11 March: At a Lehman
Brothers' Annual Global Software and IT Services Conference, Harry
You, CFO at global consulting major Accenture, declares his firm
will fight "toe-to-toe on a cost basis" with Indian technology
vendors.
Mid-March: US research firm American
Technology Research promptly puts out a report saying that Accenture
plans to displace Indian IT service providers from North American
and European corporate accounts. The analyst goes on to describe
the Accenture stock a "better value" than shares of publicly
traded Indian technology services companies.
10 April: Infosys announces its numbers
for the fourth quarter and the year ended March 31, 2003. Margins
are under pressure, and the guidance for the following year is sober.
17 April: Wipro's report card isn't
better; profits are down 6 per cent for the year.
MARGINAL THINKING
IT biggies' margins have come under attack
like never before. |
|
Nandan Nilekani/ Infosys: Infy's
net margins skid to 26.44 per cent from 31.03 per cent
in 2002 |
|
Vivek Paul/Wipro
Wipro's marketing spend was seven times its 2002 figure
at Rs 550.6 crore |
The Indian infotech majors, who
have been living it up with net margins (net profit as a percentage
of sales) of 30 per cent-plus, have now got to start learning
to live with a sobering reality. That such chunky margins are
history, as is amply evident in the report cards of the IT sector's
bellwethers, Infosys and Wipro, for the year ended 31 March
2003. Whilst Infosys' net margins are down to 26.44 per cent
from 31.03 per cent in 2002, Wipro's have slipped 4.81 percentage
points to 20.17 per cent (although that number is for the whole
firm and not just the IT services arm). Industry experts expect
the IT services sector's margins to dip to around 20 per cent,
a plunge from the 27 per cent levels of 2001. "There are
pricing pressures. Which industry can operate on a 30 percent
margin? Over the next two years margins should settle at 22-25
per cent which is reasonable," shrugs Phiroz Vandrewala,
Executive Vice President, TCS.
One major contributor to the dip in margins is the surge
in 'marketing and selling' expenditure. Infosys spent Rs 266.98
crore on marketing in the year just concluded, up 106 per
cent from the previous year's Rs 129.79 crore. Wipro's splurge
was even higher, almost seven times the 2002 spend of Rs 80.57
crore, at Rs 550.60 crore. That's a surefire indication of
the cut-throat competition and the pricing pressures. And
don't forget the global nature of the competition. "MNCs
that have set up shop here will improve their margins (which
are currently single-digit globally) while those of Indian
vendors will dip," says Vijay Khare, Senior Vice President,
Patni Computer Systems.
If you think the industry leaders are having a rough time,
spare a thought for the tier-two players, who struggling to
keep their top line in ship shape. Mastek's sales for the
fourth quarter have plunged 19 per cent over 2002's corresponding
period, and margins sunk under 20 per cent in the March ended
quarter. The shakeout begins...
|
You could blame
it on the recession in the US, or the war in Iraq, or even the sars
virus in the Far East, but the chronology of events between March
and April reveals one of the more ominous reasons for the squeeze
in margins being faced by India's IT services giants: The aggressive
competition from the multinational IT bandwagon. Over the years,
a host of MNCs has hammered the pegs of their tents firmly into
local shores, the objective clearly being to leverage the similar
low-cost, high-quality advantage the homegrown firms enjoy. The
early birds IBM Global Services, Oracle, EDs, CSC and Cognizant
have now been joined by other IT consulting giants like Gap Gemini
Ernst & Young, Sapient, Keane, and Accenture.
If you think Accenture's unbridled aggression
directed at Indian IT services firms is an isolated case, check
out what one leading industry player has to say, strictly on condition
of anonymity. "One of the reasons for the industry leader's
lower earnings guidance for the year ahead is that an MNC vendor
has actually offered clients with whom the Indian company has fixed-price
one-year contracts the same services at prices 12 per cent lower."
V. Srinivasan, MD and CEO, ICICI Infotech, confirms the trend of
pressure on pricing. "There are some cases where the clients
actually want to renegotiate the contract mid-way itself; they are
not even willing to wait till the end of the contract."
