Is
technical analysis another form of tea-leaf reading? No, say the
experts. "Though technical analysis is not strictly a predictive
tool, it is a pre-emptive weapon against the probable manner in
which a stock, or any traded asset, is likely to behave," says
Jamshed Desai, Head of Research at IL&FS Investsmart India,
"It doubles up as an effective risk management tool as well."
Pre-emptive. Weapon. Risk management. It sounds
too complicated to bother with. Then there are all these zigzag
lines to decipher. Even with your best cryptologist instincts on
high alert, you might be tempted to take the customary advice of
financial advisors: 'stay off this stuff'.
They mean well, of course. By custom, these
lines and charts are to be used discreetly, and rarely to be admitted
so in public. So if anyone is around, lower your reading to a whisper.
Psssst... is it addictive? The evidence on this is sketchy, but
those who get it tend to stay with it.
So What Is It?
Broadly, the term 'technical analysis' applies
to the study of historical asset price and volume data for the purpose
of projecting its future behaviour. Unlike 'fundamental analysis',
which looks at the company's financials to see what the stock is
worth, technical analysis only looks at data generated by the stockmarket.
|
''Primary technical analysis is much
better than using low levels of fundamental analysis''
C.K. Narayan/Consultant/
ICICI Securities |
Now, investors can go by the 'fundamentals'
or by the 'technicals', but the smart option perhaps is to use a
combination of both, using the former to identify stocks, and the
latter to figure out exactly when to buy and sell.
As Desai says, "Technical analysis is
supplementary tool to fundamental analysis." Thankfully, it
is quite easy to understand and practice---once you overcome the
fear of those jagged lines.
According to C.K. Narayan, consultant at ICICI
Securities, primary technical analysis is much better than using
"low levels of fundamental analysis" (such as market hearsay
or tips).
The broad idea is simple: you win by playing
at the leading edge of the prevailing trend. That is, you buy a
stock just as the price goes on an uptrend, and sell at the first
signal of a downtrend. The trend, as they say, is your friend.
"Technical analysis," says Deepak
Mohoni, a Pune-based technical analyst, "will help you find
a trend when it starts." But how to identify the ups and downs?
Compare spiky 'sensitive' data with generalised longer time-scale
trends. Here are the tools:
Simple Moving Average
This is the simplest trend following technique.
It smoothens the price chart's spikes and dips to present a trend
of prices averaged out over several readings. For a fortnightly
moving average, first take the average closing value of a stock
(or Sensex) over the past fortnight (14 days' prices added up, divided
by 14), and plot it against today's date. To make it 'move', you
again plot the past fortnight's average tomorrow (with a new day's
price added and the earliest day's dropped). Do this every day,
and connect the dots to get a moving average line.
|
'''To mitigate the risk of false signals,
go with the weight of technical evidence'''
Mitesh Thacker/Associate
VP/Kotak Securities |
Of course, you could take an average of any
period. The chart featured above is a 26-week moving average of
the Sensex, ideal for long-term investors. The buy/sell rule here
is simple: you buy when the quoted price goes above the moving average
value, and sell when it falls below. By the chart above, a six-month
horizon investor would have bought the Sensex on June 6, 2003, sold
it on May 14, 2004, and made off with a tidy sum.
Note that a shorter-time moving average would
have been of little help. "This is because the short term signals
will be valid only for a short period," explains Manish Shah,
Technical Analyst with KRC Research. You must pick a moving average
to suit your investment time frame. Day traders use 30-minute moving
averages, for instance. If you're investing on corporate research,
a monthly, quarterly or six-monthly moving average would be far
more appropriate.
Top-Bottom Trend Lines
You plot the stock's closing price every day,
and get a sensitive price chart. Now look for peaks and valleys.
A visibly high peak is a 'top', and a visibly sunken low is a 'bottom'.
You draw a straight line through tops to connect peaks, or through
bottoms to connect dips. Now, if both tops and bottoms keep going
higher and higher, it's an obvious uptrend (and vice-versa).
But a single trend line will do. If just the
tops keep getting lower and lower, you still have a downtrend. For
a long-term trend, take the case of BHEL's stock price over several
years (see chart below). The first top on July 31, 1997 is followed
by two lower tops (January 29, 1998 and August 31, 1999). If you
draw a straight line through the three top points, you get a downward
sloping trend line.
|
TREND CATCHING
|
» Simple
Moving Average offers a 'long view' of the price
data (averaged over a length of time) to compare spiky sensitive
prices with; if the live price overshoots the trend, buy.
» Top-Bottom
Trends tell you the generalised price story by
joining the high (or low) points to see if it's going up or
down; if the sensitive trading price goes above the line,
buy
» Momentum
Indicators offer early-warnings on whether the
price is gaining or losing momentum; if an MACD indicator
overshoots its own moving average, buy.
|
Now, a buy/sell signal here is made by a so-called
'trend reversal'. How to identify one? If the price goes above the
long downward trend, it's time to buy. For BHEL, this happens on
February 28, 2003.
Likewise, an upward trend would be made by
a straight line drawn through at least three successively higher
bottoms. If the price falls below the trend, sell.
Momentum Indicators
Technical analysis gets slightly more complex
if you want to catch an emerging uptrend even before its onset.
It can be done-by watching trend momentum. Like a car, a trend typically
slows down before turning around. Your speedometer is the momentum
indicator, the most popular kind being the Moving Average Convergence
Divergence (MACD) line. How to calculate it? Deduct a long-term
moving average (usually 26 days) from a short-term one (usually
12 days), and plot the difference. This difference tells you what's
happening. In an uptrend, the more recent averages are higher than
the longer-span averages, so the MACD value is positive. If the
trend is bearish, the MACD turns negative.
To get buy/sell signals, however, plot a separate
'trigger line'-typically a nine-day moving average of the MACD values.
Now, if the the MACD zooms up ahead of its own smoothened average
(cutting the trigger line from below on the chart), it means that
things are getting zippy, so you buy. If the MACD line goes below
the trigger line, sell (as on August 13, 2004, in the chart above).
You must be cautious, however, to avoid picking up false signals.
Slowing cars sometimes just shoot ahead again.
Yes, It Works
Admittedly, you risk a mishap or two, especially
with momentum indicators. But don't let people tell you that all
this is "too technical" for you. "Though it is used
mostly by traders now," says Narayan, "it is not fair
to call it an analysis only for traders."
True, false signals are a real problem. But
there's a way to mitigate that risk. "Go with the weight of
technical evidence," advises Mitesh Thacker of Kotak Securities.
In other words, use several tools on the same asset, and act only
if you get similar signals from most.
Used correctly, technical analysis is found
to work. Prices, after all, are found to display visible patterns
that occur over and over again-the result of the past behaviour
of investors. It is reasonable to expect this collective behaviour
to cause similar patterns in the future as well, be it a swing from
over-optimism to excessive pessimism, or vice-versa. Greed and fear
are what move markets, at times, and technical analysis does a good
job of capturing the so-called 'sentiment'.
If that's not enough, technical analysis has
the backing of market theory as well. The theory? The market, involving
the dynamic interactions of myriad players, distills everything
there is to know. "The price contains all information,"
as Manish Shah, Technical Analyst at KRC Research, puts it.
The condition: this market must always have
diverse and numerous participants. So avoid illiquid stocks that
could be rigged by a few rogues. Insure yourself against false signals:
be discerning about what can and what cannot be manipulated.
|