|
The Ogilvy Spread
J.C. Giri
President, Ogilvy & Mather, Mumbai
"We need to be wherever
the consumer is in the 360-degree circle of life"
OGILVY HEALTHCARE
The healthcare specialist.
OGILVY SPORT
Sport advertising, promotion, and events.
OGILVY ACTIVATION
Outdoor, rural and direct marketing.
OGILVY DIGITAL
Internet advertising.
AUTO CLUSTER
Works on the agency's auto-related clients.
|
Last
fortnight Religare, a Ranbaxy group company that provides financial
services, went live with an advertising campaign that attempts
to extol the virtues of trading in shares via the internet. The
campaign may not have set the Ganges on fire, but the significant
bit about it is that the company and its advertising agency, Rediffusion
DY&R, are using every medium available to get their message
across-radio, print, online, below-the-line, television and even
cinema. Religare may not be an isolated example of advertisers
resorting to 360-degree campaigns. Recent communications by Pond's
Age Miracle, Appy Fizz and Chevrolet Aveo were also launched on
multiple media platforms.
|
The Rediffusion Mall
Mahesh Chauhan
President, Rediffusion DY&R
"It's up to the agency to decide
whether it wants to have a department store model or a mall
model"
SUDLER AND HENNESSEY
The healthcare advertising division.
WUNDERMAN
The relationship management arm.
OAP
Outdoor and out-of-home promotional activities.
SHOWDIFF
Customised events, sports marketing, talent management,
content syndication and in-film placement.
|
Such hybrid campaigns may be gaining in popularity
but that's not what this story is about. Rather, it's about how
advertising agencies are remodelling themselves to be in a position
to offer clients solutions on multiple fronts. After all, today
there exist innumerable ways of getting to the consumer, and advertising
agencies are fast waking up to the fact. With traditional media,
primarily television commercials, no longer able to give advertisers
an adequate bang for their big bucks, advertisers have little
choice but to rely on other forms of communication delivery. And
that's already begun to happen. For instance, what till recently
was referred to as 'below-the-line-activity' is today one of the
most focussed areas of advertising, marketing and communications.
So much so that it is referred to as through-the-line in some
sections of advertising, and rightly so. As Ashish Bhasin, Director
of Lintas India's Integrated Marketing Action Group (IMAG, which
comprises Lintas' eight specialised arms), puts it: "If you
were to look at the us, depending on the category, almost 70-75
per cent of the ad industry's revenues come from through-the-line
areas. Looking at the trend in India, by 2007-end, IMAG estimates
show that through-the-line will command a 50 per cent share for
the entire industry. Going forward, it will make up a far larger
part of the communication and marketing pie." As far as the
Lintas group is concerned, through-the-line-activities are on
a smaller base, but make up the fastest growing part of the business.
This is true for the industry at large.
|
Lintas' Hybrid Model
Prem Mehta
Chairman, Lintas India
"Traditional media is beginning
to give way as it is not as vital to communications as it
used to be"
LINTERLAND
Rural marketing
LINTAS PERSONAL
DM, CRM, Internet solutions
AAREN INITIATIVE
Out-of-Home
LINOPINION
Public relations
ADVENT
Event Management
LINTERTAINMENT
Film marketing, in-film product placements
LINTAS HEALTHCARE
Pharma and healthcare
dCELL:
Strategic design consultancy
|
To be sure, not all advertising agencies are
responding in exactly the same manner to the increasing demands
of clients. Whilst the likes of Lintas, Ogilvy and Rediffusion
DY&R have set up separate divisions to cater to their clients'
specialised needs, others, like Leo Burnett and behemoth JWT,
have all these specialised services under one banner. Says Arvind
Sharma, Chairman of India Sub-Continent, Leo Burnett: "We
have brought Arc Worldwide to India. It will provide our clients
with speciality services like direct marketing, customer relationship
management (CRM), events management, promotions, and a whole area
of services that our clients might want, depending on their needs."
