|
Name: Mohit Kataria
(left) and Gururaj Potnis
School: IIM Calcutta
Year of Graduation: 2003
Business venture: Manthan Services (KPO)
HQ: Bangalore, Karnataka |
They didn't bag
the highest dollar-offers this placement season, yet Satyajit
Sadanand, a student of IIM-L who decided to go back home to Baroda
and turn his football club, Providence, into what accountants
would call a going concern, and Sarath Babu, a student of IIM-A
who turned down an offer from a software company and the annual
salary of Rs 8.5 lakh that went with it to start a catering business
(including a canteen on campus), have made more headlines (and
inside pages) than those that did. The phenomenon of IIM grads
jumping onto the entrepreneurial bandwagon shouldn't surprise
anyone. India is a nation of entrepreneurs, and the IIMs, goes
one school of thought, prepare an individual to be an entrepreneur
(another school of thought says that all they do is to give people
enough perspective to be independent directors on the boards of
companies). Yet, it isn't easy to opt out of the placements process,
and just-shy-of-seven-figures Indian salaries or six-figure dollar
ones. "Very few students want to take risks at the beginning
of their career and we teach them to go and learn the business
in some established set-up before becoming entrepreneurs,"
says Sushil Kumar, a professor of Agri-business at IIM-L, explaining
why few students opt to be entrepreneurs.
THE ROAD LESS TRAVELLED |
»
India has changed: starting-up is no longer considered
infra dig
» The
IIMs have changed: most run programmes on entrepreneurship
» The
students have changed: their aspirations can't be met by regular
jobs
» The
environment has changed: venture capital, even risk capital,
is available
» Mindsets
towards failure have changed: India Inc. has no problems hiring
failed entrepreneurs |
Deciding To Jump In
The IIMs, everyone knows, do not create entrepreneurs.
No one minds (except the schools themselves on occasion; for instance,
to redress this seeming lacuna, IIM-B founded a Centre of Entrepreneurship
which was funded by Infosys' former Joint Managing Director N.S.
Raghavan) because they create fine managers, probably the best
of their kind in India. Most people who become entrepreneurs soon
after finishing the two-year course at the IIMs were probably
keen on doing so even before they secured admission to the schools.
For instance, Mohit Kataria and Gururaj Potnis of IIM-C's Class
of 2003-the duo co-founded Manthan Services, a KPO or knowledge
process outsourcing firm-were keen on "doing something of
their own" even when they were students at the Indian Institute
of Technology, Delhi. "The atmosphere at IIT was very entrepreneurial,"
recalls Potnis, "but I did not have the skill sets to start
an enterprise." Both made it to IIM-C, and revived their
plans, but by the end of 2002 (during which they had prospected
in Delhi and Bangalore), were no clearer. "We decided to
play it safe and sit for placements," admits Potnis. They
didn't: in early 2003, they met with brothers Anshuman and Rishi
Das, IIT, Delhi and Rourkee alumni, respectively, and founded
Erasmic Consulting, an 'in-sourcing' firm that helps multinationals
put down offshore centres in India. The duo moved out six months
later to found Manthan.
|
|
Name: Vardan and
Ankita Kabra
School: IIM Ahmedabad
Year of Graduation: 2004
Business venture: Fountainhead (a pre-school)
HQ: Surat, Gujarat |
Name: Abhijit
Chaudhuri
School: IIM Lucknow
Year of Graduation: 2003
Business venture:
GATE Forum (a coaching institute)
HQ: Bangalore, Karnataka |
The story of Vardan Kabra is not very different.
