INDIA'S TOP
FUND MANAGERS |
EQUITY
FUNDS
Reliance Mutual Fund
Kunj Bansal
HDFC Mutual Fund
Prashant Jain
Templeton Mutual Fund
R. Sukumar
INCOME FUNDS
Sundaram Mutual Fund
Anand Radhakrishnan
Birla Sun Life Mutual Fund
K. Ramanathan
IL&FS Mutual Fund
Dheeraj Singh
GILT FUNDS
IL&FS Mutual Fund
Dheeraj Singh
Birla Sun Life Mutual Fund
Navneet Munot
Templeton Mutual Fund
Sameer Kulkarni
LIQUID FUNDS
Alliance Capital Mutual
Fund
Amitabh Mohanty
IL&FS Mutual Fund
Dheeraj Singh
Templeton Mutual Fund
Nilesh Shah |
|
Stability could well be their common
middle name. the 10 fund managers listed in the pages that follow-India's
best, according to a numbers-plus exercise carried out by Business
Today and Mutualfundsindia.com, a Mumbai-based agency that is now
part of ICRA Online-are the very definition of the term stable.
They are, without exception, bright: several are from one Indian
Institute of Management (IIM) or another, and one topped the Chartered
Accountant (CA) exams. They read serious stuff: Eliyahu Goldratt,
Spencer Johnson, K.M. Munshi and the like. They are into serious
pastimes: Hindustani classical music, philosophy, religion, psychology,
and yoga. And best of all, most of their own investments are through
mutual funds-often, the very ones they manage. That augurs well
for investors.
Size Doesn't Matter
Kunj Bansal,
36, Equity Fund Manager, Reliance Mutual Fund (Reliance Capital
Asset Management)
A continuing d-street myth concerns
the ability of only very small funds to generate superior returns.
Their nimbleness, goes conventional logic, makes it easy for them
to take positions (or exit them) to optimal benefit. With combined
assets of around Rs 1,400 crore under his management, Kunj Bansal
has shattered that myth.
The funds he manages have consistently delivered above-average,
often good, returns to investors. This, despite his aggressive fund-management
style. After all, Reliance's strategy, as articulated by the company
is to reshuffle the portfolio "based on industry- and company-specific
developments". So, despite the two funds he manages being largely
comprised of 'quality' stocks, Bansal has churned their portfolios
and how. For instance, in March 2004, the exposure of Reliance Vision
to the banking sector grew from 2 per cent to 6 per cent (it continued
to climb and reached 10 per cent by the end of April). Both portfolios
also boast significant exposure to mid-cap stocks. This bias has
helped them deliver high returns in the past 12 months. Then, the
eight-year veteran of the fund management business (the management
graduate was Assistant General Manager at UTI before he signed on
with Reliance) has always been an aggressive fund manager.
-Narendra Nathan
Karma On The Street
Prashant Jain,
36, Fund Manager, Equities, HDFC Mutual Fund (HDFC Asset Management
Company)
If there is a perfect antithesis
to the greed-is-good Gordon Gekko image of a market player, it has
to be Prashant Jain, an IIT Kanpur, IIM-Bangalore alum who manages
six equity-focussed mutual funds at HDFC Mutual Fund. The man, you
see, is a believer in the concept of karma, a tenet of Hinduism
that states that an individual's future, in this birth, and in future
ones, is a function of his or her actions. That could explain Jain's
admission that his primary objectives are to fulfill his responsibilities
towards work, family, and, sometime in the future, society as a
whole. And it can explain his deliberate approach to investing.
Jain has had plenty of time to hone his fund management skills:
he spent two years with SBI Mutual Fund and 10 at Zurich India Mutual
Fund (where he eventually became Chief Investment Officer).
Jain's investment strategy revolves around buying into companies
whose business he understands and which, in his opinion, boast sustainable
business models and a few competitive advantages to boot. His time
horizon is almost always medium- to long-term and emphasis on risk
control. "This (risk control) reduces the impact of wrong decisions
and can be achieved by effective diversification and by sticking
to well managed companies," he explains. Does this work? Well,
Jain made a killing by buying software stocks in 1995 and 1996 and
selling them in 2000. "There have been other individual stocks
that have turned out to be multi-baggers (read: appreciated a few
times over), but in my opinion, these two decisions had the maximum
impact on fund performance," he says. Jain's own investments
are largely in mutual funds, although a small portion goes into
direct equity, and he likes to listen to music, travel, read up
on religion, and practice yoga. "Right now, work and family
leave little time for these," he smiles. "But I believe
that a stage in life will come when I will have more time to pursue
these."
