But despite the higher PE ratios, it's unlikely
that the market will revert to its average mean because of the
higher growth rates of the Indian corporate sector. Earnings in
the latest quarter have been up 23 per cent for the Sensex stocks,
which is higher than the market's price earnings ratio. So, analysts
reason that the valuations are not all that out of sync. Says
Nitin Raheja, Chief Investment Officer (Equities), Dawnay Day
AV: "It all depends on what you look at in the market. Various
sectors have contributed to the growth of the index at different
times like banking now and it before this. It's backed by good
reason."
Of Risks...
But the risk-reward ratio probably is still
skewed towards stocks. Of course, stocks are volatile as they
have been especially during the last few years. They are more
volatile than bonds, though bonds are equally volatile than many
investors seem to realise going by their price movements in the
markets. But the real risk for investors is when long-term returns
do not keep pace with inflation. Raamdeo Agarwal, joint Managing
Director, Motilal Oswal, reckons that the investing now is still
tilted towards equity as compared to debt, despite the recent
run-up of the market.
Agarwal compares the price earnings of the
current market with the 10-year bond valuations. A bond valuation
can be figured out by dividing its price, say Rs 100, by the yield
or interest it fetches. Currently, the 10-year government bond
yield is around 7.5 per cent, which works out to 5.25 per cent
post-tax for the 30 per cent tax bracket. If you divide 100 (the
price of the bond) by its post-tax yield of 5.25, the 10-year
bond PE would work out to 19 times. However, the one-year forward
valuation of the Sensex also stands at 19 times. By that yardstick,
Agarwal concludes that the market is not over-priced and over
the distance can do well. "In a bond market, one can barely
preserve the purchasing power of money," surmises Agarwal,
"but with stocks one can."
...And Rewards
But the all-important question: what future
returns can one expect? Over the last 10 years, the Sensex's rolling
returns, which is the average annual returns generated every year
as on October 2006, is about 20 per cent per annum. A bulk of
this was generated in the last four years as the Sensex gave negative
returns in the three preceding years before that. A combination
of earnings growth as well as expanding valuations, as the PEs
doubled from 10 to 20, have been major reasons for fabulous returns
in the last four years.
Perhaps there's a reason for some of the
stocks or sectors to do better than others. Some of it, for now,
has a lot to do with laws of demand and supply and the stock market
is no exception to this. Over the last one year, it was the big
Sensex companies or the large non-Sensex companies that saw huge
amount of inflows as the demand for liquid companies in which
foreign investors could enter and exit easily were in great demand.
As of now, though, there's not much of an
elbow room for an upward expansion in the valuations of the big
companies. If all things remain equal, a PE expansion from the
current levels of 21 to, say 25, will yield a return of 19 per
cent, which is not that significant given that stocks are such
risky assets. Besides, it means valuations will get to precariously
higher levels. Says Manish Chokani, Managing Director (MD), Enam
Financial Services: "The bigger stocks will probably not
perform as well if there's just a steady expansion in earnings.
It's better to focus on the pay-back from companies irrespective
of what happens to the market."
Margin Of Safety
Perhaps a more significant strategy for an
investor is to seek out those companies where there's a big margin
of safety in both earnings and valuations, says Enam's Chokani.
As markets go higher, picking the right stocks for your portfolio
gets harder and it becomes increasingly difficult to outperform
the market. So, Chokani advices to pick stocks that can double
their earnings in the next three years where the valuations are
lower. "This will give me a double comfort zone if anything
should go wrong with the markets or future earnings. Over two
to three years, it's a better way to go."
Think Long Term
What worries anybody, especially lay investors,
are sudden sell-offs, such as the ones witnessed this May. These
market crashes were essentially caused by a sudden offloading
by global funds across the world. In less liquid markets such
as India, they cause mayhem and the small investor begins to lose
confidence. But if you play sufficiently for the long-term such
short-term blips are the opportunities to grab. Besides, the impact
of short-term volatility due to any adverse news gets reduced
over time. Says Raheja: "The best way to meet volatility
is to invest for the long-term."
