Three
years ago, in February 2000, economist Surjit Bhalla, predicted
that the decade beginning 2010 would belong to India. Ha, said his
detractors, ''the man is an incurable optimist''. True enough, India's
growth in gross domestic product, flagged in 2001-02 and 2002-03.
Inadequate rains devastated the agricultural sector, an effect that
found an echo in an industrial sector already plagued by idle capacities.
In September 2003, Bhalla, the Managing Director
of Delhi-based Oxus Research and Investments articulated his opinion
again, this time encapsulated in a catchy slogan that looks better
coming from a politico than an economist. ''Asian Century, India's
Decade'' is Bhalla's choice of words to describe the dominant economic
trend of this, the 21st century. Only this time, the man's idea
about India becoming the fastest growing economy in the world by
2010, brighter, even than superstar-of-the-moment China, isn't being
met with ridicule.
Bhalla's prediction is based
on his theory that a one percentage point fall in real interest
rates (the interest rate less the inflation) translates into a 0.3
percentage point growth in GDP. A simple back-of-the-envelope calculation
shows that the 6 per cent fall in real interest rates over the last
two years, then, translates into a 1.8 per cent growth in the rate
at which the country's economy is growing. Between 1992 and 2002,
India's GDP grew at an average of 5.75 per cent. Add the increment
and the result is a more-than-respectable 7.55 per cent. And were
the government to push some critical reforms-Bhalla's hypothesis
is reforms-independent-the rate of growth could touch 8, even 9
per cent. At that rate of growth, India's per capita income would
double in 10 years.
This time around, Bhalla has support. Ashima
Goyal, a Professor at Mumbai's Indira Gandhi Institute of Developmental
Research (IGIDR) believes, simply, that India's time has come. The
growth rate of the economy, she reasons, was stuck at around 6 per
cent because of artificial factors, including US economic sanctions
against India following a nuclear weapons test in May 1998, the
earthquake in Gujarat, a mini-war in Kargil, stockmarket scams,
and a slowdown in the US economy.
THE INDIAN ECONOMY: 2010
|
GDP growth: |
7-9 %
|
Agricultural growth: |
3-3.5 %
|
Industrial growth: |
8-10 %
|
Services growth: |
8-10 %
|
Inflation rate: |
1-3 %
|
Export growth: |
10-15 %
|
Import growth: |
10-15 %
|
Rupee: |
Rs 45-50 a dollar
|
Source: Surjit Bhalla's predictions |
Facts suggest that the two economists are right.
India's literacy rate has improved dramatically, from 62 per cent
in 1997 to 65 per cent now. The proportion of the population aged
between 20 years and 59 years (the most productive age group from
an economic point of view), which has stayed steady at 35 per cent
since the 1980s is now inching up and is estimated to touch 47 per
cent by 2010, according to a study by the Asian Development Bank.
A research report issued by Goldman Sachs in early October says
pretty much the same thing as a basis for its theory that the Indian
economy will be growing faster than the Chinese one by 2010. ''...this
will be driven largely by the demographic dividend India is likely
to reap over the coming years with a sharp surge in its working-age
population.'' And Indian industry, as evident from its showing in
the last financial year and the first half of this, has learned
to live, even thrive, in a competitive global economic landscape.
It isn't that the Indian economy doesn't face
any threats (See 2010 Or Bust), but these seem insignificant compared
to those that ail others. China could soon face the double whammy
of rising wages (these are currently among the lowest in the world
and will have to, per force, increase) and an appreciating currency.
The yuan trades at 8.5 to the dollar, but this is a controlled exchange
rate. Were it to appreciate by 30-40 per cent, says Subhash Mittal,
the Vice President of the Federation of Indian Exporters Organisation,
''India can compete with China in textiles, engineering goods, handicrafts,
and steel.'' And China, reasons Subir Gokarn, the Chief Economist
at CRISIL, ''cannot move up the value chain'' like Japanese car
majors did when the yen appreciated in the mid-1990s because there
is little scope for doing so in toys, engineering goods, and textiles.
