Which way is the political wind blowing?
BT polled 50 CEOs across Delhi, Mumbai, Chennai, Kolkata, Bangalore,
and Hyderabad to get a drift. Sonia Gandhi ranked very low on corporate
India's list of desired Prime Minister, but incumbent Vajpayee had
a stiff contender in Jaswant Singh (L.K. Advani didn't have many
takers). As for the finance minister, Manmohan Singh got overwhelming
support, although P. Chidambaram came close. Shockingly enough,
only one CEO favoured Yashwant Sinha, although eight were willing
to see Arun Shourie become one.
1. Who do you think
is more pro-economy? |
Congress |
22 |
Neither |
4 |
BJP |
23 |
Both |
1 |
2. Who do you think is more
pro-industry? |
Congress |
21 |
Neither |
3 |
Can't say |
1 |
BJP |
24 |
Both |
1 |
|
|
3. Who is better at policy-making? |
Congress |
25 |
Equally good |
3 |
Can't say |
2 |
BJP |
19 |
|
|
Neither |
1 |
4. Who do you think will make
a better PM? |
A.B. Vajpayee |
12 |
P.V. Narasimha Rao |
10 |
Sonia Gandhi |
2 |
Manmohan Singh |
1 |
L.K. Advani |
8 |
None of the Above |
2 |
Jaswant Singh |
14 |
Can't Say |
1 |
5. Who do you think will make
a better FM? |
Yashwant Sinha |
1 |
Arun Shourie |
8 |
Manmohan Singh |
25 |
Arun Jaitley |
1 |
P. Chidambaram |
14 |
None of the Above |
1 |
6. Who evokes greater confidence
in investors (both portfolio and direct)? |
Congress |
36 |
BJP |
12 |
Neither |
2 |
7. Who is more stockmarket-friendly? |
BJP |
24 |
Both |
1 |
Congress |
21 |
Neither |
4 |
Figures indicate number of CEOs |
THE GROWTH SCENARIOS
Where does the economy go from here?
Theoretically, there are only three options. It can go up, down,
or stay where it is. BT explored how the economy will look under
each of these alternative scenarios.
BEST-CASE SCENARIO: This assumes a strong, business-oriented
government at the centre that is committed to implementing the second-generation
reforms. Economy, and not politics, occupies centre-stage.
GDP Growth: The Prime Minister's dream of a 9 per cent
growth comes true
Exports Growth: Clipping at 20 per cent, exports fetch
a tidy $55.2 billion
Fiscal Deficit: An austere administration lowers it to
3 per cent of GDP
Interest Rate: At 6 per cent, India Inc becomes globally
competitive
Revenue Deficit: The promised zero deficit is finally achieved
WORST-CASE SCENARIO: Assumes political chaos. Governance
is paralysed, demand flattens, investments have dried up, imports
kill local manufacturing, and a global slowdown shuts off India's
exports.
GDP Growth: India returns to the 80s Hindu rate of 3 and
4 per cent
Exports Growth: Instead of growing, exports have fallen
to $43 billion
Fiscal Deficit: Is running amok at 9 per cent of the GDP
Interest Rate: Has soared to a crippling 14 per cent, bleeding
bottomlines
Revenue Deficit: Has widened to 6 per cent, thanks to poor
tax collections
STATUS-QUO: Assumes that the economy stumbles along, demand
flip-flops, and the government is busy trying to stay in power,
rather than make industry-friendly policies.
GDP Growth: Miraculously, economy retains its 5.5 per cent
growth rate
Exports Growth: Aided by global recovery, moves at 9 per
cent
Fiscal Deficit: Despite rollbacks, the government reins
it in at 5.7 per cent of GDP
Interest Rate: Governor Bimal Jalan is happy to let it
prevail at 11 per cent.
Revenue Deficit: Widening of the tax net doesn't help and
it stays at 3 per cent
WHAT INDIA NEEDS TO DO TO IMPROVE
ITS RATINGS
Since 1998, when the BJP came to
power, India's credit rating has taken a beating because its fiscal
position has been going from bad to worse. After all, as Kristin
Lindow, lead analyst (India sovereign rating), Moody's points out:
''Rating agencies look not only at economic progress, but also the
fiscal position, since growth does not necessarily mean a happy
financial position.'' (Argentina and asean countries are prime examples.)
What does India need to do to go up the ratings ladder? Says Shelly
Shetty, Director (India Sovereign Ratings), Fitch Ratings: ''India's
progress on privatisation, fiscal restraint, and higher export growth
coupled with higher foreign direct investment inflows could help
improve efficiency and create sustainable growth, thereby supporting
creditworthiness of the country.'' But is India up to it? Not really,
Shelly believes that the Gujarat fallout already has had a negative
impact on the economy. And any failure to progress on economic reforms
and bring down the fiscal deficit will hold back economic growth
and increase government's indebtedness, potentially leading to a
downgrade.
THE WISH-LIST
» Go in for greater
privatisation
» Rein in its soaring
fiscal deficit by cutting government expenses
» Make foreign investment
more attractive
» Push for greater exports
» Expand tax net for greater
revenue collection
» Invest in social and
infrastructural sectors
1
2 3
|