Diversify
It's the first defensive measure to follow
in any market. With most stocks ruling at their all time highs,
it becomes increasingly important to mix different stocks of growth
that are reasonably valued without exposing your portfolio to
a lot of risk. Some of the best moving stocks in the recent past
have been the ones that are well-managed and are poised to grow
by scaling up their operations and expanding into newer markets.
Besides, this market has been awarding quality companies with
higher valuations. So even if you are looking into the vast tier
of mid-caps and small caps, shortlist only among those that have
a sound management and a good business prospects going forward.
Hold Cash Too
Opportunities in this market come as quickly
as they go. As the economy is doing well and some of the growth
companies already discovered by the market, much of the future
earnings is already priced in. So, it's probably not advisable
to hold all your assets in stocks. Keep a little cash for those
small buying opportunities that could come by chance, advises
Chokani. He reckons it's good to keep about 20 per cent in cash.
The Complete
Fund
If keeping
tabs on different funds is a chore when all you need is simple
asset allocation, a fund of funds may be just right.
By Mahesh Nayak
|
"About 85 per
cent of returns depend upon the way assets are allocated"
Mahendra Jajoo
Head (Fixed Income & Structured Products), ABN AMro
AMC |
Navin
Singh, 24, senior manager at a Mumbai-based BPO, is looking to
make the best of this bull market, and yet play it safe with other
asset classes. Having learnt that he should not keep all his cash
in the equity basket, he's planning to diversify across equities
and other asset classes such as corporate debt and gilt securities.
But sifting through funds and narrowing down to a select few to
complete his asset-allocation mix seemed like the proverbial needle
in the haystack. Instead, Navin decided on an alternative option:
fund of funds.
The basics
What is an FoF? A fund of funds is a mutual
fund that invests in other mutual funds. It helps investors to
invest in many types of funds (that include equity, debt or a
mix of both) and different fund manager styles through just a
single investment. So if you need a proper asset-allocation, it
may seem like the way to go. "Investors can balance asset
allocation in a more systematic way and therefore hope to give
a superior outcome," says Mahendra Jajoo, Head (Fixed Income
& Structured Products), ABN Amro AMC. "Historically,
it's been proved that 85 per cent of returns depend upon the asset
allocation. Through our FoF we plan to focus on asset allocation."
As risks can be diversified by investing
in two-three different funds, an FoF helps to allocate between
funds and thereby reduce risks and make the best of fund manager
styles and asset classes. Another advantage is that you can save
on loads. Entry or exit loads are charged whenever you invest
in any fund, so if you choose three-four funds, you pay entry
load that many times. On the other hand, entry load in a fund
of fund is charged only once as most FoFs have a special service
licence agreement (SLA) with fund houses where they invest. Among
the early criticisms against an FoF were such double loads, but
that's not a worry any more.
There's also the advantage of tracking at
one place. Different funds need extensive tracking, each separately
and that could get tedious. But here a single-window tracking
should help you keep tab of your returns in one go. "In fact,
people also tend to like such product because they want this one-stop
shopping," says Jajoo. "Fund manager selection is also
vital as performance of a mutual fund depends on it. If you select
a good portfolio manager, you may be able to achieve higher returns."
An FoF chooses a portfolio manager for you through a better understanding
of the market and allocating to the right funds.
|
"Careful management
is necessary for FoF to prevent holding overlapping securities"
Amar Pandit
Financial Advisor Myfinad |
For passive investors
For now, however, the tax advantages in a
fund of fund aren't available like any other equity fund. Says
Sandesh Kirkire, CEO, Kotak Mahindra AMC, "While FoF helps
diversify, the tax structure isn't favourable." The Kotak
FoF invests in equity funds which have tax breaks, but the FoF
that invests in them is considered a debt product and hence it
attracts tax at 10 per cent for long-term capital gains and at
the normal slab rates for capital gains.
Besides, diversity may not really be achieved
if the underlying investments are similar. Says Amar Pandit, Financial
Advisor, Myfinad, "Careful management is necessary for FoF
to prevent investment in overlapping securities. If there's an
overlap, performance will get hurt." Besides, an investor
will pay a management fee twice. "The extra cost on account
of management fees charged by the FoF does not make for a good
investment," says Pandit. Over the longer term, till such
time FoFs establish a track record, it will be tough to gauge
them. Overall, the category has performed alongside the market
(see Well Balanced).