The US economy is yet to recover from 2000s
recession, the European Union will spend the next few years or more
integrating poorer European nations into its fold (and suffering
the temporary economic consequences), and most East Asian economies
revolve around exports to the US and the EU. 2010, here we come!
-Ashish Gupta
DARK
SIDE
2010
Or Bust
»
The growing divide between India's poorer northern states
and richer-by-the-minute southern ones could destabilise the economy
»
In the absence of agricultural reforms, one poor monsoon
is all it will take to affect a quarter of the Indian economy
»
India's fiscal deficit, unsustainably high at just less than
6 per cent of GDP, continues to remain a cause for concern
»
Labour reforms, such as an exit policy, are nowhere on the
horizon, and these are a must
»
India's power sector remains a mess with most reforms targeted
at the domain remaining still-born
»
An extended period of communal tensions could hamper economic
activity and put the Indian economy back on the 5 per cent plus
growth rate trajectory
-Ashish Gupta
IT's
Still Hot
India's software industry bounces back.
|
Infosys' Nandan Nilekani: There's reason
for the mile-wide smile |
No
one expected Infosys Technologies to announce that it would be a
billion-dollar company (in terms of revenues) by March 2004. The
company, if the opinions of a we-think-a-blip-is-a-downturn analysts
were to be believed, was going through hell and the sector, waking
up to the reality of declining profit margins and competition from
transnational information technology services firms. So, it sort
of surprised everyone when, in the course of declaring its results
for the July-September quarter, the company announced the billion-dollar
thingamajig Not too long after that Wipro announced its results;
the company's profit margins, which had declined for six quarters,
remained steady and it beat analyst estimates of a 9 per cent growth
in revenues over the previous quarter; it did 14 per cent.
In a conversation with analysts, Infosys CEO
Nandan Nilekani said the company wasn't scared of MNCs. If they
did not ramp up their operations quickly, he argued, it wouldn't
make a difference, and if they did, they would have to apportion
higher fixed costs over a lower revenue base.
Indian software services companies still aren't
winning the billion-dollar contracts analysts speak about but they
are showing significant gains in the business of infrastructure
management. HCL Technologies, for instance, has won a large infrastructure
management order from chip-major AMD; Wipro's infrastructure business
grew 34 per cent; and IDC estimates the size of this business at
$80 billion (Rs 3,62,400 crore)
The buzz in the industry is that customers
have more faith in the ability of Indian it services companies than
in those of transnationals. One analyst speaks of a huge General
Motors request for proposal (RFP) floating around in the Indian
market. The auto company spends over $4 billion (Rs 18,120 crore)
a year on it and EDs is its preferred vendor; but with the order
up for review soon, says the analyst, GM is looking at an Indian
alternative.
They may be immune to the transnational threat,
but India's software services biggies could face competition from
the likes of Symphony e-services and Hexaware that have set up contract
software product factories and charge around 10-15 per cent less
than the likes of Infosys. Indian it services, once again, is hot
and happening.
-Vidya Viswanathan
HUBRIS
Total Eclipse
|
The shining: Would it have gotten Indians
to stand up and be counted? |
Until
the election commission stepped in and played spoilsport, the Shining
India campaign sponsored by India's finance ministry, and created
by advertising agency Grey Worldwide was cutting a wide swath across
the collective consciousness of the country. Warm pictures of happy
middle-class families, contented pensioners, and beaming farmers
greeted Indians from the pages of mainstream dailies. ''We are basically
asking people to share in the optimism,'' says Prathap Suthan, Creative
Director, Grey, a logical extension of the agency's brief to communicate
India's new-found confidence. The ministry and the agency wouldn't
speak about the budget for the campaign, but Grey lets on that it
was asked to create 15 ads. Three was all it managed before the
Election Commission frowned on this exhibition of look-at-what-we-have-achieved
at a time when several states are going to the polls. If the sentiment
lasts, we'll have to wait till December to see the rest of the campaign.
-Ashish Gupta
|