These are the best of times for
the fund management business. Inflows are steady and performance
has been relatively easy, particularly because of the soaring
stock markets. On a three-year basis, 48 out of 89 funds have
managed to beat the S&P CNX nifty in performance. Yet, if
you take a closer look, you will find that not many have been
able to beat the market on a yearly basis.
Consistent performers managed to beat the market's benchmark
(in this case nifty) on a sustained basis. Of the total 48 equity
funds (excluding index funds) that have been in existence for
the past five years in the market, only six have done well on
a sustained basis: SBI Magnum Sector Umbrella-Infotech Fund, Birla
Sun Life New Millennium Fund, Franklin India Prima Plus, SBI Magnum
Global Fund 94, Franklin India Opportunity Fund and HDFC Equity
Fund. They reported returns from 166.5 per cent to 286 per cent
compared to 116 per cent of nifty in the last three years.
So, what makes these funds different from others? Says Prashant
Jain, Chief Investment Officer (CIO), HDFC Mutual Fund: "The
key for outperforming is not in targeting high returns with high
risk each year, rather in avoiding big mistakes in every single
year." Despite the varied investment styles and objectives-from
a sectoral fund to a thematic fund-there's much in common in the
management of these funds. Their fund managers don't hesitate
to move out of stocks that are lagging behind and yet follow a
stock-specific approach that is based on fundamentals. Says A.
Balasubramanian, CIO, Birla Sun Life Mutual Fund: "Flexible
approach is the best for achieving consistent returns."
It's difficult to repeat a good performance every year. It requires
many things, apart from a keen eye on the stocks of the future.
Says Hemant Rustagi, Chief Executive Officer (CEO), Wiseinvest:
"These are good funds and you have to grant it to the fund
manager for his efforts to maintain consistency."
The Big Guns
The SBI Magnum Sector Umbrella-Infotech Fund
has been the biggest gainer in the last three years, recording
a massive 286 per cent return. The fund's mandate has been to
provide maximum growth opportunity by investing in it stocks.
At this point, the fund has shored up cash which is about 26 per
cent of its portfolio, but 68 per cent of it is currently invested
in it stocks, and the rest in top-class telecom, pharmaceutical
and electronic companies. Sanjay Sinha, the fund manager, has
predominately invested in mid-cap it stocks. Of the total 17 stocks
in portfolio, 13 are from the mid-cap space with Infotech Enterprises
being the largest holding with 13.1 per cent in the portfolio.
"Picking stocks in IPOs has helped us deliver superior returns,"
says Sinha, CIO, SBI Mutual Fund. He feels his confidence in newly-listed
it companies has delivered results.
|
|
"Picking stocks in IPOs
that have doubled since listing has also helped us to deliver
superior returns"
Sanjay Sinha
Fund Manager/ SBI Magnum Sector Umbrella-Infotech Fund
|
"Flexible approach has
been crucial for achieving consistent returns. Our proactive
approach in handling stocks and investment more towards mid-cap
has helped in outperforming the benchmark"
A. Balasubramanian
CIO/ Birla Sun Life Mutual Fund |
Sinha has, however, followed a different approach
in SBI Magnum Global Fund 94. Primarily a mid-cap fund, it is
quite diverse with 64 stocks in its portfolio as on April 30,
2007, but no stock accounts for more than 4 per cent of the total
corpus of the fund. "Superior stock selection and complete
bottom-up approach has worked in our favour," says Sinha.
His approach: stay in cash if you don't see value in the market.
In Global Fund 94, he is sitting on cash, money market instruments
and debt worth Rs 500 crore (33 per cent). For the past three
years, the fund has recorded 285 per cent returns.
Similarly, HDFC Equity Fund has a 10-year
track record of consistency; across market capitalisations, its
concentration has been predominantly in the top 3 companies and
in large caps. "Stronger companies reduce risk in bad times.
Our preference has been for strong and well-managed companies
across capitalisation," says Jain, its manager. His fund
maintains a focussed portfolio with the target to generate higher
alpha. The fund has reduced the peak exposure of individual large
cap stocks to 6 per cent from the earlier 9 per cent
But not all funds have banked on this approach.
