|
A large
and diverse group of Indians recently developed scenarios of what
type of country India would become by the interplay of forces that
were becoming evident in the country. The group included economists,
bureaucrats, industrialists, political leaders, educationists and
social workers. There were also students, village women and homeless
street children. The many diverse perspectives produced rich insights
into the aspirations and apprehensions of people. Four possible
scenarios emerged, signs of which are already visible. Any one of
these scenarios could overtake the others if the forces shaping
it were to prevail. A young woman produced four pictures to describe
these scenarios vividly. One of them was called "Buffaloes
Wallowing". It showed a group of buffaloes wallowing together
in a pond while a child waited on the side. The buffaloes represented
leaders of various constituencies of Indian society. The child represented
the young people of India. When one buffalo wants to move, others
prevent it and so they all keep wallowing. But how long can the
children wait?
India has the largest number of young people
in the world today. There are only two countries in the world with
a billion people-China and India. China curtailed the production
of children with its 'one child' policy while population control
sputtered in India. We have approximately 65 million children below
15 years of age, and as many as 400 million young people below the
age of 23. These young people will, hopefully, join the ranks of
working people in the next few years, thus creating a huge surge
of productive activity, incomes and savings. This is the 'demographic
dividend' on which the famous BRICs report bases its projection
that India will be the third largest economy in 2050, behind China
and the us, and way ahead of Japan and Germany. India's young people
can be an asset to the global economy because while India's population
will be getting younger over the coming decades, the population
of all the developed countries, including those of Russia and China,
will be getting older. The richer countries will face a shortage
of working age people while India will have a surplus. Therefore,
India can bring in more than $200 billion (Rs 8.8 lakh crore) of
revenues every year from the richer countries and create 40 million
additional jobs by providing a variety of services to the rest of
the world.
Demographics are predictable. If enough children
have not been born in rich countries and in China in the past decade,
there is no way these countries can now increase the number of working-age
people in the next 20 years, except through large immigration inflows,
which they may not allow fearing social and political ramifications.
India is bound to have enough working-age people because the children
are already born. However, their future depends on the shape the
Indian economy and society will take over the next few years. It
depends on the decisions and actions of many leaders in India-in
political parties, the bureaucracy, civil society and business.
The consequences of not making the necessary changes are frightening.
India could end up with a mass of unhealthy, under-employed and
frustrated young people-a veritable cauldron for brewing violence.
The capabilities and spirit of our youth
are critical determinants of India's future. The two vital ingredients
of our youth's capabilities are their health and education |
The capabilities and spirit of our youth are
critical determinants of India's future. The two vital ingredients
of our youth's capabilities are their health and education. Millions
of Indians have been lifted out of abject poverty. Now, while fewer
Indians may die of starvation, it is shocking that as many as 45
per cent of India's children are malnourished. This makes them vulnerable
to deteriorating health as they grow, which is a potential burden
on society that is not factored into the calculations of the demographic
dividend that are based purely on the number of people. The causes
of malnourishment are multifarious, and rooted in systemic problems
of food availability and low incomes compounded by traditions and
habits. Quick fixes are not obvious. Therefore, many agencies will
have to think together and understand what the root causes are and
determine how they may be effectively addressed. Scenes of starvation
may spur vigorous responses from society. But malnourishment is
barely noticed. Some recent efforts to focus on this silent killer
have shown that it is neither easy to get people's attention nor
simple to get agencies to work together. But the longer we take,
the greater the burden on our society in the decades ahead.
Fortunately, the attention of Indian society
and its policy-makers has turned to the health of our education
system. All parts of the system require urgent attention. The problems
are relevance and efficiency. The content of education must be relevant
to the future lives of the learners and must be delivered in a manner
that fits the condition of their present lives. The standard classroom
model of education is not satisfactory. It generally does not foster
the desire to learn. And it does not create abilities to engage
productively with the needs of the emerging economy. Moreover, it
is very inefficient in the use of physical and human resources.
Alternative models are emerging that can provide
cost-effective education and in ways that fit the lives of people.
For example, the model for adult literacy developed by Tata Consultancy
Services enables a grown woman to learn to read in 12 weeks in 30
to 40 convenient one-hour sessions, at a cost of only Rs 100! Other
initiatives are also noteworthy-such as the UGC's scheme to add
a vocational stream to arts, commerce and science courses through
which India churns out over seven million 'general' degree holders
every year. The addition of a second stream to their curriculum,
enabling them to earn a second degree alongside, will improve their
employability. However, the biggest obstacle to the introduction
of such innovations is the rigidity in the policy framework that
impedes the grant of more autonomy to educational institutions,
changes in their curricula and willingness to allow the private
sector to play a larger role. Therefore, the children wait for better
education while the buffaloes wallow.
The consequences of not making the necessary
changes are frightening. India could end up with a mass of unhealthy,
under-employed and frustrated young people-a veritable cauldron
for brewing violence |
The most hopeful of the four scenarios of India
that emerged from the process mentioned earlier was an evocative
picture of "Fireflies Arising". In this scenario of India's
development, women and youth had a large role in thousands of local
initiatives all over the country. In this scenario, people were
not waiting passively for the buffaloes to move, but had taken initiatives
themselves. Young people were no longer a burden to be provided
for, but were agents of change. The picture showed millions of fireflies,
each carrying his or her own light, rising from the gloom and collectively
brightening up the world.
Five major forces were analysed that together,
can bring about this desirable scenario. Society and policy-makers
must strengthen these forces:
- Proliferation of it, broadband and communications
technologies to empower women and children in the rural and poor
urban areas by providing them access to education and governance;
- Improvement of education content and information
to make them relevant to the lives of people;
- Fostering local initiatives through changes
in governance structures and support through micro-finance, trained
volunteers, etc;
- Propagation of successful stories to provide
hope and insights to others and thereby 'splash around' the benefits
of development and growth; and
- Development of new models and skills of
leadership (about which I will say more).
Almost every discussion about India's future
turns to the need for a new breed of 'leaders'. And almost every
discussion about education raises the issue of the values our children
are imbibing. I believe that a society like ours that wishes to
combine the power of market-based capitalism, which requires people
to look after their own interests, with an inclusive model of development
and growth, must foster two values in all its citizens. The first
is respect for public property, not merely one's own, because Indians
are notorious for dirtying public places while maintaining spotlessly
clean homes. The second is to use the power of authority granted
by society for the benefit of the weak rather than for the aggrandisement
of oneself and one's cronies. We need many more role models who
practice these values and, thus, teach children, rather than by
preaching in classrooms and seminars.
The India scenarios exercise also addressed
these issues. It analysed different role models of leaders-who they
are and what they do-before our youth. One model is a person who
has a high position and title and is called a 'leader' even if he
or she does not do anything to improve our society. This was the
model within the scenario of "Buffaloes Wallowing". Another
model, embedded in another scenario with a picture of a strutting
peacock, is a person with wealth. This model is coming into greater
prominence in India with wealthy people celebrated in the media.
A third model, in another scenario, is a person who is feared because
he has the power to hurt, like some of our less savoury political
'leaders'.
However, it is the fourth type of leader that
we need. These are people who care for a cause and not merely their
own benefits. They take the initiative to act and do not wait around
to be told to do something. They have open minds and learn the ideas
that will help them attain their goals. They collaborate with others
knowing that they do not themselves have all the resources and authority
required to obtain their goals. Thus, they encourage others to follow
them towards a shared goal. These are the 'fireflies' that Indian
youth must be for India to emerge as the great country that the
vast number of its young people can make it.
|