JWT too has RMG Connect, which performs a role similar to that
of Arc Worldwide.
Doubtless, however, it's the divisional structure
that's most popular with agencies. Consider Lintas' IMAG, which
consists of eight divisions. Linterland, its rural marketing arm,
has 10,000 people working for it at any point in time. Lintas
Personal, which started as a direct marketing entity, has today
evolved into offering CRM and internet solutions too. Aaren Initiative
is the company's out-of-home operation, LinOpinion its public
relations division, Advent the event management arm, and Lintertainment
is involved in film marketing and in-film product placements and
associations. There's also Lintas Healthcare and dCell, a strategic
design consultancy that focusses on packaging, corporate and brand
identities and retail design. Then there's Ogilvy, which has OgilvyOne,
which in turn includes a host of focussed operations. These include
Ogilvy Healthcare, Ogilvy Sport, Ogilvy Activation (which concentrates
on outdoor, rural and direct marketing), and Ogilvy Digital, which
also includes Ogilvy@neo.
|
Prasoon Joshi
Creative Director South & Southeast Asia, McCann-Erickson
"One can't become a one-stop shop
for every integrated service that there is; I've seen that
model and it just doesn't work" |
There's clearly reason for such specialised
branding. Explains Prem Mehta, Chairman, Lintas India: "Clients
would not see those services (for which different brands have
been created) as specialised unless they were branded separately.
In fact, if you look at things like direct marketing and design,
these are things that the agency provides free of charge to the
client in any case; but for these units to compete with specialised
companies, they needed to have the character of specialised expertise."
Adds J.C. Giri, President, Ogilvy & Mather, Mumbai: "We
need to be where the consumer is in the 360-degree circle of life.
We need to be present at every touch point."
It's not as if divisions for direct marketing
or rural marketing or design or out-of-home or in-film marketing
are new phenomena. For many years now, they've been on offer as
a part of a bouquet of services. However, it's only in the past
couple of years that these offerings have been packaged, branded
and promoted as individual, specialised services. Giri adds that
agencies have also realised the importance of having people with
in-depth domain knowledge at these specialised niches if the objective
is to "deliver quality work seamlessly."
|
Arvind Sharma
Chairman of India Sub-Continent, Leo Burnett
"We have brought Arc Worldwide to
India, and that will provide our clients an array of speciality
services" |
Another agency that's put in place a hybrid
model is Rediffusion dy&r, although the specialised divisions
don't rely on the mother agency for branding. There's Sudler and
Hennessey, which is the healthcare advertising division, Wunderman,
which handles customer relationship management, OAP, with a focus
on outdoor and out-of-home promotions, and Showdiff, which specialises
in customised events, sports marketing, talent management, content
syndication and in-film placement. Says Mahesh Chauhan, President,
Rediffusion DY&R: "It's up to the agency to decide whether
it wants to have a department store model, or a mall model."
However, there's at least one agency that
doesn't appear enamoured of any of these models. McCann-Erickson
in India is the only multinational advertising conglomerate that
does not have specialised divisions. It does have McCann Healthcare,
but that's run as a separate company, with a separate office.
Prasoon Joshi, Creative Director for South & Southeast Asia,
McCann-Erickson, is more keen to focus on his agency's core strength.
"We need to define and understand what it is (the core strength).
We can't become a one-stop shop for every service that there is;
I've seen that model and it just doesn't work," shrugs Joshi.
Those are indeed brave words that go against the grain. Joshi
may have a point when he voices doubts about an agency's ability
to build competencies across the spectrum; but, then again, with
clients increasingly seeking value-added services, ad houses that
don't set up such specialised shops run the real risk of losing
out dollops of business. As Lintas' Mehta points out: "Traditional
media is beginning to give way as it is not as vital to communications
as it used to be." Traditional agencies too might be going
down the same road.
|