A
company that claims it will boast a subscriber base of 120 million
by 2010 is best taken seriously. Or laughed at. It's hard to laugh
at Rs 90,000 crore of fixed assets and Rs 23,500 crore in revenue.
Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited (BSNL), the corporatised-it turned one
in October 2000-operating arm of the government's Department of Telecommunications
(DOT) is the company making that claim.
This year, BSNL will invest Rs 14,076 crore
towards that objective. Last year it did Rs 16,571 crore. And between
the current financial year and 2006-07, it will invest a total of
Rs 66,500 crore. Phew!
The company's new Chairman and Managing Director
Prithipal Singh, an Indian Telecom Service lifer who considers his
present post the pinnacle of his achievements, may look avuncular,
and speak ever so softly, but the substance of BSNL's ambitions
are such that they should send a cold shiver down the spines of
its competitors.
By 2005, BSNL's cellular service (based on
the popular Groupe Speciale Mobile technology) will cover 1,021
cities and reach out to 15 million subscribers, half the estimated
GSM market according to the company and just around a third according
to BT's own calculations.
This year, its target for connections is 2.4
million GSM, a million CDMA (Code Division Multiple Access, a rival
mobile technology, and its Wireless-in-Local-Loop platform is being
used by basic telephony companies to provide `limited' mobile services),
and 3 million fixed lines.
BSNL HAS AMBITIOUS PLANS BUT COMPETITION
WILL BE INTENSE
Fixed line
BSNL: With 34 million lines, it is focusing on incremental
growth and teledensity, not business. Seeking hike in local
call charges.
COMPETITION: Cherry-picking high-value customers. Except
Bharti, companies are focusing on limited mobility, which
comes free with the new licences.
MARKET SIZE: Rs 27,000 crore
Mobile
BSNL: Setting up two networks-GSM and CDMA-to provide
similar services. Envisages 15 million GSM subscribers-50
per cent of the market-by 2005; its licence has been gathering
dust since 1999.
COMPETITION: Private players focusing on one network
only. Everyone except Reliance is kicking off fresh operations,
rationalising tariffs and strengthening brands.
MARKET SIZE: Rs 7,500-8,000 crore
Domestic
Long Distance
BSNL: Responded aggressively to IndiaOne's 50 per cent
lower tariffs by reducing its own rates by 62 per cent. Flexing
its incumbent muscle to stall IndiaOne wherever possible.
COMPETITION: The current tariff war is over. The game
will move to a new turf once Reliance and VSNL join the fray.
MARKET SIZE: Rs 8,000 crore
International
Long Distance
BSNL: Its ability to originate and terminate calls
will help since it will not have to share revenues. Investments
will be low. Has applied for a licence.
COMPETITION: VSNL is grappling with the loss of its
monopoly. IndiaOne is up and running. A clutch of ISPs are
getting in. Global carriers have overcapacity. Easy to drive
a hard bargain.
MARKET SIZE: Rs 7,100 crore
Internet
BSNL: Under the Sancharnet brand, the five-year old
service has 250,000 connections. Projected to double in six-to-eight
months. Sancharnet will also spearhead the foray into internet
telephony.
COMPETITION: VSNL and Satyam Infoway are well-entrenched.
As are HCL Infinet and NOW. But no one is raking in the moolah.
Internet telephony has failed to enthuse the ISPs.
MARKET SIZE: Rs 800-900 crore
Broadband
BSNL: 328,000 km of optic fibre cable already in place.
Will go up to 400,000 km this financial year. Will start high-speed
internet services. Also plans to deal in bandwidth.
COMPETITION: The last mile has proved a thorn in their
flesh. All broadband service providers in a shambles. Reliance
is working on a 115-city network that everyone is waiting
for.
MARKET SIZE: Rs 300 crore
Value-added
services
BSNL: Projects underway include intelligent network,
free-phone service, premium rate service, pre-paid calling
cards, virtual private network, universal number, televoting,
and account-calling card.
COMPETITION: It's scattered. But it's there. Anyway,
there isn't a great deal of money to be made.
MARKET SIZE: N.A.
|
The plans don't end there. BSNL has applied
for an international long distance (ILD) licence; it proposes to
become a broadband service provider; and it is even contemplating
internet dhabas (cafes are for the anglicised).
Government companies aren't known for their
aggressiveness-certainly not companies still trying to live down
their past as government departments. It's almost as if, magically,
in the two-kilometre journey that separates BSNL's new office at
New Delhi's central business district Connaught Place from its old
one at Sanchar Bhawan in the heart of Lutyen's Delhi, the company
has acquired some gumption.
It isn't just ambition that lies behind BSNL's
plans. It is the desire to survive. Not too long ago, artificially
high domestic long distance tariffs (Rs 24 a minute for distances
over 1,000 kilometres) used to subsidise relatively low local call
charges of Rs 1.20 (for a three-minute call). Competition changed
that: IndiaOne, the first private company to enter what had until
then remained BSNL's fief, slashed rates by 50 per cent in the Rs
8,000 crore-a-year market; BSNL had to cut rates even further to
Rs 9.50 to stay relevant.