Another strong performer has been a fund that has not hesitated
to take large exposures in select growth stocks and sectors. "Compared
to other equity funds, our fund takes more concentrated positions,"
says K.N. Siva Subramanian, who manages the Rs 855-crore Franklin
India Opportunity Fund. "It will continue to follow a bottom-up
approach to stock selection, in keeping with the overall investment
philosophy". The top four stocks in the portfolio-India Cements,
HLL, sail and Bharat Electronics-account for over 30 per cent
of its portfolio. Yet, despite its relative concentration, the
fund manager has been able to beat the benchmark nifty for the
past five years: The fund has generated a 370 per cent return
compared to Nifty's 238 per cent.
|
"Our research focusses
not only on the track record of the company, but also on its
future strategy and its ability to continue to generate wealth
on a sustained basis"
R. Sukumar
Fund Manager/ Franklin India Prima Plus |
Franklin Templeton Prima Plus has also maintained
a consistent performance, but with a different style of investment.
Managed by R. Sukumar, the fund's strategy is to scout only for
fundamentals and valuations. Prima Plus invests in wealth-creating
companies whose competitive advantage will translate into superior
return on capital. "Our research focusses not only on the
track record of the company, but also on its future strategy and
its ability to continue to generate wealth on a sustained basis
in a competitive business environment. This strategy has helped
the fund in providing superior risk-adjusted returns over the
last 12 years through various market cycles and short-term volatility
in the markets will not have an impact on this approach."
In the past five years, the fund has recorded a whopping 458 per
cent return compared with the 238 per cent rise of nifty.
|
"We have focussed on
stocks/sectors with higher growth potential. This fund will
continue to follow a bottom-up approach to stock selection,
in keeping with the overall investment philosophy"
K.N. Siva Subramanian
Fund Manager/Franklin India Opportunity Fund |
Apart from housing & construction and
capital goods sectors, computer and telecom sectors have been
largely responsible for the impressive performance of these funds.
In fact, the Birla Sun Life New Millennium fund, which invests
mainly in the TMT sector, was able to deliver better returns than
its peers due to its flexibility of investing in banking, printing
and stationery sectors. "Our proactive approach in handling
stocks and investment more towards mid-cap has helped in outperforming
the benchmark," says Balasubramanian of Birla Sun Life.
Consistency Pays
Of course, past performance does not guarantee
future returns. But sticking to those fund managers who have a
finger on the pulse of the market always reflects on the performance.
Says Rustagi of Wiseinvest: "Consistent performance and long-term
track record are crucial for a fund." Investors must have
a good chunk of their investments in these funds, but yet at the
same time diversify and look out for new themes emerging in the
market like the infrastructure play. But one must not junk some
of their existing funds because of one bad year. "There are
funds that may have one bad year, but overall may be good funds,"
says Rustagi. Look for funds that have a track record of good
performance and have the flexibility to approach different markets
and business cycles. There's a fairly good chance your portfolio
will reflect their performance.
The Rise Of Money
Managers
Are you planning to outsource your
portfolio to professional managers? Here's what you should know.
By Nitya Varadarajan
|
|
"A PMS manager can invest
a smaller corpus either on a high risk theme or a low risk
theme"
Nitin Jain
Head (PMS)/ Religare Securities |
"Many companies talk
of big asset bases. PMS should be of a manageable size to
benefit all"
Shashank Khade
Senior VP/ Kotak Securities |
Lately,
a large number of brokers are getting into portfolio management-essentially
tailoring your portfolio to your requirements and managing the
same for a fee. The business is huge and growing as the number
of high net-worth individuals rises as well. But there's a reason
why you could consider portfolio managers: This business has come
of age.
Many portfolio managers have been around
for a couple of years. Says Shashank Khade, Senior VP, Kotak Securities:
"We have been through the learning curve and have seen it
all." From your perspective, that essentially means a better
handle on managing your stocks.
The Service
Portfolio managers are usually from companies
that deal with equities. Stockbrokers find portfolio management
services (PMS) a way of augmenting revenues, so do fund houses
and boutique investment bankers. The services on offer are both
discretionary and non-discretionary, depending on your requirement.
A discretionary service is where the broker or fund house takes
all the decisions of investing, i.e., buying and selling shares
on your behalf, leaving you hassle-free.
There are concept schemes or products that
target specific ideas or themes in the market. Like in the case
of mutual funds, you can opt for a product depending on your taste
and risk appetite. However, instead of a bunch of units, your
holding is in stocks of companies against your name. You can start
by a minimum of Rs 10 lakh, but this varies between schemes and
brokers.