But for the uninitiated into mutual funds,
where choosing different funds and understanding allocations is
unpleasant, fund of funds may be the answer. Even passive investors
should find an FoF a welcome attraction. Needless to say, it took
care of Navin Singh's asset allocation like a breeze.
Outward Bound,
Ahoy!
Fancy
that Google stock or an apartment overlooking the Thames? No sweat.
Now you can buy both, thanks to RBI's new rules.
By Anand Adhikari
|
"As Indian market grows and wealth
increases, people definitely want to start investing outside"
Ajay Srinivasan
Prudential Corporation Asia |
Long
ago, investors could hold only Indian assets, in Indian rupees.
Buy a holiday house in Goa or hold equity in Indian companies
or own mutual fund units. Today's investors, however, can aspire
for global assets in various currencies. They can buy shares of
Google or Microsoft in dollars, or own Arcelor Mittal in euros.
For close to three years now, the Reserve Bank of India (RBI)
has allowed resident Indians to invest abroad and acquire foreign
currency assets.
Now, however, the RBI has enhanced the limits
and added to the smiles of Indian investors. Central bank governor
Y.V. Reddy recently increased the overall remittances limit from
$25,000 to $50,000 (Rs 11.25 lakh to Rs 22.5 lakh), and expanded
the scope to include direct investment in overseas equity, mutual
fund schemes, real estate and all other capital transactions.
Overseas fund managers are delighted. For
Asian fund manager Ajay Srinivasan, Chief Executive of $400-billion
(Rs 18 lakh crore) Prudential Corporation Asia, this spells opportunity.
"It's the right way to go. As Indian market grows and wealth
increases, people definitely want to start investing outside,"
he says. Now, Templeton, Alliance, Fidelity, Schroders, AIG, Jardine,
Aberdeen too are said to be eyeing the Indian investor's wallet.
|
"There is going to be more and better
investment opportunities in India than overseas"
John Band
Cortex Advisory |
Options Galore
Theoretically, investment across the international
spectrum will result in diversification, reduction in the level
of various risks and a possible increase in the overall returns
in the long run. "It offers a good diversification strategy
in the sense that investors can take exposure in sophisticated
products abroad," says S. Swaminathan, National Head (Mutual
Fund), IDBI Capital Markets Services.
But there's a whole lot of risks too. "You
have to factor in the currency risk. If rupee appreciates, as
it did in the last couple of years, investors will lose out,"
observes Moses Harding, Executive Vice-President, IndusInd Bank.
For example, if you invested $10,000 in, say, an apartment at
Rs 46 per dollar, the outflows would tot up to Rs 4.6 lakh. If
the rupee appreciates to say Rs 44, when you remit the same $10,000
(assuming the same price), you would get only Rs 4.4 lakh in India.
Besides, investors are faced with other kinds
of risks such as transparency and earnings growth. Swaminathan
has a word of caution: "International markets are also vulnerable
to earnings, inflation, interest rates, political factors, and
currency risk."
But for those who are up to the challenge,
especially the growing tribe of HNI investors, there are some
opportunities available-a variety of sophisticated and specialised
mutual funds. Feeder funds are also expected to make their way
providing another investment avenue. Returns of some foreign funds
are phenomenal-up to 74 per cent (see Mutual Funds: The Top Funds).
Assets On the Other Side
Weigh the opportunities and risks
before investing overseas. |
OPPORTUNITY
Overseas investments: Remittances scheme enhanced for resident
individuals from $25,000 to $50,000 (Rs 11.25 lakh to Rs 22.5
lakh) per annum.
RISK
Currency risk: There's currency risk to watch for. If rupee
appreciates you will lose money, all other things remaining
equal. And vice versa.
Asset risk: As in any form of investing, the overseas assets
you hold could tumble in value.
ADVANTAGE
Rupee diversification: For domestic investors, provides
currency (dollar, euro or pound sterling) hedge if anything
could go wrong with the Indian currency.