The MNCs for their part have their own very
good reasons for stepping on the gas in India. Their gung-ho expansion
plans come in the wake of a global consolidation, which resulted
in IBM's acquisition of PricewaterhouseCoopers consulting business
and Cap Gemini taking over Ernst & Young's consulting business.
Thus, they're now able to provide end-to-end services (right from
it services to strategy consulting), and that's what clients are
naturally expecting. With the MNCs willing to match or even go below
prices being offered by Indian vendors, there are those clients
who feel they're getting much more value from the global majors
for the same price they would otherwise be paying the Indian IT
services players.
"IT outsourcing is getting more and more
strategic to the end customer and it's the CEO rather than the CIO
who is getting increasingly involved. Consequently, the demand is
for end-to-end services. The CEO doesn't care what programmes the
IT vendor specialises in, he is more concerned with strategic and
cost implications. So we have to go to him with a complete and cost
effective offering" explains Amitabh Ray, Director (Exports)
at IBM Global Services. Adds Salil Parekh, coo (Asia-Pacific), Cap
Gemini Ernst & Young: "Pricing is always going to be an
issue in this market but we are banking on the fact that our clients
see our processes and methods as superior to those followed by Indian
vendors. And it's available at the same price.''
If the perception still exists that the MNCs
will be charging more than their Indian counterparts, Amit Govil,
Managing Director, Sapient India, dispels that myth. ''We cannot
price ourselves any higher than our Indian competitors just because
of our brand name. We're going to have to compete head-on by offering
value at competitive prices,'' he says.
Staging A Fightback
The Indian vendors may be hurting, but they're
fighting back with strategies that range from broadening their service
offerings, to tapping new markets and market segments with products,
to more ambitious and far-reaching strategies like acquisitions
to beef up their front-ends. Companies like i-flex are banking on
niche offerings and domain expertise as well as the "made by
India" brand, as CEO Deepak Ghaisas puts it. Others like ICICI
Infotech plan to move away from the "cost-arbitrage model to
products and intellectual property rights," says Srinivasan,
in addition to tapping markets like the Middle and Far East. Patni
Computer Systems Senior Vice President Vijay Khare points out that
Indian vendors should start focussing on verticals, and areas like
BPO, infrastructure management, and real-time embedded systems.
The Indian vendors may be hurting, but they're
fighting back with strategies ranging from broadening service
offerings, to tapping new markets, to acquisitions
|
The biggest challenge for the Indian sector,
however, is to create a marketing face-that vital front end-to compete
with the MNC competition whose stronghold is the consulting space.
Whilst the task for the domestic industry is to integrate forward,
the MNCs have to focus on building a back-end. And both sectors
are doing just that. Wipro, for instance, recently acquired the
utility division of consulting firm AMS in the US. And Keane picked
up SignalTree, a US-based Indian vendor with development centres
in India. The IT and consulting sector is clearly going through
a mammoth consolidation phase, the aim being to put together an
efficient end-to-end service offering.
So what's going to be tougher-integrating forward
or backward? "Both are tough, but I would say that the integration
of a back-end is the tougher of the two since the delivery model
has to be perfected," says Lakshmi Narayanan, President and
Chief Operating Officer, Cognizant Technology Solutions, a US-based
company that has a completely Indian back-end. Companies like Accenture,
IBMGs and Sapient, however, are banking on their global delivery
resources model, which includes several thousands of professionals
across countries.
As the war between homegrown IT vendors and
the MNCs plays out, investment bankers, who are expecting a wave
of accelerated deal-making in the near term, are licking their chops.
Munesh Khanna, Managing Director, nm Rothschild & Sons India,
says the results posted by the tech majors have already resulted
in valuations plummeting across the sector. "What happened
last fortnight (to Infosys and Wipro) will be a trigger for mergers
and acquisitions. Second-tier companies that have been holding out
will have to take a call now. As for the majors like Infosys, Wipro,
Satyam and Patni, they should be looking at cross-border acquisitions
if they want to sustain their growth rates." What won't make
it easier for the second-rung IT services companies is the war for
talent, which can only succeed in pushing up their wage costs up,
by as much as 15-20 per cent. Clearly, only the more cost-effective,
and the more integrated, will last the long haul in this highly-competitive
landscape.
|