The Management Mantra
What you should know about portfolio
services. |
»
Unless it is a high risk fund (with market triggers
on volatility), the longer you stay, the better
»
Check out on the services provided, and the fee. Transparency
and retail interfacing are important. So is the SEBI registration
in case you have a grievance
»
Portfolios can be tailored according to your preference or
choice
»
The more experienced your PMS provider, the better. He will
understand the ups and downs of the market. Nevertheless,
monitor your portfolio regularly and keep up with related
news and prospects
»
If you realise that direct investments in stock markets or
mutual funds could deliver the same or more, you can go it
alone. There are good online brokers, if you want to buy stocks,
where you can get suggestions and buy calls |
The Costs
Usually, the fees are fixed or variable or
a combination of both, depending on the scheme or your manager.
A fixed fee is charged on the corpus, much like a mutual fund.
A variable fee, on the other hand, is charged on the profits that
the portfolio has generated. For example, Religare Securities
charges a fixed fee of 2 per cent per annum and the performance-based
variable fee ranges from 10-20 per cent on profits with a hurdle
rate of 12 per cent return on portfolio (up to this nothing is
charged). In another scheme, it charges only on "out performance,"
which is scheme returns minus benchmark returns.
But there's a flipside to the charges. The
losses have to be entirely borne by you. "Remember that it
is only the profits that get shared, not the losses," says
Gaurav Mashruwala, CEO, ace Group, and a certified financial planner.
A Choice of Styles
There's a lot to choose from
the different schemes on offer. |
Kotak Securities
Origin
DESCRIPTION: Small- and mid-cap portfolio with focus on
future stars
ANNUAL RATES: The fixed and variable components do
not exceed 4 per cent of portfolio totally and levied
MINIMUM INVESTMENT: Not specified, though average collections
range Rs 25 lakh per person
Religare Securities
Panther
DESCRIPTION: Aims to achieve higher returns by taking
aggressive positions across sectors and market caps
ANNUAL RATES: 2 per cent fixed and performance-based
variable from 10-20 per cent with a hurdle rate of 12 per
cent return levied
MINIMUM INVESTMENT: Rs 25 lakh
Motilal Oswal
Value PMS
DESCRIPTION: A low churn portfolio that aims to buy
undervalued stocks and sell overvalued ones with a capital
preservation consciousness but not guarantee
ANNUAL RATES: Not given
MINIMUM INVESTMENT: Rs 50 lakh
Parag Parikh Financial Advisory Services
Cognito
DESCRIPTION: Equity stocks; conservative outlook with
steady returns and no cyclicals
ANNUAL RATES: 2 per cent flat or 1 per cent and 10
per cent of profits
MINIMUM INVESTMENT: Rs 5 lakh
Franklin Templeton Mutual Funds
FT Select
DESCRIPTION: Large-cap stocks benchmarked against BSE
Sensex with good liquidity and with hedged strategy
ANNUAL RATES: Fixed is 2.5 per cent of the daily
average of net assets excluding brokerage; Variable is 1.5
per cent of daily average of net assets of the account excluding
brokerage plus profit sharing of 20 per cent with a hurdle
rate of 12 per cent per annum
MINIMUM INVESTMENT: Rs 50 lakh (cash) or Rs 1 crore
(for portfolio)
HSBC Mutual Funds
Signature
DESCRIPTION: Stocks with a long-term growth potential
available at a discount to intrinsic value; maximum stock
exposure is 10 per cent and maximum sector exposure is 25
per cent
ANNUAL RATES: Three options, i.e., Upfront (1.75
per cent with 0.5 per cent per annum of daily average of
net assets); 2.5 per cent per annum charged monthly of daily
average of net assets;or fixed 1.25 per cent per annum charged
monthly of daily average of net assets and 15 per cent of
profits with a hurdle rate of 10 per cent
MINIMUM INVESTMENT: Rs 50 lakh
Product samples available with brokers
and fund houses
|
The Advantage
The nature of a PMS product is different from,
say, a mutual fund. Says Nitin Jain, Head (PMS), Religare Securities:
"Cash management is better here, which translates to better
returns than a mutual fund, which operates under a restricted
framework." For example, a PMS can sell out all stocks against
your name if you so desire, which a mutual fund can't do. Likewise,
unlike a mutual fund, a PMS operates on a narrower portfolio of
stocks due to its smaller corpus. "A PMS manager can invest
a smaller corpus either on a high-risk theme or a low- risk theme,"
avers Jain.
Usually, there's no load. But Khade believes
in trying to encourage investors to stay in for the long term
to get good results. "We sometimes charge an exit load to
discourage investors from selling out," he says. Besides,
keeping the corpus at a manageable level can give better results
to investors. "Many companies talk of big asset bases,"
says Khade. "PMS should be of a manageable size to benefit
all."