DISADVANTAGE
Transaction costs: The cost of transacting in global
markets is high; brokerage and other maintenance charges
higher.
|
Apart from mutual funds, yet another product
available is the global fixed deposit in strong currencies such
as us dollar ($), euro (m) and pound sterling (£). In the
past, Citibank was the only bank in the country marketing these
global fixed deposits. The RBI guidelines initially allowed only
the fixed deposit option to domestic investors in view of fear
of safety and security. But the deposits were not very attractive
earlier because the US Fed rate was historically low at 1 per
cent, though the rate now looks attractive at 5.25 per cent.
Today, Citibank offers 4.87 per cent interest
rates for a six-month deposit in dollars. If you have a slightly
longer term time horizon, you can earn 5.90 per cent in a Canadian
deposit for one year. Pound sterling deposit of over a year offers
7.14 per cent, which is the highest. "Interest rates abroad
are not very attractive for domestic investors. If one really
has a very pessimistic view of the Indian economy, then the diversification
into global markets makes sense," says a banker who did not
want to be named.
|
"You have a bigger and probably better
universe of companies to choose from"
Andrew Holland
Executive Vice President, DSP Merrill Lynch |
As far as stocks were concerned, the RBI earlier
allowed investment in multinational companies with Indian subsidiaries.
Here again, though, the investor needed to have an appetite for
risk and an urge to get a piece of global companies. But now stocks
of Google and Microsoft can be easily purchased so long as they
come under the overall ceiling of $50,000 (Rs 22.5 lakh) per annum.
As you can imagine, the universe of stocks across the globe is
huge. "You have a bigger and probably better universe of
companies to choose from," says Andrew Holland, Executive
VP at DSP Merrill Lynch.
Not So Soon
For now, with the Indian stock markets doing
well, most investors prefer to own assets they know and understand.
John Band of Cortex Advisory reacts by saying it doesn't make
any sense to invest abroad. "Indian economy is growing faster
than many other economies in the world. There is going to be more
and better investment opportunities here than overseas,"
says Band. Harding, too, pitches in by saying, "when return
on investment is much higher in the domestic market, why should
one invest abroad and also take a currency risk?"
Valid point. In a bullish market or buoyant
economy, people don't necessarily think of reducing risk and investing
abroad. But sooner or later, the opportunity to diversify assets
will be felt, especially as other foreign markets turn attractive.
Says Srinivasan: "I think the time will come when people
will want to diversify and look for opportunities abroad."
Indeed.
High
Sugar, No Problem
The new diabetes care policy fills a gap.
Tip: Watch the premium.
By Shivani Lath
|
Are you a diabetic? Now, worry less |
If
you are one of those one in eight people who can't stomach the
sugar, and are paying huge drug bills and doing the rounds of
laboratories testing blood and collecting reports, there's welcome
news.
ICICI Prudential Life Insurance has launched
a new diabetes insurance policy which covers diabetics. But like
most other health insurance products, this does not reimburse
the traditional way after submission of bills, but pays the sum
assured at the time of detection of any diseases that strike as
a result of the diabetic condition. The idea behind the product,
says N.S. Kannan, Executive Director, ICICI Prudential Life Insurance,
is that "diabetics are expected to pay three times the premium
in a life insurance scheme simply because they suffer from an
ailment that is pre-existing."
The diabetes care policy is designed to cover
not just the type 2 diabetics but also the high sugar (pre-diabetes)
patients in order to incentivise them to control the condition.
The package, therefore, provides not just a reimbursement but
an incentive scheme which provides the patients three free medical
examinations a year at any of the Wellspring or Metropolitan laboratories,
which the company has tied up with. "To increase the economic
incentive, these laboratories will also collect the blood samples
from the patients' homes for no charge," says Kannan.
