|
Ajit Singh, Union Agriculture
Minister: At his Delhi residence, the minister scans the
sky for signs of rain
|
Just
how badly can one season of poor monsoon affect an economy $485-billion
big? Here's one extreme scenario: Political pressure forces the
government to waive off interest payment by farmers on borrowings
of approximately Rs 63,439 crore; instead of slashing agricultural
subsidies-currently at a budget estimate of Rs 39,801 crore for
2002-03-the government ups support; fiscal deficit zooms, the government
starts borrowing to pay its bills, jacking up the cost of capital
for private sector that, already buffeted by falling profit margins,
must now contend with vanishing consumers. Investments, both in
industry and stockmarkets, slow down. The upshot: An economy that
seems to be chugging to recovery, slumps back into coma.
That scenario may or may not play out. But
what's undeniable is the fact that from the farmers in Dharwad to
the punters on Dalal Street, all eyes are on the horizon, searching
for that elusive patch of grey, which will bring rain to the dry
fields of India and, in turn, the farmer his money and the marketer
his sale. When BT went to press, there were no signs of rain, prompting
Union Agriculture Minister Ajit Singh to declare that " if
the monsoons (did) not arrive by July 31, the country could well
have a major problem at hand".
THE
LAST DROUGHT
|
Nineteen eighty seven was the last time when
India faced an official drought, although an 'unofficial' drought
did hit the country in 2000, when just 66 CMS of rainfall was
received between June and September. The result: agricultural
production marginally declined, and the gross domestic product
(GDP) fell to 4 per cent from 6.4 per cent the previous year.
Sectors worst hit inlcuded the basic goods industry (steel and
aluminium) and consumer durables. Rajeev Karwal of Philips India
recalls that CTV sales plunged some 15 per cent in Maharashtra,
Madhya Pradesh and Orissa. The Associations Council of CII in
its study, which covered 119 manufacturing sectors and 10 services
sectors, stated that "the poor performance (of) agriculture
and the contraction in overall demand, (coupled) with a steep
decline in demand in the rural economy (have) stalled the progress
in dependent manufacturing sectors". It will be a miracle
if things end up differently this fiscal.does monsoon matter? |
A recent study by the Confederation of Indian
Industry corroborates Singh's fear. The food bowl areas of Uttar
Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh, Haryana and Punjab have had a shortfall
ranging from 49 per cent to 63 per cent. The considerable destruction
that a drought will wreak on crops of bajra, oilseeds, pulses and
paddy is only part of the story. Of bigger concern is this: The
rural market is estimated by some rural marketing companies to be
around Rs 50,000 crore for consumer non-durables, Rs 45,000 crore
for seeds, fertilisers, farm equipment and tractors, Rs 7,000 crore
to Rs 8,000 crore for consumer durables (including TVS, and refrigerators),
and another Rs 8,000 crore automobiles. Points out Sujay Mishra,
analyst, Kotak Securities: "Most of the rural demand comes
from the top 25 per cent of the large farmers."
If the crop fails, there may not be any significant
impact on the price of wheat (the country is sitting on a stock
of 60 million tonnes), but markets worth thousands of crores of
rupee could vanish. Says R.C. Jain Managing Director, Eicher Tractors:
"The direct impact will be on the disposable income of farmers.
So, even if a farmer decides to buy a tractor, he will first have
to get his margin money financed.''
That instead he may simply decide to postpone
purchase is already apparent. In the first quarter of current fiscal,
tractor sales were down 12 per cent. Jain reckons that in the whole
year, sales may not cross 2 lakh-that's 30,000 less than last year's.
Tractors may be an angry rain god's most direct victim, but there
are other industries in the path of his wrath: two-wheelers, textiles,
and consumer durables, for example.
While most big players like Hindustan Lever
(HLL) say it is too early to tell, Dalal Street is already jittery.
The 30-share index Sensex is wallowing at a nine-month low of 3,024.
Sure, a lot of it has to do with corporate America's accounting
scandals, but the fear of a drop in rural demand is also one of
the key factors. For instance, the HLL stock-a bellwether for the
FMCG sector-was off 27 per cent last fortnight from its 52-week
high of Rs 266.
There are no such victims yet in the two-wheeler
industry, but the tension is palpable. Nearly half of all two-wheelers
sold is in semi-urban and rural markets. Points out Atul Sobti,
Senior Vice President, Hero Honda: "A similar drought-like
condition two years ago plunged the two-wheeler industry into negative
growth." Hero Honda itself escaped the worst because there
was a shift happening from scooters and mopeds to motorcycles. But
this time around, Sobti says, the shift has stopped and any fall
in the purchasing power of rural consumers will severely impact
the industry.