-Shilpa Nayak
Surf's
Up
Sameer Kulkarni,
35, Vice President & Head, Fixed Income, Templeton Mutual Fund (Franklin
Templeton India)
It shouldn't surprise anyone that
a man whose bible is Dr. Spencer Johnson's Who Moved My Cheese?
Lists the ability to change as the most important factor for personal
or professional success. "If you do not change, you become extinct,"
says Sameer Kulkarni, who likes to offer the metaphor of surfing
to describe his job: You find the optimal wave and stay away from
those that are too strong or too weak. That and the ability to minimise
liquidity-interest rate-and credit-risk, reckons Kulkarni, are the
keys to managing a debt fund successfully. When he wants to get
away from it all, this fund manager-he also likes the works of John
Maynard Keynes and Eliyahu Goldratt-likes to listen to Hindustani
classical music. And no, he doesn't surf.
-Priyanka Sangani
Tugga-clone
Amitabh Mohanty,
32, Vice President (Fixed Income) Alliance Mutual Fund (Alliance
Capital India)
It seems somehow apt that a manager
of debt funds-Amitabh Mohanty oversees all the debt funds and the
debt portion of balanced funds of Alliance, apart from directly
managing Alliance Cash Manager, the company's flagship liquid scheme-be
an ardent follower of Steve 'Tugga' Waugh, the former captain of
the Australian cricket team and a man renowned for his sheer grit
and resilience. "Safety and liquidity are paramount in a liquid
fund and we will not compromise this for a few more basis points,"
says the Indian Institute of Management, Ahmedabad alum. To ensure
that his debt funds generate higher returns (than its peers and
competing investment options such as fixed deposits) Mohanty has
always focused on what he calls emerging opportunities. Floating
rate bonds are one such. These are linked to the Mumbai Inter Bank
Offer Rate (MIBOR), and the interest rate risk they carry is zero.
"We are pioneers in using floating rate bonds and have been doing
so for the past two to three years," says Mohanty. Even better,
such bonds are highly liquid. That could explain why Mohanty parks
25-30 per cent of the assets under his management in them.
-Narendra Nathan
Soros,
Buffet, Gross, And Dare We Suggest, Munot?
Navneet Munot,
33, Fund Manager, Gilt Funds, Birla Sun Life Mutual Fund (Birla
Sun Life Asset Management Company)
The mere fact that Navneet Munot,
a chartered accountant who signed on with the Aditya Birla group
soon after clearing his qualifying exam, lists George Soros, Warren
Buffet, and legendary bond manager Bill Gross among his role models,
should please investors. So should his analysis-heavy approach:
to maximise risk-adjusted returns for the funds he manages, Munot
uses a method that, at once, looks at the relative valuation of
the yield curve, and his own view on interest rates formed by studying
macro-economic fundamentals. "It is necessary to get the big
picture right, yet have a passion for details," he says.
In many ways, Munot is a complete fund manager: apart from studying
the methods of his role models, he studies psychology (can't do
without it in the money management business, is his verdict), is
extremely disciplined, and keeps his eyes and ears open at all times.
"There is an immense sense of trusteeship that is necessary
in this business as someone else's money is at stake," says
Munot. Expectedly, the man who reads books on history, philosophy,
and yoga when he gets the time, is a long-term player, whose own
investments go into equity (a long-term play) and debt funds in
a proportion that he periodically alters. That's scientific.
-Shilpa Nayak
A
Percentage Play
Anand Radhakrishnan,
35, Fund Manager (Fixed Income), Sundaram Mutual Fund (Sundaram
Asset Management Company)
The key to managing a debt portfolio
in a situation where interest rate volatility is high is to simply
understand where they are headed. "The starting point is to have
a view on the interest rate structure," says Anand Radhakrishnan,
an iim, Ahmedabad alum who directly manages Sundaram Bond Saver,
and who is responsible for all other debt funds and the debt component
of balanced funds and Monthly Income Plans (MIPs). This, Radhakrishnan
manages with the assistance of an in-house model that incorporates
nine variables including money supply, inflation, industrial production
and, the interest rate in the US. He compares this with the shape
(flat or steep) of the yield curve before making a decision. "As
the yield curve is flat right now, we are more into medium- and
short-term papers," says Radhakrishnan. The fund manager may be
an ardent follower of the 'safety first' approach, characteristic
of the corporate policy of the TVS Group of which Sundaram is a
part), but he doesn't miss opportunities to earn that bit more by
taking calculated risks on rating upgrades. Radhakrishnan bets on
quality companies (such as IPCL, Ashok Leyland, or Indian Hotels),
whose debt is rated below AAA (highest safety). There's little chance
of a rating downgrade in such cases, but a fair chance of an upgrade.