The Class of 2004 student from IIM-A was certain that he wanted
to do his own thing when he was a student at IIT, Bombay. "I
realised that I lacked business acumen," he says, proffering
a reason for his decision to opt for a PGDBM from IIM-A. Kabra
and his wife Ankita, also a student of IIM-A's Class of 2004,
run a pre-school in Surat. Indeed, it would appear that entrepreneurs
are wired differently: Abhijit Chaudhuri, a Class of 2003 student
from IIM-L, insists that even when he was a young boy, "I
wanted to do something different." "I would often discuss
becoming an entrepreneur (when I was at Ranchi's National Institute
of Foundry and Forge Technology)," he adds. Chaudhuri runs
gate Forum, a company that helps students prepare for the Graduate
Aptitude Test in Engineering (for admission to post graduate programmes
at the IITs).
Every year, at the better business schools
in the country, the graduating batch boasts several individuals
who have entrepreneurial dreams. "There were 11 of us,"
recalls Ankita Kabra, of the informal group that would meet and
discuss how they would become entrepreneurs after completing the
course, "and our ideas ranged from launching a bookstore
to starting an educational institution to even venturing into
distribution". By February of 2004, though, placement season
at IIM-A, things had changed. "Our group of 11 was down to
three," says Arvind Kumar, also from the Class of 2004 at
IIM-A (Kumar runs a small packaging firm called Easypack Solutions
near Mumbai).
|
Name: Vikash Choraria
School: IIM Lucknow
Year of Graduation: 2005
Business venture: Value King (a distribution venture)
HQ: Kolkata, West Bengal |
What's The Big Idea?
Potnis and Kataria are in the fairly-established
(and lucrative) area of KPO. "We aim to be market leaders
in the legal outsourcing space," says Kataria, who claims
Manthan, which started with a team of 25, now employs 250. That
can be said of several other entrepreneurs from the IIMs as well.
However, a significant number do opt to try something new or unexpected
(at least for someone from an IIM). Chaudhuri's gate Forum is
the first of its kind; "We are India's only firm offering
this kind of preparatory tools for gate aspirants," says
Chaudhuri. One wouldn't expect to find a pre-school being run
by a couple of IIM-A grads, although it must be said that the
Kabras, who are working towards launching a primary school, may
be onto a good thing. "There is a lot of potential in the
education space in cities such as Surat and we want to tap it,"
says Kabra. Nor would one expect to find an IIM-L graduate running
a distribution venture. Vikash Choraria, from the Class of 2005,
does just that with Value King, a company that seeks to deliver
products (all kinds from perishables to personal care products
to consumer durables) and services (think dry-cleaning, travel
assistance, even car-washes) at the doorstep of customers, and
at prices that are lower than prevailing market ones.
|
Name: Arvind Kumar
School: IIM Ahmedabad
Year of Graduation: 2004
Business venture: Easypack Solutions (a packaging firm)
HQ: Vasai (near Mumbai), Maharashtra |
If one were to look at these ventures objectively
(this is, after all, a business magazine), some look good, others
reasonably good, and not-so-scalable, and still others... (well,
let's leave it at that, shall we?). Arvind Kumar says he hit upon
the packaging idea in desperation as he was "running out
of time". "My margins are high," he adds, but admits
that "I use pretty elementary technology and can, therefore,
operate only at the local level." It is likely that some
of the ventures featured on these pages will fold up, as indeed
most first entrepreneurial initiatives do. The very fact that
they have been through an IIM, however, gives these entrepreneurs
a safety net; industry should snap them up, failed attempt at
being an entrepreneur and all (some companies may actually consider
this experience worth paying a premium for). At the peak of the
dotcom boom, Lokendra Tomar, a Class of 2000 student from IIM-L
founded coolavenues.com, a community site targeted at B-school
students and aspirant-MBAs. It floundered but had managed to survive,
building a significant brand salience among MBAs. Tomar, however,
had no difficulty in finding a job and is currently Vice President
(Delivery Knowledge Services), Integreon. Says Santrupt Mishra,
VP, Aditya Birla Group, "As long as one can justify his decision
first not to partake in the placement process and then wrap his
enterprise up and take up a full-time job, any employer would
be happy to have him on board." That's the beauty of being
an IIM-entrepreneur. Even if your company doesn't really take
off, you end up a winner. Twice over.
|