DOES
MONSOON MATTER?
|
Here's a contrarian view. But first, the conventional
wisdom. one percentage point increase in agricultural production
translates into Rs 10,000 crore of additional income in the
hands of farmers and, sooner or later, in the hands of marketers.
Now the question: if, as the met department claims, India has
had 13 successive years of good monsoon, how come rural demand
hasn't gone through the roof? In fact, the tractor industry,
a ready measure of prosperity in rural India, has been witnessing
declining sales for the last three years. Contends Sujay Mishra,
analyst at Kotak Securities: "The beneficial impact of
the improvement in agricultural growth is only marginal to say
the least.'' In 1998, for instance, while agricultural growth
improved to 14.3 per cent (from 6.7 per cent in 1997), growth
for consumer companies fell to 13.8 per cent compared to 15.5
per cent in 1997. Point: the monsoon-growth equation may be
harder to crack than we think. |
Even softdrink and dairy products manufacturers
are dreading the long-term impact of blighted farms. Sanjiv Gupta,
Deputy Division President of Coca-Cola India, says that currently
sales are brisk because of the lack of rains, but warns that "if
agricultural income gets affected rural markets, even for colas,
will crater". Gujarat Cooperative Milk Marketing Federation
(GCMMF) is keeping a wary eye on the horizon, too. No rains will
mean no fodder for milch animals and, consequently, lower milk production
and a spurt in prices of dairy products. "We are expecting
a 15 per cent growth this fiscal, but that will be difficult to
achieve if the monsoon is delayed," says R.S. Sodhi, General
Manager (Marketing), GCMMF.
It's not just domestic markets, but exports
too that seem set to take a hit. Take the case of textiles. Home-grown
cotton is more than 10 per cent cheaper than the imported variety.
But with Gujarat, Maharashtra, Karnataka and Andhra Pradesh-principal
cotton-growing areas-still waiting for rains, cotton production
is likely to fall to 140 lakh bales compared to 156 lakh bales last
year. Says S.P. Oswal, Chairman, Vardhman Spinning Mills: "Meeting
the $13 billion (textiles) export target won't be difficult, but
increased cotton prices will put our margins under tremendous pressure."
THE CONTRARIANS
Interestingly enough, not everybody is worried
about the monsoon. The most notable optimist: the consumer durables
sector. Venugopal Dhoot, Managing Director of Videocon International,
believes that the monsoon scare has been blown out of proportion.
His company, he says, is not experiencing any slowdown in sales
of CTVs, and for the whole of this fiscal, there may actually be
a 15 to 20 per cent growth in sales.
Rajeev Karwal, Senior Vice President, Philips
India, agrees with Dhoot. His reasoning: The affected northern states
account for only a quarter of all CTV sales. Moreover, Karwal's
argument goes, with the festival season round the corner and the
cricket World Cup due in 2003, television manufacturers have little
cause for concern.
Even on edgy Dalal Street, there are some brave
analysts who believe that monsoon is not a big issue as of now,
especially since there are no obvious signs of a slowdown. Says
Navin Aggarwal, Head of Institutional Research, Motilal Oswal Securities:
"The forecast of a sharp fall in agricutural growth and consequently
industrial demand is based more on the prevailing pessimism than
hard facts."
Aggarwal's isn't the lone dissenting voice.
There are others who believe that the direct link between agricultural
growth and rising industrial demand is fast weakening. As evidence,
they point to the fact that while agricultural growth in 1996 was
negative, tractors, motorcycles, and fertilisers did well.
But this anomaly is easily explained. First,
due to a lag effect, the impact of poor agricultural growth was
felt only a year later in 1997. Also, as the services and industrial
sectors were booming, a large part of the shortfall was absorbed.
This time around, agriculture could take a bigger hit, and its impact
on the economy could be severe. Says a senior executive in a Delhi-based
multinational: "If the festival season brings no spend in rural
India, the people who today are sneezing at this problem, will find
their jaw fall off."
Also, let us not forget that last year, when
industrial growth sank, it was agriculture's robust 7.4 per cent
growth that kept the GDP from falling below the 5 per cent mark.
Therefore, unless industry and services grow fast enough to neutralise
the dip in agriculture, the GDP growth will necessarily decelerate.
And that could well mean a relapse into the 80s' lacklustre 'Hindu'
rate of growth.
|