The company has weathered competition largely
by not providing its 34 million subscribers access to IndiaOne's
service-citing a lack of agreement on revenue-sharing for interconnection
and technical difficulties in providing the Carrierr Access Code-but
that will change once the telecom regulator gets its act together.
That, and the imminent entry of Reliance and VSNL into the fray
will erode BSNL's marketshare.
If competitors aren't exactly shaking in their
shoes-they should be-it is because BSNL's plans have remained just
that, plans, for some time. It acquired its GSM licence, for instance,
in 1999. The licence has, however, not yet been operationalised
even as private cellular operators have spread their tentacles to
1,400 cities. Says AT&T India Managing Director Virat Bhatia:
"They need to chase value in cellular, unlock the commercial
potential for providing access and find ways to retain maximum revenue
in the immediate time-frame."
What Ails BSNL?
It can't be the money. With revenues of Rs
23,500 crore and net profits touching Rs 5,000 crore, the company
isn't your everyday cash-strapped telco (See Where's
The Money?). And it has survived the reduction in domestic long
distance tariffs that everyone expected to hurt. "DLD traffic
has risen 30-35 per cent after the cuts and we have managed to bridge
the (revenue) gap," says Singh. "They must have regained
their revenues," adds Ajay Pandey, COO, Tata Teleservices.
"They didn't need to invest in additional capacity to accommodate
rising demand."
It can't be the infrastructure. BSNL has 35,000
telephone exchanges, each one of them digital, 328,000 kilometres
of optic fibre cable (OFC; another 100,000 kilometres is to be lit
this year), and 1,065,000 public telephone booths.
The money and the infrastructure will both
come in handy. In cellular telephony, for instance, the company
is up against some entrenched rivals, such as Bharti, Hutch, and
BPL-Idea. Then, there are the two competitors it will encounter
at every stage of its integrated telecom play, Bharti and Reliance.
It won't be easy for BSNL to play the price
card. Several of its competitors have been in business for a while
and may have recovered some of their fixed costs. And cellular tariffs
are probably as low as can get without seriously affecting a company's
bottomline. Singh's strategy? To leverage existing infrastructure
to lower the cost of rolling out the network and hope quality of
service will do the rest. "We will grab most of the growth
(in the cellular market)," says Singh. "People are not
very satisfied with private mobile operators and are waiting for
our service."
WHERE'S THE MONEY?
The price war in the STD market hasn't meant
much to BSNL's financials. |
January 2002
was the month of doomsayers. Indiaone announced the launch
of its domestic long distance service that would lead to a
50 per cent off their peak rates. BSNL responded with an aggression
rare for a PSU and reduced its rates by 62 per cent. The world
applauded and winced at once. Surely, analysts said, BSNL
won't be able to absorb the quake. Didn't it use the cushion
of high long distance revenues to subsidise low local call
charges? And with TRAI in no hurry to revise local charges,
BSNL would surely go but down, down, down. However, BSNL bounced
back as its predictions of positive elasticity came true with
a 35 per cent rise in volumes. Since it had huge unutilised
capacity, it capitalised on the volume surge without having
to make additional investments. And here it is; armed with
reserves exceeding Rs 30,000 crore and talking of a capital
outlay of over Rs 14,000 crore in the current year in spite
of falling equipment prices. Just for kicks, car market leader
Maruti Udyog's annual earning is only about two-thirds that
figure.
|
A government company mouthing the s-word; doesn't
Singh realise what people think of BSNL's service quality? He does.
Only his reference isn't to the way BSNL's front-line staff deal
with customers; it's got to do with the quality of service. The
erstwhile monopoly's network will provide the widest coverage-and
that's one area where even the best private companies could do with
some improvement. "Its biggest strengths are experience and
size of the network. None of us can replicate that in a short period.
BSNL's network is so huge that it can go all out to offer whatever
products and services it wants to,'' says Pandey. Then, as a sting
in the tail, ''If only they could bring in a bit of innovation and
customer orientation, they could give us all a tough fight."
Volumes, though, won't translate into profits.
Most non-metro mobile operations-BSNL has 18- aren't money-spinners
and the company doesn't have a presence in the two largest fixed
service and cellular markets, Delhi and Mumbai. Shedding some of
its PSU-baggage would help. One analyst believes an evaluation of
customers would help too. "Right now, BSNL doesn't differentiate
between high-value customers and low-value ones."
The company isn't averse to meeting corporate
needs, but its Director (Commercial & Marketing), B.R. Khurana
is scandalised by the suggestion that maybe it is time BSNL created
a hierarchy of customers. "We don't distinguish between customers
on the basis of the amount billed; we don't work for business alone."
Oops.
1 2
3
|