"In India, it takes a long time for actual market conditions to
be reflected in the rating, and a smart fund manager should be able
to use this (to his advantage)," says Radhakrishnan. He or she should.
-Narendra Nathan
Life
After Super-returns
K. Ramanathan,
32, Fund Manager, Income Fund, Birla Sun Life Mutual Fund (Birla
Sun Life Asset Management Co.)
Like most debt fund managers who
rode a falling interest rate regime to register some stunning returns
for investors, K. Ramanathan begins most conversations these days
by stating that the best is over. "Over the past three years,
fixed income funds generated some of the most attractive returns
ever," he says, "but investors should not expect such
super-normal returns from debt in the future." The engineer-MBA
from Regional Engineering College, Suratkal, and Mumbai's S.P. Jain
Institute of Management & Research should know: he has lived
through the volatile debt markets of the past five years-he joined
the Aditya Birla Group in 1998-and witnessed the Asian crisis, 9-11
and the events that followed, and free falling interest rates. "It
has been a great learning experience for debt market operators,"
he says.
Ramanathan, who loves travelling (he loved New Zealand and claims
"the serenity of the place was a contrast to the otherwise
stressful lives we lead") believes it is only a matter of time
before interest rates bottom out and sees this posing the biggest
hurdle between funds like the ones he manages and reasonable returns.
His take: investors should not expect more than a 5.5 per cent annualised
return on income funds. So, what's the smart income fund manager
doing? Building aggressive portfolios and looking at longer maturity
periods. The excess liquidity in the market, explains Ramanathan
(companies aren't borrowing much and foreign debt is still less
expensive than that of the domestic variety) bodes well for the
bond markets. Paradoxical as this may sound, Ramanathan believes
this is the time to invest in equities: almost 70 per cent of his
investments are in equity funds. That's where your investments should
go, Constant Reader, unless you happen to be risk averse. In that
case, your money is safe with Mr. Ramanathan.
-Shilpa Nayak
Return To Forever
Nilesh Shah,
36, Former Director & CIO (Fixed Income), Templeton Mutual Fund
(Franklin Templeton India)
Nilesh
shah may be between jobs-he recently quit Templeton and is yet to
join Prudential ICICI Asset Management Company-but the whiz-kid
who came first in the qualifying exam to become a chartered accountant
(ca) in 1991 is a shoo-in as far as this listing is concerned purely
on the strength of his performance managing the liquid funds at
Templeton. "SLRs are important," says Shah, who, legend
has it, never allowed the Net Asset Value of any fund he managed
to fall, not even for a day. "First Safety, then Liquidity,
and last, Return." Then, there are the details. Most investors
in liquid funds exit in March (due to year-end considerations),
and return in April. Shah, accordingly, built portfolios with "papers
that matured in March".
In one way, Shah's move to Prudential ICICI is a homecoming of
sorts. The avid reader who nurtures his Gujarati provenance-his
favourite authors are K.M. Munshi and Uma Shankar Joshi-joined Templeton
to manage fixed income funds in 1997, but rose to become the Chief
Investment Officer for both equity and debt by 2000. The merger
with Pioneer saw him becoming CIO (Fixed Income) of the merged entity
but at Prudential ICICI his new designation reads CIO (Equity and
Debt). At Templeton, he managed Rs 13,000 crore; at Prudential ICICI,
he will Rs 15,000 crore. Not surprisingly, then, Shah is using the
time at hand to develop a strategy for equity as well. "I have
done this earlier and what is needed is just some brushing up,"
he smiles.
-Narendra Nathan
Work
And Work Alone
Dheeraj Singh,
35, Fund Manager, Income Segment, IL&FS Mutual Fund (IL&FS Asset
Management Company)
It's not really possible to take
a break because of the hectic work schedule." That's Dheeraj
Singh for you-a mechanical engineer with a post-graduate diploma
in management from IIM-Bangalore who is as serious-minded as serious-minded
can be. For over 11 years, Singh has managed fixed income funds
at JM Financial, Escorts, and now at IL&FS. And he has developed
an investment approach all his own. Non-aggression is one element
of this; the fund manager prefers to stick to tried and tested securities
with AA ratings (this signifies a high degree of safety) rather
than try something adventurous. Liquidity is another. Some fund
managers believe an income fund should be highly liquid to meet
redemption pressure. Not Singh. "The liquidity bit is important
to be able to have a nimble portfolio," he says, referring
to the fact that a highly liquid fund should be able to churn securities
to its advantage. With a change in the interest rate regime unlikely-"A
secular change is way off as there is a lot of liquidity in the
system," explains Singh-this fund manager's work looks cut
out. Thrills? That will have to come from the thrillers he is so
fond of and the happenings in the equity market: all his investments
are in equity funds.