There are tailored products and also those
that tap a particular segment of the market, including derivatives.
"We do invest in derivatives for hedging and in money market
funds for cash management," says Jain.
But if you invest, check the costs and the
product you select. Mashruwala feels that since portfolio managers
charge a hefty fee, opting for a differentiator is important,
which usually is in the non-discretionary portfolio-you must have
a tidy Rs 1 crore for investing here.
Remember to compare the performance with
the market's benchmark Sensex. If your portfolio has outperformed,
then your outsourced fund manager has been worth it.
To Prepay Or Not?
It's the million-dollar question. Here's
how and when to prepay your home loan.
By Clifford Alvares
It's
a tricky situation for homeowners with a loan. With the rising
interest rates-which are at a five-year high-the big question
they face is: Should I prepay the home loan? A swift round of
four rate hikes since October 2006 has jacked home loan rates
up by a whopping 25 per cent. And if you are among the many who
have taken a home loan very recently, you've probably faced a
financial double blow: The impact of rising interest rates and
skyrocketing real estate prices.
For most individuals who bought houses when
rates were the lowest at around 7.25 per cent in December 2003,
the impact of the rising interest rate is huge. Of course, part
of it has been compensated by the surge in property prices that
increases your home equity. But on your home finances, the result
is excruciating. Consider this: your EMI (equated monthly installment),
taken at 7.25 per cent, increases by a whopping 32.8 per cent.
On a larger Rs 50 lakh loan, the EMI increases by a tidy Rs 12,950-that's
a big increase.
Banks have been sending out letters to older
borrowers to prepay a part of their loans or re-balance their
monthly installments to reflect the current rise in rates. Says
Rajiv Sabharwal, Head (Retail Assets), ICICI Bank: "We wrote
to customers to prepay a certain amount and there has been an
increase in prepayments"
When and Why
But when do you prepay a loan? There are
a few factors that could affect your decision. First, if your
interest rate has been very low, say 7.5 per cent, and the current
rate is around 11 per cent, your whole EMI is not enough to cover
the current interest cost. Banks re-adjust your monthly installments
to reflect current levels, and also encourage you to prepay a
part of the loan.
|
|
"We have seen an increase
in prepayments and many people are coming forward"
Rajiv Sabharwal
Head (Retail Assets)/ICICI Bank |
"If your money is earning
you a rate lower than your effective post-tax rate, go for
prepayment"
Amar Pandit
Certified Financial Planner |
Ideally, a prepayment strategy should be based
on three factors: Affordability, opportunity cost and the tenure
of your loan. Says Amar Pandit, a Certified Financial Planner
(CFP): "You have to consider a combination of factors, like
when was the loan taken, and your effective interest rate and
the amount of surplus funds you have." The first is not a
major hindrance as there has been an increase in annual incomes
of most individuals.
But for many others, it's, perhaps, a good
idea to consider the opportunity cost of prepaying your home loan.
In economics, there's something called the opportunity cost. A
home loan costs around 11 per cent today, which is your cost.
But if you can earn more elsewhere, then prepayment, in the short-end,
is not for you. It's only when you have idle long-term money and
it's earning you lower than what you pay, can you go for a prepayment
as it will help wind up that loan earlier. Adds Pandit: "If
you have money and it's earning you a rate lower than your effective
post-tax rate, then you can go for prepayment."
For others, especially those who have been
affected by the tenures, a prepayment makes sense, too. If you
have taken a loan that is about two years old, your tenures can
nearly double with the recent spate of rate hikes. So a 20-year
loan can turn into a 40-year loan, even more, depending on your
contracted rate. It's here that you can take a decision to make
a part prepayment. Ideally, your home loan tenure should not extend
beyond your working lifetime or about 22-25 years, beyond which
the total cost of the house becomes expensive. You can decide
the amount of prepayment. Says Sabharwal: "The homeowners
can decide what is best. But we have seen that when the rates
are low, a customer prefers to increase tenure. If the rates go
higher, he prefers an increase in prepayments." But if your
tenures go up beyond your retirement age, says Pandit, it makes
economic sense to go for a partial prepayment.
NEWS
ROUND-UP
Trade Your Policy?
There's still enough value in a lapsed policy.
|
Aggarwal: Calls for trading in life
policies that are likely to lapse |
It may come as surprise to many-life
insurance policies can be traded. This is seen as a solution to
the many policies that would otherwise lapse. These policies affect
the insured (gets lower surrender value), the agent (who loses
his commission) and the insurer (overheads increase).
