|
Bombay Dyeing's Nusli Wadia is a very hands-on-non-executive
Chairman and actually tastes all of Britannia's planned offerings. |
The opening gambit
of Britannia's born-again biscuit strategy is a focus on power brands,
akin to Hindustan Lever Limited's much publicised gamble of concentrating
its efforts on 30 brands that accounted for the bulk of its turnover-a
gamble that worked. Alagh reacts indignantly to suggestions that
the strategy was inspired by Lever. Britannia, he says, had formulated
the strategy well before HLL went public with its. The seven brands
identified as part of the power-club: Marie Gold, Treat, Good Day,
Fifty Fifty, Milk Bikis, Time Pass, and Tiger and its variants.
Then, there's the repackaging initiative. Five
years ago, Britannia hired Paris-based Shombit Sen's Shining Strategic
Design to craft a new look for it. Now it has gone back to the man.
Alagh is tightlipped about the new design but says, ''The primary
ingredient of biscuits is wheat, and we want to highlight its benefits.''
It isn't every company that goes in for two facelifts in a span
of five years, but it isn't every company that diversifies into
a new business, pin its hopes on it, and just when it is beginning
to do well hive it off into a joint venture.
Cost is another focus area. The company's operating
margins have improved from 4.1 per cent in 1998 to 7.7 per cent
in 2002. Raw material and packaging costs are down approximately
10 per cent, the workforce has been pruned from 5,074 in 2000 to
4,126 today, and the Britannia is eyeing more gains.
Lever has tried that, again, and with some amount
of success-over the past 15 quarters its profits have been robust
despite modest growth in sales. Still, gains from operational improvements
are at best incremental. For exponential progress of the kind Britannia
seeks, selling more is a pre-requisite. Says Satish Turlapati, an
FMCG analyst with Motilal Oswal Securities, ''To grow the company
will need more than cost cutting measures"
A Cookie-Cutter Strategy?
The market for the twice-baked stuff that goes
under the generic name biscuits may have grown at an anaemic 6 per
cent since 1996, but Alagh hasn't let that statistical spoil-sport
dampen his enthusiasm. ''The maximum gains are always made in periods
of uncertainty,'' he reflects philosophically. He has got a strategy
to back his belief, but it is still on paper.
The specifics range from leveraging organic
growth- a low pay-off option-to edging out the unorganised sector
with "right products at the right price".
Efforts to identify those products are on as
is a programme targetted at creating what Alagh terms ''opportunity
managers'', by ''encouraging innovation'', and ''penalising conventional
thinking''. ''And we'll continue to bond with the trade,'' explains
Alagh.
That sounds suspiciously like a cookie cutter
strategy, although Alagh's promise of ''innovative products and
exciting promotions of the Britannia-Lagaan kind'' could give it
a much-needed edge. The last, for those who came in late, involved
a promo where lucky winners could square off against the Lagaan
team led by Aamir Khan.
The problem with a strategy like that is that
it is heavily price dependent. Consumers in urban markets may be
open to premium offerings, but as Britannia's experience with its
Nutrichoice range of biscuits has shown, the takings aren't rich.
The competition is aware of this. Parle, which
owns the world's largest selling (nearly 2.5 tonnes a year) biscuit
brand Parle G boasts a 65 per cent marketshare in the Rs 1,500-crore
domestic glucose biscuit market largely on account of its lower-than-low
price strategy (the company declined to comment).
And Bakeman's marketing chief Pradeep Kant,
says his company is looking to grow its marketshare. ''We are confident
of taking on competition".
The ace up Alagh's sleeve could be managerial
bandwidth. In March, 2002 Britannia named Nikhil Sen Chief Operating
Officer. Sen joined the company as a management trainee in 1980
and his elevation is widely seen as an effort by the company to
strengthen its marketing. And Nusli Wadia himself isn't your everyday
non-executive chairperson.
An ardent foodie himself, he personally tastes
each of Britannia's potential offerings. The company grapevine has
it that when Milkman was venturing into lassi it was Wadia who nixed
the proposed salted variant in favout of a sweetened one.
Alagh will need all that counsel and more.
Growing the biscuits business will mean launching premium offerings
that can compete with the likes of Jacob's- ironically, a brand
owned by Danone-and McVites in the fragmented urban market. It will
also mean building on Tiger's success in the rural market with new
variants and in the face of intense competition. In, his own words,
he has to be a jerry, not chase one.
1
2 3
|