-Shilpa Nayak
Rational Exuberance
Sukumar Rajah,
39, Director And Chief Investment Officer (Equity), Templeton Mutual
Fund (Franklin Templeton India)
Few equity fund managers in India
enjoy as much recognition as Sukumar Rajah. That shouldn't surprise
anyone. At ITI Pioneer, and at Templeton (the former merged into
the latter in 2002), the Indian Institute of Management, Bangalore
alumnus has managed some of India's best-known and best-performing
funds such as Franklin India Prima Plus, Franklin Infotech Fund,
Franklin Pharma Fund, and Franklin India Tax Shield. The man himself
ascribes much of this to two things. A simple Thomas Carlyle tenet
he follows: Conviction is worthless if it is not converted into
conduct. And the belief that the key to successful portfolio management
is a level head, the ability to step back from the market, and the
even rarer ability to make rational decisions. "Markets often throw
up surprises and investing is a continuous learning process," says
Sukumar, "but what is important is not to concentrate on one or
two stocks, but to build a diverse, solid portfolio that will outperform
market cycles." And so, the man who swears by Peter Lynch's One
Up On Wall Street: How To Use What You Already Know To Make Money
In The Market, and Robert G. Hagstrom's The Warren Buffet Way, ensures
that his fund managers understand an issue, find out what the right
thing to do is, and then actually do it-something that he claims
makes Templeton different from the rest.
-Priyanka Sangani
The
Methodology |
In March, business today commissioned
mutualfundsindia.com, an arm of ICRA Online, and the magazine's
partner in presenting monthly and quarterly mutual fund updates,
to arrive at a listing of India's best fund managers. Fund
managers were to be ranked across four categories: equity,
income, liquid, and gilt.
Equity: Includes diversified equity schemes, equity-linked
saving schemes and sectoral schemes.
Income: Includes both short-term and long-term income
schemes
Liquid: Includes all liquid schemes
Gilt: Includes both short-term and long-term gilt
schemes
Monthly income plans (MIPs), index schemes and balanced
schemes were not considered. Most fund houses put two people
in charge of these schemes who handle the debt and equity
parts independently and this makes it difficult to pinpoint
who did a better job. Index schemes were also not considered
as they tend to replicate the performance of a particular
index and do not require fund management skills.
Eligibility criteria were applied at two levels. At the
first level, a fund house was considered eligible for ranking
under a particular category only if it had assets under management
that were at least 1 per cent of the total assets under management
of all eligible schemes in the category. At the second level,
a scheme was considered eligible if it was open-ended, declared
its NAV daily, and had completed a minimum of three years
of existence for equity schemes, two years for long term income
and gilt schemes and one year in case of liquid and short
term income and gilt schemes.
Risk Adjusted Return (SORTINO Equivalent): For equity,
income and gilt schemes, the risk adjusted return was calculated
as the risk premium (return in excess of peer group average)
divided by the downward standard deviation. The idea behind
using peer group average was to ensure that the schemes that
delivered below-average returns at a very less risk did not
end up scoring high on risk adjusted return scale.
In the case of liquid schemes, the magnitude of downward
deviations of the schemes' returns from the average call rate
for 2003-04 was used.
Once the risk adjusted return/downward deviation was calculated
for all the schemes in the category, the appropriate weights
were assigned to each. The weightages for each sub-category
were decided on the basis of the total industry 'assets under
management break up' between these sub-categories. If there
was more than one scheme in the same sub-category, the weightage
was assigned on the basis of the fund size of the schemes.
Thus the scheme having higher fund size got a higher weightage
compared to scheme with lower fund size.
On the basis of this methodology, the three top managers
in the four categories were identified (See India's Top Fund
Managers). Since IL&FS' Dheeraj Singh is present in three
categories, the number of fund managers profiled comes down
to 10. As Templeton has several schemes (managed by several
fund managers), we have featured the fund's CIO R. Sukumar.
|
|