When a policy lapses, trading in life insurance is a way out.
Says Rahul Aggarwal, CEO of Optima Risk Management Services: "Trading
in life policies that are likely to lapse is a good way out and
it is practised in many countries. It makes immense sense for
a portfolio builder, though it has its downside for the original
policyholder."
The life cover trade
|
»
Pure life term policies don't get traded-only
endowment policies
»
Look at the cyclicality of interest rates before buying such
policies
»
If you have missed out on buying a policy earlier, make up
for lost time now. Such policies have a shorter maturity period
without compromising on returns |
But if you are the original policyholder, then you might not
gain much. Although you could get more money than the surrender
value of the policy, there's a downside-the loss of life cover.
In the event something happens to the original buyer, the acquirer
of the policy becomes the beneficiary-and not the family members.
Brokers accumulate such life policies due to the maturity bonuses-the
rate of return, depending on policy issue period, could work out
to as much as 9 per cent. For individuals, perhaps, it's best
to renew life policies and not let it lapse, but for investors
and brokers, it makes for a good investment. For others, you can
buy such lapsed policies to make up for the lost time.
- Nitya Varadarjan
Know Your Diamond
Here's a quick guide on how to buy that sparkling
stone.
If you don't know anybody in the
diamond business, you could very well get taken in the diamond
buying process. But don't worry, here is enough information about
diamonds to save you from the agonising, cold-sweat, high-pressure
jewellery store experience. Just read these five tips before you
go shopping, and you'll know what you're buying.
A diamond's beauty, rarity and price depend on the interplay
of all the 4Cs: Cut, its (the diamond's) angular proportions;
Carat, its weight; Clarity, to the presence of inclusions, and
Colour, the degree to which it's colourless. So look for these
precisely.
A lot of jewellers use terms like "deluxe" and "super-deluxe"
to classify diamonds; more often than not this is a sure-shot
way to dupe the customer. In order to ensure the quality of your
diamond, buy it from one of the many companies offering branded
diamonds as they are certified. Ask to see original certificates
and not photocopies.
Ask to inspect diamonds under a 30X microscope. The so-called
"loup", which is a handheld magnifier, is only of 10X
magnification. Reputed jewellers should have a 30 power microscope.
You must shop around in more than one store as different stores
specialise in different shapes, sizes and qualities. You must
find a retailer that caters to your needs.
Last but not the least, ask the retailer/jeweller about the
origin of the diamonds. Ask for the diamond company's policy on
conflict diamonds, as well as a written guarantee from the diamond
supplier that proves the diamonds are conflict free.
Happy shopping for your sparkle!
-Deepti Khanna Bose and Anusha Subramanian
Attractively Small
Fund houses are targeting the small- and
mid-cap space. Should you invest?
|
Naganath: Sees tremendous opportunity
in micro-cap funds |
It's now the turn of small- and
mid-cap stocks. With the valuations stretched in the larger cap
segments, fund houses are now training their sight on the small-
and mid-cap segments. Last fortnight, two fund houses-HDFC and
DSP Merrill Lynch-launched the HDFC Mid-cap Opportunities Fund
and DSP Merrill Lynch Micro-cap Fund, respectively.
And the reason is not too far to seek: in the last one year,
small- and mid-cap segments have not moved in tandem with their
larger counterparts. And besides, most fund houses have open-end
funds that are invested in the larger cap companies. Says S. Naganath,
President & Chief Investment Officer, DSPML AMC: "We
launched the micro-cap fund to complete our bouquet of offering
to customers. Secondly, we see tremendous opportunity in some
of these micro-caps growing to become a sizable company in the
next few years."
The micro-cap fund is a three-year closed-end equity scheme,
which will adopt the style of a private equity player and invest
in stocks with a market capitalisation of less than Rs 1,500 crore.
The fund targets a Rs 500-crore corpus, but will convert into
an open-ended scheme after the lock-in period of three years.
HDFC Mid-cap Opportunities Fund, another three-year close-ended
fund, will invest around 5-15 per cent in small- and the rest
in mid-cap stocks.
Interestingly, since the beginning of this year, this segment
has livened up. Nine out of 25 new equity funds launched this
year target the small- and mid-cap stocks. The market senses tremendous
opportunity in this segment as some of these companies can scale
up, expand their businesses, thereby increasing shareholder wealth.
But there's a catch: not all small companies are cut out for the
big league.
-Mahesh Nayak
|