The scheme works such that if a person shows
that he has been able to control the condition (on various parameters
determined by the doctors), he gets a 30 per cent discount on
the premium of the next year, depending on the age and extent
of control (see Diabetes Care).
|
"Only about 35 per cent of the sum
assured is actually used for medical expenses"
N.S. Kannan
Executive Director, ICICI Prudential Life Insurance |
The sum assured, which could be Rs 3 lakh,
Rs 5 lakh or Rs 10 lakh, is paid out the moment a patient is detected
with any of the six ailments-heart diseases, bypass, stroke, kidney
failure, major organ transplant or cancer. The scheme also includes
a 10 per cent rider, of the sum assured, to cover two complications
that arise out of diabetes-eye defects that may need laser treatment
or limb dysfunction that require amputation.
ICICI Prudential has also tied up with Wockhardt,
Nicholas Piramal, Biocon and Johnson & Johnson to provide
policyholders as much as a 25 per cent discount on oral drugs,
insulin strips and glucometers. "We have also tied up with
75 gyms across the country which will give discount memberships
to the policyholders," adds Kannan. The policy is available
for a term of five years for people between the ages of 25 and
60, who already suffer from adult diabetes or impaired glucose
tolerance (commonly known as high blood sugar).
The company also has a 10-year and 20-year
general health plan called Health Assure to cover critical illness
for normal people between the ages of 18 and 55, with the maximum
age at maturity being 65. The minimum sum assured is Rs 1.5 lakh
and the maximum is Rs 10 lakh.
In April this year, it launched a 10-year
cancer care policy for people between 20 and 55 years, with a
minimum coverage of Rs 5 lakh. The idea is to enable patients
to get the money when they are detected with the disease, rather
than on submission of bills. "We've found that only 35 per
cent of the sum assured is used for medical expenses, while the
rest is used by the family to meet related expenses such as travel,"
says Kannan. Meanwhile, let's hope the diabetes care policy actually
encourages people to stay healthy.
Really
Burns A Hole
Credit card debt is expensive. Pay up in
full.
By Clifford Alvares
If
you are using your credit card like it is ready cash, then you
are headed for trouble. Just ask Sangeeta Nachnani. Generally
choosy about spending big, Sangeeta bought clothes and jewellery
worth Rs 65,000 last year for her wedding and charged it to her
credit card. One year down the line, she is still paying off her
dues. Worse, after shelling out more than Rs 20,000 in interest
charges over the year, Sangeeta's dues have barely nudged down
and she continues to owe a hefty Rs 52,000 on her card. Her total
bill so far: Rs 85,000.
But her bill might rise further. Sangeeta
has been using the revolving facility on her credit card, which
allows her to pay a minimum of 5 per cent of outstanding dues.
Revolving allows card holders to roll over part of the bill to
the next month with a low repayment of 5 per cent, thus totting
up huge interests costs, besides adding to the outstanding tenure.
Perhaps this is a familiar lament of most
card holders. That three-by -two-inch plastic in your wallet might
appear as the most innocuous thing to use when you are out shopping.
True, it's a handy tool if you know how to use it. But if you
don't, credit cards can make you lose financial control, and in
the bargain even cost you a bomb.
That's because the interest rate on the plastic
card is a high 2.95 per cent per month, which might not seem like
too much at first glance. But on a compounded annual basis, the
usual way in which banks quote interest rate on loan products,
the interest rate works out to a whopping 42 per cent per annum-more
than four times a typical home loan interest rate or about twice
that of a personal loan.
Besides, paying only the bare minimum of
5 per cent to keep your credit card going, could take years before
you repay all your outstandings. A bill worth Rs 65,000 can take
as long as 28 years to repay, at the minimum rollover levels of
5 per cent. Instead, the credit card balance that should be paid
off in full gets stretched for years.
That's not all. It's not just the interest
charges on the credit outstanding that you are paying. Cardholders
have to pay an additional service tax of 12.24 per cent (including
surcharge and cess), on the monthly interest costs. By adding
that to the interest cost of 2.95 per cent, the actual rate shoots
up to a high of 3.3 per cent per month, or, on a compounded basis,
close to a whopping 48 per cent annum.
Of late, Sangeeta has upped her repayments
from the minimum of 5 per cent to a fixed sum of Rs 15,000 every
month and hopes to cut down to zero debt in about five months.
To top it, she decided to use the free credit period of 45 days
to the hilt, and pay up all new credit card charges in full. She's
learnt the hard way, but she has learnt just the same.
|