Suraj
Sinha has been rather pensive, of late. A mid-manager at a corporate
on an enviable salary, he thought he was leading a fiscally sound
life. No home loan to pay off, no shopping-binge liabilities, no
ailing parents to support. Just one kid-his five-year-old Shantanu.
But then, reality hit him. He had to cough
up a minor fortune to have Shantanu admitted to a school; and has
discovered that this is just the first step of an escalator he committed
himself to six years ago. Shantanu, chortling away, of course, doesn't
have a clue why daddy has turned so quiet.
Daddy dear is burdened by three facts. Education
is no longer the incidental expense it was for his own parents,
his job is a lot less secure, and his son will aspire to the hallowed
portals of American Ivy League colleges. He could say 'heck, school
is school', and opt for the state-subsidised systems. But then,
quality gaps are said to have widened beyond all hope. Is there
a way out?
Start
Early, Estimate Budget
The best time to start investing for your child's
education is when you hear those first few bawls from the cradle.
Time makes all the difference.
INSURANCE ILLUSTRATED
|
We do a lifestyle profile of
each parent to understand the need of the parent and further
how much money he can park aside from his annual income for
his child's secured future," says Rinku Sachdev, Financial
Services Consultant, ICICI Prudential Life Insurance, "It
is after this that we recommend a product to suit the person."
If you're a 29-year-old parent with a one-year-old, here's
a 21-year insurance plan (ICICI Prudential's Smart Kid, a
unit linked plan). To start with, you must invest Rs 1 lakh
per year for the next five years, and then half of that till
the plan's maturity. The insurer deducts the fee for the life
cover, and invests the rest in a unit linked plan (like a
mutual fund, half debt and half equity in this case). You
get Rs 1.5 lakh when your child is 10, Rs 3 lakh when 12,
another Rs 3 lakh when 15, Rs 2 lakh when 21 and Rs 5 lakh
when 22. At the end of the plan's tenure, when your child
is 22, the fund is worth Rs 29 odd lakh, despite the five
withdrawals (since the fund includes risky equity investments,
it is not an assured sum).
You could get several variations on this scheme, depending
on your specific needs. The important aspect is life cover.
In the tragic event of your child losing you prematurely,
the sum assured- a fat lump sum-is paid immediately-and if
you take the premium-waiver option (at a nominal charge),
your child still gets the periodic payments down the years
without any need of further premium payments. The whole idea
is to secure your child's education.
|
WORD OF CAUTION
|
There exist mutual
funds aimed specifically at kids' education. The only way these
schemes are different from regular growth schemes is that they
have a lock-in period, which other growth schemes don't. This
doesn't assure you any better returns, but certainly assures
the fund manager an 18-year commitment. "Though mutual
funds are the best possible investment option today," says
Hemant Rustagi, an investment advisor, "take a look at
all the growth schemes and select a few instead of investing
only in children's schemes for building an education kitty for
your child." |
First, make a budget estimate by looking at
current fees. Boarding schools such as Lawrence, Doon and Welham
are upwards of Rs 1.5 lakh per annum, all expenses included, while
good day schools such as Cathedral, J.B. Petit and Bombay Scottish
in Mumbai cost around a fifth of that just in fees. A good local
undergrad college, say St Xavier's or Narsee Monjee, would be around
the same-Rs 30,000 for three years. An MBA after that could cost
some Rs 4 lakh at an IIM, or Rs 9 lakh at ISB. The real nose-bleeder
is an Ivy League college in the US; Harvard could mean $37,500 per
year (or some Rs 17.5 lakh for a four-year liberal arts degree).
And all these are current rates-even with inflation of just 5 per
cent, these will sound like the proverbial 'good old days' in 20
years.
Educate Yourself, Invest
You may opt to create your own portfolio for
your child's education fund, with a blend of stocks, mutual funds,
fixed deposits and other investments. Rajiv Bajaj, Managing Director,
Bajaj Capital, advises parents to approach the entire issue as any
other investment-with clarity on your target sum and risk appetite.
Typically, the word 'child' evokes 'safety',
and so debt investments seem attractive. But given the low interest
rates, you need to think beyond that. You could start with some
portion of equities, perhaps, and gradually replace it with high-liquidity
debt as your child's education expenses mount-to get yourself a
safety cushion.
That said, don't ignore the 'solutions' that
insurers have to offer. "You as a parent have to set a goal
and quantify it," says Pankaj Seith, Head (Marketing), HDFC
Standard Life Insurance, "after which the reverse calculation
of the premiums is worked out by us." Most such deals involve
putting in some money against the promise of returns fat enough
to pay the fees. If you're given to comparing returns, these deals
could seem tightfisted. The premiums sound way too high for the
sums delivered to pay the fees.
But there's a reason for that. "Insurance
is important for an education portfolio because it has a life cover
aspect to it," says Sujata Dutta, Head (Marketing), Tata AIG
Life Insurance. "If the sole earning parent dies, not only
are future premiums waived, but the child education plan also doesn't
suffer. This benefit is not there in any other investment vehicle."
The Peg Ratio
A ratio to hang your portfolio by? Maybe not.
But useful nonetheless.
By Narendra Nathan
Price.
This, first and foremost, is what a stock-picker must make sense
of. In theory, this means comparing the stock's market price with
its intrinsic value. "The successful investor is one who invests
only when the market price is far below (this gap is known as the
'margin of safety' in finance) its intrinsic value," says Raamdeo
Agrawal, Joint Managing Director, Motilal Oswal Securities.
But the first casualty of a stockmarket boom
is this margin of safety. The stock is no longer available 'cheap',
especially if one goes by traditional valuation parameters such
as the price-earnings (PE) ratio, calculated by dividing the share
price (P) by the earnings-per-share (EPS). This is typically when
analysts turn to the peg ratio.
What is it? A ratio. The PE divided by the
earnings growth rate (g). The idea is to take future growth expectations
into account.
What difference does it make? Imagine two companies,
X and Y, both quoting at Rs 100 each, with an EPS of Rs 5 each.
Their PE: 20 each. Assume you have good reason to believe that company
X will grow at 10 per cent, while Y will grow at 30 per cent. Assume
also a bull run, with market frenzy pushing all prices up. Company
X rises to Rs 120 next year, while company Y, powered by its faster-growth
story, goes to Rs 150. This would give X a PE ratio of 21.8 and
Y a less attractive ratio of 23.1. Which of the two stocks are better
valued?
If you go by simple PE, you will be misled-since
the growth difference hasn't gone away.
Had you picked on the basis of the peg ratio,
by dividing the stock's PE by the growth rate, you would've stuck
with Y. For the current year, the peg of X is 2, while that of Y
is 0.67. A year hence, X is 2.18 and Y is 0.77 "As a thumbrule,
peg below one is treated as cheap while above one is treated as
costly," says Gurunath Mudlapur, Head of Research at Khandwala
Securities.
Now apply the concept to the top 10 Nifty scrips,
and you will find that Hindustan Lever and Wipro, for instance,
are highly priced even after taking prospective growth (by analysts'
2003-04 estimates) into account.
Neat? Sure. But don't rush off to peg your
future on the ratio. Growth expectations could depend on varying
investment horizons. Moreover, the peg ratio tends to fail in special
cases. A start-up growing furiously on a small base could look very
tempting, for example, while a large powerhouse could look dangerously
overpriced. It's no substitute for intimate corporate knowledge.
|